Lynerit 2023-08-07

6.14 submit - Submitted on June 14th
7.06 revision (20 days to revise) - Revision requested on July 6th (20 days given to revise)
7.19 revision submitted - Revision submitted on July 19th
8.05 review complete - Review completed on August 5th
8.07 accept - Accepted on August 7th

Nyctos 2023-07-28

4.13 Submit
4.17 With editor
4.18 Under review
5.14 Review Complete (20 days to revise)
6.2 Revision submitted to journal
6.19 Review Complete (20 days to revise)
6.26 Revision submitted to journal
7.3 Review Complete
7.9 Accept

Translation:

4.13 Submit
4.17 With editor
4.18 Under review
5.14 Review Complete (20 days to revise)
6.2 Revision submitted to journal
6.19 Review Complete (20 days to revise)
6.26 Revision submitted to journal
7.3 Review Complete
7.9 Accept

EYE TO EYE 2023-07-28

The editing speed is very fast, but the reviewers are relatively slow. Three revisions were given in total, but overall it is still good.

lilili666 2023-07-14

Hello, I would like to ask if this journal manuscript cannot exceed 5000 words? Does this include the word count of the references?

kzhe 2023-07-12

Pure theoretical calculations, from submission to final rejection, went through three rounds of revisions and four reviewers. The rejection was due to one reviewer constantly questioning the material's stability. In reality, another reviewer also raised concerns about stability, but agreed to accept the paper after we provided relevant data. It was very unfriendly and the review process was slow.

SAT 2023-06-29

Although two reviewers were positive about the results and requested a revision, the editor refused it and instead allowed for the article to be transferred. It is difficult to comprehend this decision. However, I am going to submit a rebuttal against their decision and hope for the best. Editors can be peculiar.

advanced soft materials 2023-06-29

I also encountered the same situation. Is there any expert who can answer?

SAT 2023-06-28

Yes, if the Required reviews completed status turned to Decision in process, it generally indicates that the item or request has been rejected.

伊芙利特之际 2023-06-24

Hello, what does "Decision in Process" mean? Has there been any result? I've been in the same situation for many days.

Xujie23 2023-06-12

4.24 Submission, sent to the editor and under review on the same day.
5.8 Received feedback, requiring minor and major revisions. The editor allowed twenty days for the revisions.
5.17 Returned the revised manuscript and it was accepted on 6.1.
The journal has a high efficiency, and the reviewers are quite professional. It received positive reviews.

Melex 2023-06-06

May I ask if all the chief editors encourage authors to provide their photos and covers in the feedback for revision?

塔塔1202 2023-05-18

Excuse me, has anyone delivered it to Deputy Editor Cao Xia? How is the processing speed?

小张想发TOP 2023-05-07

Does changing from "with editor" to "progress in decision" mean that it will be rejected?

小张想发TOP 2023-05-07

Have you experienced progress in the decision-making process, dear OP? Before submitting it for approval.

taotaoZ 2023-04-03

Feb 16, 2023 - Submitted to the journal
Feb 16, 2023 - Editor invited
Feb 18, 2023 - With Editor
Feb 18, 2023 - Under review
Feb 19, 2023 - Under review
Mar 3, 2023 - Required Reviews Completed
Mar 4, 2023 - Revise
Mar 21, 2023 - Revision Submitted to Journal
Mar 22, 2023 - Editor invited
Mar 22, 2023 - Under Review
Apr 2, 2023 - Required Reviews Completed
Apr 2, 2023 - Accept

luvkve 2023-03-04

2022.02.10 submit
2022.02.11 with editor
2022.02.11 editor invited
2022.02.16 with editor
2022.02.28 reject

Rejection letter: We only accept 15% of Nanoenergy, we cannot afford to wait for graduates, Swedish people are too slow.

世上只有一个威威 2023-02-26

Will the impact factor continue to rise?

luvkve 2023-02-23

It has been eight days and there is still no movement, how can we find out who the assigned associate editor is?

xfzhang96 2022-12-11

From submission to the editor's hands, it takes 3-5 days, and sometimes even just one day if it's fast. It usually takes about a week for the editor to make a decision on whether to send it for review.

Missy z 2022-12-08

Hello, may I ask how long it takes for Editor Invited to change to the next status after you submit the contribution?

Jackie 2022-12-02

I remember it was about two weeks or so. After I submitted it, it first went through the "with editor" status, and then it changed to "editor invited" status. After two weeks, the editor finally took over and sent it for review. At that time, it took another two weeks for the first review to be completed and accepted.

xfzhang96 2022-11-22

The editor is very nice, and the speed is also very fast.

天地一沙鸥-ZZZ 2022-11-18

Hello, I wanted to ask how long you took at the "Editor Invited" step. After I was matched with an editor, it changed to "Editor Invited," but it has been seven days already without any updates.

Jackie 2022-11-18

I will share my submission process with everyone, hoping it will be helpful. After submitting on August 31, 2022, the editor was assigned. It remained in the "with editor" status until September 18. The editor sent it for review on October 3, and the first reviewer completed their review. On October 10, the editor provided 20 days for minor revisions. After receiving the first reviewer's response on October 30, the article was sent to two reviewers who completed their reviews on November 4. From then until 7:30 PM on November 18, it remained in the "review complete" status. Around 9 PM on November 18, the editor sent an email to receive it. Throughout the entire process, the reviewers were fast and friendly, while the editor may have been busy and took a longer time. I hope this information is useful for everyone!

让我发个大子刊吧 2022-11-02

Haha, just got rejected.

Charming666 2022-11-02

Hello, based on my experience, the first review was quick, and the article was generally assigned to an editor for review. The second review took a bit longer. This greatly depends on the editor. Sometimes, if the editor is busy and unable to read the article, the process may slow down. Generally, a decision can be made within one to two weeks after reading the comments. At the latest, it may take a month. Please be patient and good luck~

让我发个大子刊吧 2022-11-02

Congratulations! My submission was assigned to Professor Dai Liming on the second day, and it has been with the editor ever since. It has been a week already. How long does it usually take to consider whether to send it for review or reject it?

Charming666 2022-10-31

October 29th, receiving.

rhylongbai 2022-10-30

2022.4.21 Submitted
2022.4.22 Under review
2022.5.3 Under review, time changed once
I have reminded the editor several times during the process, but no one responded. After contacting the journal manager, the editor replied that one of the reviewers had not responded, and on 9.8, they re-invited a reviewer.
2022.9.16 First review comments received, with a few experimental and mechanistic issues raised.
2022.9.30 Revision submitted.
2022.10.4 Under review
2022.10.8 Under review, time changed once, one reviewer submitted comments.
2022.10.26 Second review received, one acceptance and one requesting citation of three of their own articles.
2022.10.27 Revised.
2022.10.29 Editor agreed to accept.

Overall, the process took over half a year. If I hadn't reminded them several times, it would probably have taken more than a year. I will be more cautious in future submissions.

rhylongbai 2022-10-18

2022.4.21 Submission
2022.4.22 Under review
2022.5.3 Under review, time changed once
Midway, I have urged the editor several times, but no one responded. After contacting the journal manager, the editor replied that one of the reviewers had not responded, and then on 9.8, they invited another reviewer.
2022.9.16 First round of comments received, with several experimental and mechanistic issues raised.
2022.9.30 Revision
2022.10.4 Under review
2022.10.8 Under review, time changed once, one reviewer submitted comments.
As of now, there is still no news... It's too slow... It has been half a year with no results...