liu 2023-07-03

May I ask how long it took for the original poster to become "under review"? I have also been in the editor's hands for two months...

strdrv 2023-06-26

The review process takes 12 months, which is extremely slow.

walkking 2023-05-31

2022.8 Submission
The first review result for 2023.5 has not been released yet.
We cannot submit to this journal again. We have already followed up once, but it was not effective.
I strongly advise against submitting to this journal; it is too time-consuming.

lycutter 2023-05-14

It's been cracking. Submitted on March 20th and still with the editor. Never seen a journal this slow.

xxxxsss 2023-05-09

Very slow, submitted around 22/11, no reply as of now 23/5/9. Withdrawing the submission now would incur very high sunk costs and it is uncertain if there will be any feedback in a few days. Considering the previous comments below, it is suggested to urgently look for alternatives.

lycutter 2023-05-05

It has been two months and it is still "with editor". Can I push for the manuscript?

王笑辰 2022-11-20

Oct 05, 2022 Submitted to Journal
Nov 11, 2022 With Editor
Dec 05, 2022 With Editor
Dec 08, 2022 Under Review
Dec 22, 2022 Under Review
Feb 05, 2023 Under Review
Feb 24, 2023 Required Reviews Completed
Mar 02, 2023 Decision in Process
March 27, 2023 Rejected and Resubmitted

Translation:
Oct 05, 2022 Submitted to Journal
Nov 11, 2022 With Editor
Dec 05, 2022 With Editor
Dec 08, 2022 Under Review
Dec 22, 2022 Under Review
Feb 05, 2023 Under Review
Feb 24, 2023 Required Reviews Completed
Mar 02, 2023 Decision in Process
March 27, 2023 Rejected and Resubmitted

花海19 2022-01-23

Posted in April 2021, there has been no news until now. I sent an email to urge them, and they said they are still waiting for the review comments. It's really taking a year to review an article, it's a bit irresponsible. I've been waiting for so long, but it's not like I can withdraw the submission now. I'm really frustrated.

zachyao 2021-08-31

The manuscript has been withdrawn, it's too slow. It's been three months and there's been no progress. Everyone should be cautious when submitting.

zachyao 2021-07-12

The speed is a bit slow, it has been a month since I submitted it, but it hasn't reached the editor yet.

hezy 2021-06-17

Submitted in March, currently under review.

lmmmmmm 2021-05-25

2020.09.05 Submitted to Journal
2020.09.17 With Editor
2020.10.08 With Editor
2020.10.10 Under Review
2020.12.09 Under Review
2021.01.19 Required Reviews Completed
2021.01.20 Decision in Process
2021.01.31 Reject

Two reviewers, both with acceptable attitudes, provided less than 10 comments combined. The editor's reply of "reject & resubmit" is truly incomprehensible. In a hurry to publish the paper, I made some minor revisions and submitted it to Medical Physics, where it was accepted in less than 4 months.

ssaipp 2021-05-25

Brother, have you received the first trial result now? It took me a month and a half for my status to change to "with editor"...

筱沫 2021-05-12

It's really too slow. I submitted it in December last year, and now it's almost June. I sent an email to the editor, and the editor said they are still waiting for the reviewers' comments. It's been six months and they still can't finish reviewing a paper. It seems a bit irresponsible. Withdrawing the submission is not an option now, and continuing to wait feels like an endless pit. It's a dilemma.

筱沫 2021-04-17

Translation: Be cautious about submitting manuscripts if you care about the speed of the review process. It takes over a month for the manuscript to reach the editor's hands, and then another month to be reviewed. It has been over two months since the review started and there is still no news. It is estimated that it will take at least three to four months to receive the first review result. It has been over four months now and there is still no outcome from the first review. I am very anxious about this. This information is provided for reference only.

Leo1990 2021-04-16

Can I ask if there will be any changes in the status of your submission? I have submitted my manuscript for a month now, and it is still in the submission status for the magazine.

筱沫 2021-04-08

The translation of the text "一样，4个月杳无音讯" into English is "The same, no news for 4 months."

JJJJJJL 2021-02-25

My first trial has been more than two months, there should be news soon, be patient and wait.

罕见的大雪 2021-02-25

How many months does it take for the first trial to produce a result? It has been four months for me, and there is no news at all.