认证评论 - Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers Part O-Journal of Risk and Reliability
zchn12 2023-03-09
Not very fast, it takes about four months from submission to receiving feedback. The revision time would also take at least one or two months, which may not be suitable for those who are in a hurry to graduate. The journal reviewers are quite professional and their questions are accurate, requiring a certain level of innovation.
piepie 2023-02-20
Is the review speed fast?
piepie 2023-02-18
May I ask how long is the review period for senior editors? Is there a high requirement for innovation?
piepie 2023-02-17
How long is the submission period? Is the requirement for content and algorithm innovation high?
piepie 2023-02-17
Is this journal article demanding a lot of innovation, including algorithms and content?
miracle666 2022-11-20
2022.8.10 Delivery
2022.9.21 Major repair
2022.10.31 Return of manuscript
Received one week later
zchn12 2022-11-08
Yes, please wait a moment longer.
zchn12 2022-11-08
It has been approximately half a month.
zchn12 2022-10-31
May I ask how long after returning from the major revision you uploaded the modified draft?
zchn12 2022-10-31
May I ask how long after returning from the overhaul did you upload the revised draft?
贺啦啦啦 2022-08-05
This journal is too slow.
Submitted on 4.19.
Reviewed on 4.20.
It's already 8.5 and it's still under review. Unbelievable, the peer review process is also too slow.
麦子粉 2022-07-21
2021.11.3 Submission
2022.3.25 Feedback for revision, major revision
2022.5.13 Submission of revised version
2022.7.18 Acceptance
The reviewers and editors were both very good!
Feng77 2022-07-11
Submitted in mid-February.
Received feedback for revision at the end of March, requiring major revisions.
Received feedback for revision in mid-May, requiring minor revisions.
Accepted on July 11th.
Two reviewers provided many constructive comments.
The editor was very diligent and reliable. The feedback was provided promptly. It is worth submitting.
爱祖国 2022-01-15
Excuse me, senior, for this journal submission, it is currently in the peer review process. Is it under external review?
Find the ideal target journal for your manuscript
Explore over 38,000 international journals covering a vast array of academic fields.
SearchBecome a Peeref-certified reviewer
The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.
Get Started