认证评论 - Catalysis Science & Technology
注: 认证评论选取于全球各个学术评论平台和社交媒体。

祝潇怡1992 2023-07-26

Excuse me, did you make some modifications after being rejected and then got accepted?

祝潇怡1992 2023-07-26

7.26 just submitted for review

zengxueliang 2023-07-26

I took another look today, and it has already been received.

zengxueliang 2023-07-25

May I ask if your submission has been reviewed? Mine is still with the editor. It has been over a month.

zengxueliang 2023-07-19

I am even more miserable than you.

祝潇怡1992 2023-07-17

Translated into English: Transferred to this journal on June 29, 2023. Still with editor as of July 17, 2023. Focus on computational chemistry.

意林~ 2023-07-06

Both reviewers have given minor revisions.

意林~ 2023-07-06

Posted on June 19th, received the review comments on July 6th.

hhhhhhy 2023-06-29

May I ask how long it will take to retrieve?

zengxueliang 2023-06-21

Record it,
Submitted on March 2nd,
Received reviewer comments at the end of May, one rejection and two minor revisions. Editor requested major revisions.
Returned revised manuscript on June 3rd.
Rejected at the end of June.

zengxueliang 2023-06-15

Your article should have been accepted, right?

灯火阑珊i 2023-05-19

3.31 Submission
5.2 Received feedback, Minor Revision. The editor mentioned that no need to submit for external review after the modification.
5.7 Revised, until today it has been in "With Editor" status. Does the editor really need this much time to consider?

zengxueliang 2023-05-17

I feel that the speed is quite slow. It has been several months for me too, and I am still in the reviewing process. Seeing others being so fast, I truly envy them.

zengxueliang 2023-05-16

We share the same illness. After submitting, I have been in the process of peer review and constantly switching between "in peer review" and "with editor". It's been a while but I envy those who receive news within one or two months.

qiuzhuo 2023-05-12

May I ask about the selected reviewer?

王俊超 2023-04-16

Submit for review in 7 days, receive feedback in one month, return for major or minor revisions within 30 days (with one reminder for editing in between). For the second review, there is only one minor issue, which will be addressed and returned on the same day, and accepted 3 days later.

qq572020211 2023-04-14

My submission went very smoothly this time. It was sent for review on the same day of submission, and it was accepted without any issues as well.

00123333 2023-03-27

May I ask if your submission has been reviewed? How long will it take with the editor?

妹妹抖 2023-03-21

2022.11.16 Submitted
2022.11.17 With editor
2022.12.17 Major revision (2 reviewers, 1 minor revision, 1 major revision)
2023.1.18 Revision submitted
2023.2.3 Accept
2023.2.4 Online
2023.3.21 Page numbers provided

felixkinggg 2023-03-14

The speed is incredibly slow, so those who are eager to publish articles and graduate should not submit.

zengxueliang 2023-03-06

After submitting, it took only one hour to be with the editor, but this status has remained unchanged for four days.

catcat 2022-10-04

The review process is extremely slow. It has been almost a month since the submission in September, and it is still in the initial review stage with the editor. For those in urgent need of the article, it is not recommended to submit it.

一头牛 2022-09-02

No, I submitted it on August 9th, and it has not been reviewed yet as of September 2nd. I sent a letter to the editor on August 29th, and he replied that it will be prioritized for decision-making. It should be fast now.

coco1234 2022-08-30

Have you submitted for review now?

一头牛 2022-08-29

You have not been with the editor for a long time, I submitted on August 9th, and it has been 20 days today, and it is still "with editor".

coco1234 2022-08-27

Last time, the submission was assigned to Professor Ye Jinhua, and it was reviewed in just 2 days. This time, it has been in the "with editor" status for several days.
Submitted on August 23rd.
With editor since August 24th.
Until today, it is still in the "with editor" status.

1594369135@qq.com 2022-08-27

I did not calculate the traditional industrial catalysis direction. The manuscript was edited and submitted for review within two hours after submission.

胖大喵爱吃鱼 2022-08-16

Hello, may I ask if you have submitted for review? I have encountered a similar situation with editor for 13 days without any progress. I cried...

胖大喵爱吃鱼 2022-08-16

8.3 submitted
8.3 initial assessment
8.4 with editor
It has been 13 days since it's with the editor, no progress. I sent an email to the editorial department, and they said there is a delay in handling my manuscript. They have contacted the editor to prioritize my manuscript. Sigh, I'm crying...
8.18 in peer review
It has been 17 days since submission for peer review, no news...

胖大喵爱吃鱼 2022-08-16

I have been with editor13 for 13 days, crying... I submitted my article before you sent this message, and I chose Editor Ye Jinhua. However, I made a calculation in my article, and I don't know if the system will assign me to Editor Lopez.

Create your own webinar

Interested in hosting your own webinar? Check the schedule and propose your idea to the Peeref Content Team.

Create Now

Ask a Question. Answer a Question.

Quickly pose questions to the entire community. Debate answers and get clarity on the most important issues facing researchers.

Get Started