学术乐色 2023-06-22

2023.05.18 submission, invite two reviewers
05.21 under review
06.10 reviewers assigned
06.13 two reviewers suggest minor revisions
06.20 response to reviewer comments
06.22 received
The editorial review was fast, and the reviewers' suggestions were professional and to the point. The entire process was remarkably quick, with acceptance within a month. It is a very good journal, and I appreciate the efficiency. I suggest inviting foreign reviewers to help speed up the review process.

LiBBBB 2023-02-14

Does this journal require payment?

LiBBBB 2023-02-14

Are there any other fees for this journal?

LiBBBB 2023-02-14

Is this journal charging a fee?

幼儿园英英 2022-12-13

Some reviewers have finished their reviews and returned them. It will be done once all the reviewers have returned their reviews.

方方哥 2022-11-01

In the field of ceramics, I submitted to several top journals. Each time, it took the editor over 2 weeks to get back to me, and in the end, they all asked me to submit to their subsidiary journals. After going back and forth for almost half a year, I decisively declined. I directly submitted to APYA and saved myself from going down the wrong path for so long.

10.3 Submitted
10.10 Under review
10.23 Minor revisions, 6 reviewers, over 50 comments, rejected half of them
10.28 Re-submitted
10.31 Accepted

蓝碎玻璃杯 2022-10-25

Laser cladding direction
09.12 Submitted
09.14 Under Review
10.09 Minor revisions, four reviewers, a total of 24 comments, none of them were very critical
10.22 Resubmitted
10.24 Accepted
The speed of manuscript processing surprised me. It was a bit unexpected. I thought it would take another month, but it was accepted in just two days.

愤怒的流沙包 2022-10-09

After 54 days with the editor, I became under review.

azw 2022-10-09

It has been over two months under review, and the date has changed three times. If anyone knows the reason for the date changes, please comment in this thread. Thank you.

愤怒的流沙包 2022-10-06

It has also been a month for me, still with an editor.

ruby 2022-09-28

I have been contributing to this magazine for over a month now, and I am still working with the editor. I don't know what to do.

愤怒的流沙包 2022-09-28

August 16, 2022 submission
September 5, 2022 with editor
September 28, 2022 still with editor

科研人 2022-09-22

Garbage journal, submitted on May 17th, rejected on September 22nd, after more than four months of delay. The rejection comments were also very vague and general, surprisingly, a journal with a physics background knows nothing about physics!

加肥猫 2022-09-21

At first, I submitted to another journal under Springer. The response I received was that it was not suitable for publication and they advised me to submit elsewhere. They provided me with suggestions to submit to 5 other journals, and I chose Applied Physics A. I resubmitted on June 13th and underwent major revisions for a month, followed by minor revisions. Finally, on September 20th, it was accepted! The reviewers demonstrated strong expertise in their field and provided critical questions. The editor was also diligent and responsible. I feel that Springer's article assistance service is quite good. They provide submission advice based on the content of each article, which is excellent.

azw 2022-09-20

I have been under review for 3 months.

蓬莱仙山 2022-09-18

Why have I been under review for 4 months?

幼儿园英英 2022-08-26

My thesis was revised, at that time I spent half a month with the editor, and then it went under review.

jiamaolee 2022-08-25

Can I ask if the author's article has been submitted for review? Mine has been with the editor for 25 days, which is too slow...

jiamaolee 2022-08-10

From the beginning until today, I have been with the editor. The processing speed of this journal is not fast!

幼儿园英英 2022-08-09

Is it normal for the editor to take almost two weeks?

笑对人生 2022-08-06

Four review comments, revised twice, the comments are very pertinent, the only drawback is that the acceptance period for the manuscript is too long, must urge for the submission.

Anboyu 2022-07-23

23 Feb 2021 - Submitted
12 Apr 2021 - Major Revision - Third Reviewer
02 May 2021 - Accepted
6 Oct 2021 - Retrieval - Retrieval period is a bit long

snowy 2022-07-13

Posted on February 25th,
Around March 10th, under review,
There have been several changes in the information during this time, with the most recent on June 21st, but it is still under review.
A few days ago, I messaged the editor to inquire about the status, and the editor said they are waiting for the editorial decision. Another week has passed, and it is still under review.

一定早睡 2022-07-08

Return for major repairs after one month of submission, and accept after one month of submitting modifications (with about 10 days stuck in the editing process in between).

frcly 2022-05-18

I searched for the second half of 2021 and 2022, but it seems like there are no results yet. Did I make a mistake in my search?

frcly 2022-05-18

The submission was reviewed and revised for half a month. After receiving the revised draft, it was accepted within 4 days.

yangchux 2022-05-06

Posted on April 4, 2022
Minor edits on April 17
Returning on April 29
Received on May 5
The speed is very fast, wishing the magazine to continue to thrive!

逃逸粒子 2022-04-15

No layout fee required, the speed is okay.

xuzhipiao 2022-04-15

I don't know if there is a layout fee. If so, how much is it? Thank you!

zczhao 2022-03-19

May I ask how much page fee you paid approximately?