认证评论 - SCIENTIA HORTICULTURAE
注: 认证评论选取于全球各个学术评论平台和社交媒体。

独为伊人亮 2022-08-14

Hello, may I ask if you have been finally hired? Mine is also the same result.

槑孖 2022-08-09

The text translates to: "As of the 7th of July, it shows that the manuscript is under review. Up until now, there has been no result, and there is currently only one reviewer assigned."

槑孖 2022-08-09

Congratulations, congratulations! I hope mine can also go smoothly.

liuRC 2022-08-06

Return for minor repairs on July 26th
Accept on August 6th
Exactly two months, love this speed.

ssrs 2022-07-22

I am pleased to inform you that it has been favorably received. Does this count as being received? [Frowning]

槑孖 2022-07-21

Okay, thank you~ Now I have a rough idea, I will patiently wait. I hope the outcome won't be too bad, otherwise I would feel sorry for this cycle. ?

ssrs 2022-07-21

The speed of review is indeed a bit slow. There are quite a few invitations sent to reviewers. It took about 60 days for the first revision, and it took 40 days to find reviewers.

槑孖 2022-07-21

Hello, I would like to ask how long it took from the notification of your paper being sent for review to the return of the review comments? My number 67.6 shows that it has been sent for review, but so far only one reviewer has accepted the review request, and there has been no progress from the others.

ziii 2022-07-18

2022.5.1 submitted
2022.6.4
2022.07.17 online

Translation:
2022.5.1 submitted
2022.6.4
2022.07.17 online

ssrs 2022-07-10

I would like to ask, for this journal, after the first round, are the same 5 reviewers still reviewing the revised version? How long does the review process usually take? Please help, thank you. [Bowing]

liuRC 2022-07-08

After taking a look, my editor is Takanori Saito.

槑孖 2022-07-07

Submitted on June 18th, it was just sent for review today. It was delayed for a while and I thought I would have to wait a long time (at least a month) for it to be reviewed. It is faster than expected, hoping that everything will go smoothly from now on!

槑孖 2022-07-05

Hello, I'd like to ask, who is your editor? I noticed that you submitted for external review very quickly. It has been 18 days since I submitted mine with an editor...

liuRC 2022-07-01

Received a notice for repair on the 7th of January. The two reviewers reviewed it for a total of 20 days, much faster than I expected. My junior sister wasn't so lucky, her manuscript was rejected after being held by the editor for a month.

槑孖 2022-06-24

May I ask what progress has been made on the paper? Has it been submitted for review?

槑孖 2022-06-24

May I ask what progress has been made on the paper? Has it been submitted for review?

nichengbeizhucele 2022-06-16

Submitted on 5.29, the current status is still "With Editor."

liuRC 2022-06-12

6.11进入外审 translates to "Enter external audit on 6.11" in English.

liuRC 2022-06-06

Just invested today, and the journal has a good outcome.

Amy 2022-05-17

Does anyone know the retrieval speed of this journal?

cau666 2022-05-12

Is it being reviewed now?

xq1996 2022-05-06

It has been almost 20 days with the editor, and it still hasn't been reviewed.

Jackie01 2022-04-27

Overall, the publication's article quality has gradually improved, with relatively high requirements. It is considered a classic magazine in the field of horticulture.

xsx 2022-04-23

Help, what should I do if I can't open the author's guide on the journal's official website?

弹弹弹,弹来好运 2022-04-17

Posted on February 21st
Received feedback on March 27th, extensive revisions required
Uploaded revised manuscript on April 15th
...waiting, hoping for smooth progress.

wintersweet 2022-03-07

Is there a "View Attachments" in the main page inside the attachment? Please check if there is anything there.

Vivian1234 2022-03-07

Hello, OP. The phrase "我的状态写的是revise 后面跟着reconsidered after major revision" translates to "I wrote revise in my status, followed by reconsidered after major revision." Does this mean minor revision or major revision? I couldn't find many review comments, so I'm not sure.

Vivian1234 2022-03-07

Hello, 56th floor owner. It has been one and a half months since submission, and there is only one sentence in the email that seems to be a revision suggestion. Besides the email, may I know where else can I see the specific review comments?

潇韵 2022-02-20

Original text: 楼主,您好,我的也是required review completed 一个多月的都,一直没消息,好着急,请问,您中间有催编辑吗

Translation: Hello, OP, my required review has also been completed for over a month, but I still haven't received any updates. I'm really anxious. May I ask if you have reminded the editor during this time?

嗦碗粉吧 2022-02-10

Borrowing a building. Hello, may I ask if the review comments from Scientia Horticulture can be viewed in the system besides receiving email notifications? I have not received the email with the review comments, but when we checked in the system, it showed as "incomplete". We contacted the editor, and they said they have resent it, but we still haven't received the review comments. We are confused.

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started