认证评论 - OPTICAL FIBER TECHNOLOGY
注: 认证评论选取于全球各个学术评论平台和社交媒体。

一个活络的博士 2023-05-10

Mar 21, 2023 Apr 25, 2023 Completed - Accept

Translation:
Mar 21, 2023 Apr 25, 2023 Completed - Accept

一个活络的博士 2023-04-10

2023.4.8, Decision in Process

一个活络的博士 2023-04-10

Mar 21, 2023 Apr 08, 2023 Decision in Process

Translation: The decision is currently being processed from March 21, 2023 to April 08, 2023.

一个活络的博士 2023-03-27

Delivered on March 21st, with editor.
Under review since March 27th.
Please await further response regarding the submission outcome.

neinei 2022-06-22

Hello, I would like to ask how to find out the editor's email address.

小福ing 2022-02-23

How long does it take for the host to review? It's been a month and there's no progress...

无法预测 2021-06-06

There are 5 reviewers, 3 of them accepted my work directly, 2 suggested revisions, and one requested major revisions. The first review process took almost a year.

无法预测 2021-05-27

May 21, 2020 "submitted" javascript:;
January 25, 2021 "required reviewers completed"
February 21, 2021 "Major revision"
April 22, 2021 "revision submitted"
April 27, 2021 "with editor"
May 27, 2021 "accepted"
For more than a year, the editor has been holding onto it, sending about ten reminders, frustrating.

我要成为大娱乐家 2021-04-28

It seems that Elsevier journals are relatively slow. It takes ten days for the status to change to "with editor" after submission, then it stays "with editor" for a week, followed by "under review" for a little over two months. After two reviewers' recommendations, one suggesting acceptance and the other suggesting major revisions, the editor finally rejected the submission, taking a total of three months. Considering this speed, if accepted, it would probably take at least five months.

xiaochongzi211 2021-02-04

During the first review, it took two months, during which I wrote one reminder letter.
During the second review, it took one month, during which I wrote another reminder letter.
For the final minor revision, I made the changes in the afternoon and submitted them back. I received them at 4 am the next morning.

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started