认证评论 - MICROCHIMICA ACTA
注: 认证评论选取于全球各个学术评论平台和社交媒体。

Wzm 2023-07-27

May I ask how long it takes for you to proofread? After receiving it, can I just wait?

要什么昵称 2023-07-13

The submission cycle is written too little, maybe about three months.

要什么昵称 2023-07-13

This magazine is a bit slow, so please be cautious when considering submitting. I often review and complete it within two or three days, but it takes a couple of months to see the required reviews completed. After receiving the reviewers' comments, the editor will also review the manuscript and ask very detailed questions. If you're not in a rush, you can give it a try as it helps to standardize writing.

投搞一直被拒 2023-07-07

Can those who make fluorescent probes submit to this journal? Distinguished academicians and outstanding young scholars.

勇敢牛牛 2023-03-22

It has been almost two months and I am still under.

852247316 2023-03-21

Excuse me, is this magazine fast? How long does it take to receive the first feedback, approximately two months?

sss12345 2023-03-10

Not bad, the suggestions for the major renovation are very professional, and many valuable questions have been raised.

lucky123hhh 2023-03-04

Hello! I would like to ask how long it takes for the proofreading process? It has been a month since the article was submitted, and there hasn't been any other updates.

lucky123hhh 2023-03-04

May I ask how long it took for the proofreading process? The article has been submitted for a month already, and surprisingly, it still hasn't been proofread.

1995@ecut 666 2023-02-18

There are five reviewers, and the review process takes one month. Please be patient and wait.

oolili 2022-12-16

11.30 with editor
12.3 editor invited
12.3 with editor
12.3 under review, reviewers invited
12.5 under review, reviewers agreed
12.15 required reviews completed
Wish good luck.

lucky123hhh 2022-12-08

What other statuses are there after "under review"?

lucky123hhh 2022-12-07

Hello! May I ask what are the possible states of this journal? My article has been under review for almost three weeks. Will there be any statuses like "required review completed" before major or minor revisions?

1995@ecut 666 2022-12-06

The reviewers are very conscientious, and the longstanding journal is still good.

oolili 2022-11-26

The translation of the text is as follows:

Microchimica acta
2022.10.4 submitted
10.7 editor assigned
10.8 reject and resubmit
11.9 resubmitted
11.15 with editor
11.18 editor invited
Too slow.

yanweizhen 2022-10-13

Submitted: 11 November 2021
Refused and resubmitted: 5 January 2022
Resubmitted: 23 March 2022
Major revision: 17 May 2022
Accepted: 31 May 2022
Published: 04 July 2022

This journal is not as slow as everyone thinks, and the self-citation rate has been declining for two consecutive years, while the impact factor is still rising.
In the first round of review, there were two reviewers, one rejection and one editor, who raised many meaningful questions. In the second round of review after resubmission, there were still two reviewers, one minor revision and the other still the editor, who ultimately suggested major revisions. The suggestions given by both editors were very rigorous, even pointing out many typos and symbol-related issues. The major revision response was 4000 words, and it was directly accepted. It is important to seriously supplement experiments and provide sincere responses. I hope everyone will cite it more to increase the impact factor.

做最好的自己123 2022-10-01

Sent four reviewers, three of them gave feedback, one of which is the editor! It's just that the proofreading process is a bit slow!

花落未央Smile 2022-09-29

I want to ask the original poster, how many reviewers are there?

Yu Han 2022-09-26

I submitted it on July 14th, and it is still under review until now. It's really slow, I'm afraid I won't be able to graduate on time...

做最好的自己123 2022-09-22

Please fill in the table below and the proof is a bit slow.

做最好的自己123 2022-09-19

Submitted on the 13th, arrived at the editor's on the 16th, officially accepted on the 19th! I don't feel like this journal is as slow as everyone says, and the self-citation rate is not that high either! I still have a positive outlook on it and hope everyone can cite it more to increase its impact!

做最好的自己123 2022-09-15

Posted on July 21, major revisions on August 20, revised on September 12, continuous updates to follow. Hope it can help everyone, feels quite fast.

小呆子123 2022-08-11

August 10th has become "Under Review", recently the journals have become so slow.

小呆子123 2022-08-02

Posted on July 20th
With editor on July 22nd
Editor invited on July 25th
Currently still in the process of inviting editors, may I ask how long this process will take? Based on the comments, it seems to take around 1-2 months, which makes me want to switch and submit elsewhere.

科研小白兔 2021-10-13

What was the final result?

科研小白兔 2021-10-13

How long did you submit for review, Asia?

静水186流深 2021-07-08

The editor is very serious and careful. He/she has provided dozens of modification suggestions. It has been resubmitted for acceptance, and the process is not as slow as imagined. Currently, the latest self-citation rate has significantly decreased. I hope the magazine will continue to improve.

xky_009 2021-01-12

I have been submitting for two months and still with the editor. It has been over a month since I received the editing invitation. Does this mean there is no editor available? Furthermore, why are my emails to the magazine being returned? Does it mean they only allow receiving emails and not others sending emails to the magazine? Also, the magazine's page does not provide any contact information for the magazine. Facing graduation, I really cannot afford to wait any longer. I can't even send an email to withdraw my submission. Can you please tell me what is going on?

xky_009 2021-01-12

Hello, may I ask how you send emails to this journal? Why is it that every time I send an email to this magazine, it gets returned and cannot be sent? I also can't find any other contact information for this journal. Has this magazine set up an automatic return for other people's emails?

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started

Ask a Question. Answer a Question.

Quickly pose questions to the entire community. Debate answers and get clarity on the most important issues facing researchers.

Get Started