bao 2021-03-24

The above is written incorrectly, the results were only released on March 21st, and the under review period was 44 days.

菇凉我没心没肺 2021-03-23

I hope good luck comes.

amupf 2021-03-22

My required reviews have also been completed. It has been 21 days.

bao 2021-03-22

February 5th under review
February 15th write a reminder letter
February 21st, 9 am required review completed, review period of 44 days
February 21st, 2 pm, minor revisions, two with no issues, one with multiple review comments
February 22nd, 4:30 pm, returned with revision suggestions,
Hope to receive it soon, graduation is only left with this one article.

粉碎机 2021-03-16

"Materials Letters X is not considered as SCI, right?"

我命由我不由天 2021-03-13

2.01 Submission
2.04 Formatting revision
2.05 with editor
2.15 Under review
2.16 Required reviews completed
3.03 Required reviews completed (Wishing for a miracle, the second reviewer's comments finally arrived)
3.04 Rejection (Actually, they suggested transferring to Materials Letters:X, but I didn't agree)
Two reviewers, the first reviewer: "The topic is potentially interesting but the work is not novel enough for publication in this prestigious journal." This reviewer didn't understand at all and didn't provide specific feedback, just gave a random reason for rejection. So frustrating.
The second reviewer found it interesting and approved.
In the end, the editor suggested transferring, and since I didn't agree, it got rejected.
Graduation requires such difficult research articles. Research really isn't easy.

oldkitty 2021-03-09

The reviews that I am required to complete were received two weeks later.

一台SCI机 2021-03-08

Accepted on March 7th, 2021, exactly two months ago. Worked hard for a hundred days and successfully graduated!

amupf 2021-03-06

I have also completed the required reviews, it has been 5 days already.

清风 2021-03-04

It feels slow, and I am also waiting with a broken heart. I hope everyone has a good outcome.

赶路者 2021-02-25

Posted on December 20, 2020
Format modified on December 22, 2020
With editor on December 23, 2020
Under review on December 29, 2020
Revision comments on January 26, 2021, 9 items
Revised submission on February 3, 2021
Format modified for highlights on February 4, 2021
With editor on February 5, 2021
Under review on February 6, 2021
Accepted on February 23, 2021
From submission to acceptance, it took a little over 2 months, which is relatively fast. The main focus was on highlighting important points and strict formatting requirements. The word count should not be too high, with three figures and one table not exceeding 2000 words, and four figures not exceeding 1800 words.

bao 2021-02-25

2021.2.1 Submission
2021.2.3 Format modification
2021.2.4 with editor
2021.2.5 under review
2021.2.25 It has been twenty days, the outcome is unknown, this is a crucial article for graduation, feeling very anxious.

一台SCI机 2021-02-24

After modification and rework on February 23rd, it will be submitted for review on February 24th.

清风 2021-02-20

Hello, may I ask if your article has any results? My situation is the same as yours, so I would like to have a discussion with you.

史胖 2021-02-17

It took a total of 67 days, but overall it turned out pretty well.

一台SCI机 2021-02-16

During the Spring Festival, I didn't have time to watch it. The minor repairs will be completed by February 6th, with a one-month deadline.

一台SCI机 2021-02-03

Reviewing took half a month, Required Reviews Completed. Some progress made!!!

清风 2021-02-01

The moon shines over the land of Kyushu, bringing both joy and sorrow to different households. As for me, things are moving at a painfully slow pace here. Sigh.

acdfhb 2021-01-27

Under review status, this depends on the reviewers, some are fast, some are slow.

oldkitty 2021-01-27

It has been nearly two weeks since I submitted the revised manuscript, and it is still under review. I don't know what's going on.

acdfhb 2021-01-27

materials letters 2020.12.22 submitted
2020.12.28 modified format and resubmitted
2020.12.29 with editor
2020.12.30 under review
2021.01.15 Required Reviews Completed
2021.01.17 moderate revision
2021.01.22 resubmitted and with editor
2021.01.23 under review
2021.01.25 Required Reviews Completed
2021.01.26 accept
Thank you, editor A.F.W. Willoughby, for your fast response. Best wishes for the continued success of the journal!

ocean in spring 2021-01-25

Posted on December 25th, format revised on the 27th, under review on the 28th, minor revisions on January 1st, revised again on January 16th, accepted on January 18th. This speed is too fast, isn't it?

一台SCI机 2021-01-17

With the editor, the week has finally been submitted for review. The speed is still very fast. I hope for good luck!!!

一台SCI机 2021-01-15

May I ask how long it usually takes for "With editor" to be reviewed? I am in a hurry to graduate.

acdfhb 2021-01-15

Hello, my day is also in this state now, Required Reviews Completed. Doesn't this mean that the review is finished? Why is it so slow? Any progress on yours?

清风 2021-01-13

My article has also been with the editor for nearly a month. Someone asked, "Is the editor directly reviewing it?" But then it went under review and I'm still waiting, feeling quite anxious. Let's all work together.

lyp1108 2021-01-08

May I know who is the editor in charge of handling it?