一路向北 2022-06-30

Does MATERIALS LETTERS require 4-5 highlights? The editor said there is a problem with my highlights, but didn't specify where the problem is. I only wrote 3 highlights and I suspect that it's too few. Can someone with experience share some insights, please? Thank you.

胁田兼则 2022-06-25

Not yet, convinced.

无所谓惧怕 2022-06-25

6.25 decision in process

无所谓惧怕 2022-06-23

Submitted on May 16th, reviewed on the 23rd, reminded once during the process, sent to 6 reviewers, 2 accepted, 1 returned, still no news now.

keeper 2022-06-22

Brother, is there any result now? I submitted it on June 1st, it was under review on June 3rd, and there was a change on June 20th.

kevinbeyond 2022-06-20

Require innovative points in the paper, comprehensive data is needed. Generally speaking, the speed of acceptance is acceptable, and after modifying according to the 11 suggestions proposed by the reviewers, it was finally accepted after 4 months.

只想一篇文章毕业 2022-06-18

I have been waiting for two and a half months. The comments on my manuscript have not been given to me yet. I am already speechless about this journal.

无所谓惧怕 2022-06-16

Mine too, it was submitted on May 17th and only one reviewer accepted it. Then last week I sent an email to urge, they said it was sent to four people, but still no response now.

赶路者 2022-06-15

It seems that it's not as fast as expected! Submitted on May 19th, reviewed on May 24th, and still under review until now, with no change in the date.

胁田兼则 2022-06-08

The dates of May 25th and June 4th have been changed twice under review.

kurapika 2022-06-02

Mine is the same. Other people's are all done quickly, but mine has been in the hands of the editor for rework.

keeper 2022-05-31

Boss, do you know how to handle this technical review comment? "In its current state, the level of English throughout your manuscript does not meet the journal's desired standard. Please check the manuscript and refine the language carefully."

keeper 2022-05-31

"Bosses, what does the opinion of technical review mean? 'In its current state, the level of English throughout your manuscript does not meet the journal's desired standard. Please check the manuscript and refine the language carefully.' Does this mean I need to find a place to polish it?"

菩提树 2022-05-31

Submitted on May 6th, accepted on the 31st, with minor revisions in between. There were three reviewers, and the process was very fast.

无所谓惧怕 2022-05-18

How many reviewers are you?

挥洒法和 2022-05-18

OP, I have been investing for 20 days and it is still in my hands for editing.

挥洒法和 2022-05-18

Submitted on April 30th
Returned for format modification on May 5th, re-submitted on the same day
With editor since May 8th until now
Watching others' acceptance being so fast, why haven't I heard anything?

胁田兼则 2022-05-16

Submitted on April 2nd
Returned for format revision on April 8th, resubmitted the same day
With editor on April 12th
Under review on April 23rd
Changed the review date to present on May 8th
It seems like not everyone is fast.

kkkk16 2022-05-16

Due to the epidemic, I am unable to conduct experiments at home, so I have organized some previous data. This journal has a low word count, making it very suitable for a slightly innovative small project. Moreover, the review process only took 7 days and the feedback was super efficient. The overall experience was refreshing. Thank you to the editor and reviewers.

pubdidi 2022-05-11

4.20 submitted - Submitted on April 20th
4.21 技术审查 - Technical review on April 21st
4.24 再次提交 - Resubmitted on April 24th
5.4 小修 1个问题 - Minor revision with 1 issue on May 4th
5.10 修回 - Revised on May 10th
5.11 接受 - Accepted on May 11th

赶紧毕业 2022-04-30

Thank you for sharing, it has been 50 days since the review, and it has not ended yet. I am just unlucky, I guess there are not many ML submissions that have not been completed within 50 days of the first review.

王杨杨 2022-04-30

Hello, on March 2nd, we received a request to modify the format. On the 4th, we returned the revised manuscript. On March 20th, we received the review comments. The first review process took about two weeks. On April 19th, we replied with the suggested modifications. Currently, the manuscript is under review after the revisions. I hope this information is helpful to you. Good luck!

Mr.editor 2022-04-28

Submitted on February 11th, notified on the 18th to make some specific formatting changes. Assigned manuscript number on the 23rd and underwent formal review. Returned for revisions on March 10th. Due to the pandemic, the revised manuscript was submitted on April 6th. Accepted on April 25th. Conclusion: The review process was relatively fast, and the impact factor is acceptable. The formatting requirements were quite strict.

依旧恋星辰丶 2022-04-23

After receiving, final confirmation will be requested within one week. It will be published within one or two days after completion.

赶紧毕业 2022-04-23

May I ask about the status of the original poster's paper? I submitted my paper on March 10th and it is still under review.

只想一篇文章毕业 2022-04-19

Just wanted to ask, how long will you be under review?

转到设置以激活 2022-04-19

May I ask how long it takes to retrieve after receiving it?

奋斗熊 2022-03-31

Received 23 December 2021,
Revised 31 January 2022,
Accepted 14 February 2022,
Available online 16 February 2022,
Version of Record 26 February 2022.

Submitted before Christmas, took a long time during the editing process, but everything after was quick.

Arieswen 2022-03-23

Is there a requirement for the length of the paper?

荪蒲 2022-03-22

Why has it been almost two months since I submitted the review?