不太冷漠的枫 2022-08-15

The second review also has a reviewer holding me up. So anxious, so anxious, 5555555555.

不太冷漠的枫 2022-08-13

Boss, did you send it for review during your second trial? There were six small issues from one reviewer in my first trial. After I replied, I sent it for review yesterday. I don't know if it will be reviewed by two reviewers.

不太冷漠的枫 2022-08-13

Last night, I submitted it for review. I hope to get the results quickly!

不太冷漠的枫 2022-08-12

Ah, everyone else seems to be submitting their work and getting accepted within two or three days. It's been four or five days for me, and there's still no response from the editor. I feel like there's no hope before the end of the month. It's taking even longer than when I first submitted it for review. I give up.

胁田兼则 2022-08-11

After 4 months, I received a moderate revision. There was only one reviewer with 4 comments.

Daive Hu 2022-08-10

7.22 Accept

不太冷漠的枫 2022-08-10

Boss, after revision, did you send it to the reviewer or did the editor take a look and accept it? Thank you for your reply!

不太冷漠的枫 2022-08-10

The speed of the first review was quite fast, it came back in two weeks. There were two reviewers, one had no comments and the other raised six small issues. After making serious revisions, it was delayed for a week due to a minor matter. It was resubmitted on August 7th, and the next day it was mentioned that the word count exceeded the limit, characters cannot exceed 2000 words. After making some changes, it was sent back again. From August 8th to August 10th, it is still "with editor". The editor is probably on vacation.

豌豆VI 2022-08-10

Is there a word count limit for submissions?

豌豆VI 2022-08-10

Is there a word count or length limit for submissions? The guide for authors cannot be opened.

豌豆VI 2022-08-10

Is there a word or page limit for submissions? The guide for authors cannot be opened.

陈康 2022-07-31

At noon, they were still complaining about me, but in the evening they accepted it.

陈康 2022-07-31

6.22 Submission
6.23 Under review
7.8 Moderate review
7.21 Resubmit
7.22 Under review
7.31 Under review
During the second review, there was a reviewer who kept holding me back and didn't review.

泰山学人 2022-07-30

Article status display: Decision in Process, hoping for a good outcome!

taocicailiao 2022-07-29

May I ask if the journal MATERIALS LETTERS requires every author to confirm before assigning a manuscript number and conducting the review process? Thank you.

AVSVAV 2022-07-23

6.10 submission
6.12 format revision
6.13 submit to editor
6.13 submit for review
7.7 revision
7.12 return of manuscript
7.18 acceptance

ustb-hwf 2022-07-21

Hello, where can I see this online trace?

keeper 2022-07-20

Do you have any news now, brother?

慢慢爬 2022-07-20

"What is the current status now?"

Daive Hu 2022-07-20

Metal Oxide Material Direction
7.16 Submission
7.17 Review
7.20 Minor Revision

我愿潇洒如鹰 2022-07-16

Why is there no response when I click on continue on the login and registration interface of Materials Letters? Please help.

Mabohao 2022-07-15

The webpage tracking shows 2+under review, with only one accepted for review and no updates on the others, it has been a month already.

只想一篇文章毕业 2022-07-13

Buddy, you need to keep a calm mindset. I was also very hopeful at the beginning, expecting to receive feedback within a month. However, I ended up waiting for three and a half months... Prepare for the worst, that's all I can say. Good luck to you.

keeper 2022-07-13

I have been waiting for a month and a half already. The "Under Review" status has changed twice during this time. This journal feels very inconsistent in terms of speed, with some people getting responses quickly while others wait a long time. I chose to submit to it because it was supposed to be fast, but now I feel a bit frustrated.

只想一篇文章毕业 2022-07-12

With an extremely complicated mood, I wrote this review. It wasn't until the second half of my third year of research that I prepared to submit it. After searching, I felt that this journal had a relatively fast average speed, so I decided to submit to it with my advisor's approval. Then came the incredibly uncomfortable process.

On March 26th, I submitted it.
On March 29th, I made formatting revisions.
On April 2nd, the journal received it.
And then the long, long, long peer review process began.
Until the time of degree conferment, there were still no reviewer comments. I felt disheartened.

Starting from the end of May, I wrote three reminder letters one after another, all requesting for a bit more time as it was still under review.

My advisor was worried that it would delay the issuance of my degree certificate, so I rushed to publish another paper based on my work. As a result, on July 10th, I received reviewer comments from the newly submitted journal, but there was still no result from Materials Letters.

Then, on the morning of July 11th, my supervisor called me and told me that it had been directly accepted. They showed me the email, which only had a few simple questions from the second reviewer, and the first and third reviewers didn't even participate.

It took more than three months, but it was accepted. I consider myself lucky that it didn't affect my job offer.

To those who are considering submitting to this journal, be cautious!

锦鲤 2022-07-10

Dear experts, I have a question. After "with editor," if there is no external review and directly a decision, does it mean it will be a tragedy?

alfred9807 2022-07-08

Excuse me, does the first author also need to confirm by email? For the submission made by the corresponding author, other co-authors received the confirmation email, only the first author didn't receive it.

keeper 2022-07-07

Is there any news, brother?

一路向北 2022-07-04

Thank you for your reply. I didn't exceed the word count, so I'm not sure what the problem is. I changed it to four paragraphs and then edited it. My article has been accepted.

Submission: April 12, 2022
Review: May 10, 2022
Revisions: June 7, 2022. There were a few minor issues, but I had other things going on, so I kept postponing the article's revision until the last two days. After submitting, there was a prompt about issues with the highlights.

Revisions: June 29, 2022. I had other matters to attend to, so I delayed the revision of the highlights for 20 days. After submitting, there was still a prompt about issues with the highlights.

Revisions: June 30, 2022
Revisions: July 2, 2022. Four minor issues.
Accepted: July 4, 2022.

keeper 2022-06-30

It should be your highlights characters exceeding the limit. I remember each one should not exceed 85 characters. Please go and check the requirements.