oddss 2023-06-20

It can be done within 1-2 days.

24March 2023-06-19

May I ask how is the speed of the journal's peer review process? How long does it usually take for a submission to be under review?

LiLeey 2023-06-09

It has been under review for 4 months. The last status update was in April. Should I remind them to review it? How do you all find the email address to send a reminder letter?

太沙基的小跟班 2023-06-04

I proofread it in about a week.

太沙基的小跟班 2023-06-02

The speed is fast, submission to acceptance takes less than four months, with two rounds of revisions in between, which took about a month. Generally, the external review takes about a month to produce results.
The chief editor and editors are all very nice and efficient, usually processing within three days.
Thank you to JSS, the journal is very friendly.
The main research direction is soil science and soil mechanics, specializing in the improvement of special soil types. Welcome to communicate. WeChat, Yan_Junbiao.

duoduo玩泥巴 2023-05-10

It seems like it will take more than a month.

li-ethan 2023-04-28

How long after receiving will the proof be? Just wait?

li-ethan 2023-02-15

2.14 under review

li-ethan 2023-02-13

2.3 with editor
2.14 under review
3.6 Rework
3.27 Revised
3.28 with editor
3.31 under review
4.17 Required Reviews Completed
4.22 Accept
4.30 proof

椭圆三向箔 2023-01-17

After three months of reviewing and editing, it has been accepted. The speed is acceptable.

wwwmming 2022-10-31

Speed is given 10 points. It was submitted at 10 o'clock in the morning and rejected at 8 o'clock in the evening. The editor seems to be a Chinese person or of Chinese descent.

椭圆三向箔 2022-10-26

I feel sorry for the original poster. Can you see which editor handled it?

要投多少次才行啊 2022-10-25

I'm speechless:
Submitted on 7.21, in August it changed from "with editor" to "under review", and I had to wait until 10.25 for the editor to tell me it was rejected directly.
I won't even mention the time, as it is already known that the review process for soil science journals is usually long.
But since it wasn't sent for review, there was no need to keep it under review and waste time. It would have been better to reject it earlier so I could find another journal.

吃瓜群众A 2022-08-23

6.15submitted
6.15with editor
6.17under review
7.15major revision
8.15resubmitted
8.16under review
9.07minor revision
9.12resubmitted
9.15accept

Translation:
6.15 - Submitted
6.15 - With Editor
6.17 - Under Review
7.15 - Major Revision
8.15 - Resubmitted
8.16 - Under Review
9.07 - Minor Revision
9.12 - Resubmitted
9.15 - Accept

lovevast 2022-08-20

Excuse me, boss, how long does it take to review? How many times have you updated it with the editor?

小呆瓜@ 2022-06-30

I have waited for more than 3 weeks.

生化环材我占了三 2022-06-29

I would like to ask my colleagues who have experienced this before, after completing the Required Reviews, how many days does it usually take for the editor to provide the first review result? I have been waiting for 3 days already.

mary651 2022-06-24

Already submitted for 7 days, it has been in the "with editor" status. How many days at most can it be sent for review?

wty0803 2022-06-09

The subject of the paper is heavy metals in soil. The submission process is as follows:
- Submitted on 4.28
- Under review by editor on 4.30
- Under review by reviewers on 4.31
- Requested major revisions on 5.31
- Resubmitted on 6.4
- Accepted on 6.9

The overall duration was a little over a month, with two reviewers providing friendly and constructive feedback. The experience was positive, and if there are suitable manuscripts in the future, I will submit again.

mephistok 2022-05-24

5.16 Submission
5.21-present under review

jiaxiwang 2022-05-19

2021-12-12 Submission
2022-3-2 Received
Underwent a major renovation in between.

Milany 2022-05-19

December 2021 Submission
First review with two reviewers, major revisions
Sent back for revisions, editor assigned another reviewer
Second review with major revisions again
Sent back for revisions, minor revisions were given
Accepted on May 14, 2022
The editor and reviewers were all responsible.

liying9391 2022-05-15

It is an old and well-regarded journal in the field of soil science. The first submission focused on the characteristics of soil pollutant loss. The editorial efficiency was impressive, and the overall difficulty was not high. It went through three reviewers and required one major revision and one minor revision before being accepted, taking less than 3 months in total.

February 20, 2022: Submitted
February 21, 2022: Under review
March 16, 2022: Required reviews completed
March 27, 2022: Decision in process
March 28, 2022: Major revision
April 26, 2022: Returned in the evening
April 27, 2022: With editor
April 28, 2022: Under review
May 4, 2022: Decision in process
May 5, 2022: Minor revision (only four questions)
May 6, 2022 (Friday): Returned
May 9, 2022 (Monday): With editor
May 14, 2022: Decision in process
May 15, 2022 (morning): Accepted.

瓜瓜_dm 2022-05-13

Hello, I would like to ask if your application for the submission account of this magazine went smoothly? I have applied several times without success, and I am not sure what the problem is. Can you help me solve it? Thank you.

晗111 2022-05-12

My book has been with the editor for many days now, but there has been no response. From 5.4 until now, it is still with the editor.

陈鸭鸭 2022-05-10

Rejected, the editor suggested resubmitting after rejection. Are there any experts who have succeeded after resubmission?

晗111 2022-05-07

My situation is the same. I submitted on the 29th, and it was only "with editor" on the 4th. It is also "with editor" now.

木木心 2022-04-24

Mine is the same. Recently, due to the impact of the epidemic or short vacations abroad, mine is also very slow.

阿hao1 2022-04-22

07 Apr 2022 Submitted
08 Apr 2022 With editor
There has been no progress until now, this is too slow.

木木心 2022-04-05

January 20 - Submitted
January 22 - Under review
February 26 - Returned for revision
March 1 - Resubmit
March 2 - With editor
March 3 - Under review
March 29 - Minor revision for formatting
April 3 - Resubmit
April 4 - Accepted with editor on the same evening!

Everyone, please pay attention to checking the format, especially the format of references. This is very important!

Thanks to the editor-in-chief of JSS,

Journal of Soils and Sediments

Also, I hope everyone can submit articles smoothly.