认证评论 - JOURNAL OF MATERIALS SCIENCE
注: 认证评论选取于全球各个学术评论平台和社交媒体。

ymz416 2023-08-03

Translation:
Posted on 03 May 2023
Accepted one month after major renovation on 02 Aug 2023.

九尘 2023-07-20

How to find the contact information of a reviewer?

lsk1999 2023-07-10

2 weeks editing invitation, approximately 1 month under review, then 1 month major, then 1 month accept.

小鹿斑比 2023-06-30

Write down all the points mentioned in the email he gave. If any points are missing, write "None" directly. Anyway, I have included all the points he mentioned. Write them as subheadings before the references. Currently, my submission is under editor review, so it should be fine.

小鹿斑比 2023-06-30

I also encountered this the day before yesterday, and this is how I wrote it.
Supplementary information: None.
And now I am inviting the editor, so there shouldn't be any problem with this.

linyu123 2023-06-30

If you don't understand, just ask. After rejecting, can you ignore the transfer and directly submit to the next journal, or will he really transfer you to another one?

1-8 2023-06-29

After submission, the article was returned with the reason that supplementary information is required. It states: "A brief description of any additional material omitted from the main body in the interest of presenting a clearer and more readable manuscript." However, my article does not have any supporting materials. What does this mean? Can anyone who has submitted before help clarify? Thank you!

纽哈 2023-06-27

"Written before the references."

x-yao 2023-06-26

I am also in this situation and would like to ask how to solve it.

x-yao 2023-06-26

I have returned several times to write a bunch of statements and such. I have written and uploaded them all, but why is it still not working? Should I write them in the main file? I have been uploading them individually, and then I changed to a compressed file, but it still doesn't work. Can you please tell me what's going on?

way 2023-06-26

Are all the articles in this journal fully open access?

way 2023-06-26

I want to ask, is this journal fully open access?

纽哈 2023-06-23

It has been over a week since the manuscript review was completed, but the editor stubbornly refuses to provide any feedback.

shum09 2023-06-20

It took over a month to find a reviewer, and after making significant revisions (there weren't many actual suggestions for improvement), it was accepted within half a month. I just wanted to ask if there is still a need to pay over $3,000 in publication fees. I don't recall choosing Open Access, did I?

Clearlove 2023-06-12

5.12 submission
5.13 editor assigned
5.19 editor invited
5.19 reviewer assigned
5.23 review assigned
5.23 under review
5.30 reviewer assigned
5.31 under review
6.6 reviewer assigned
6.8 review completed
6.12 under review
Why is it repeatedly "under review," even if each time it is assigned to a reviewer?

俗闺女J 2023-06-12

2023-3-25-New Submissions
2023-3-38-Editor Assigned
2023-3-29-Editor Invited
2023-3-30-Editor Assigned
2023-4-02-Reviewers Assigned
2023-4-03-Under Review
2023-4-16-Reviews completed
2023-4-20-Reviewers Assigned
2023-4-24-Under Review
2023-5-2-Major Revision
2023-5-16-Revision Submitted
2023-5-19-Editor Invited
2023-5-19-Reviewers Assigned
2023-5-20-Under Review
2023-5-23-Reviews completed
2023-5-26-Under Review
2023-6-08-Accepted

Translation:
2023-3-25-New Submissions
2023-3-38-Editor Assigned
2023-3-29-Editor Invited
2023-3-30-Editor Assigned
2023-4-02-Reviewers Assigned
2023-4-03-Under Review
2023-4-16-Reviews completed
2023-4-20-Reviewers Assigned
2023-4-24-Under Review
2023-5-2-Major Revision
2023-5-16-Revision Submitted
2023-5-19-Editor Invited
2023-5-19-Reviewers Assigned
2023-5-20-Under Review
2023-5-23-Reviews completed
2023-5-26-Under Review
2023-6-08-Accepted

lixia-scu 2023-06-11

2.23 submission
2.24 editor invited
3.18 reviewers assigned
4.5 under review
4.8 review completed
4.11 under review
4.14 reviews completed
4.21 reviews completed
4.24 reviews completed
4.25 major revisions needed
6.01 revision submitted
6.05 editor invited
6.10 Accepted
The actual start of the review process was quite fast, with most of the time spent on finding an editor and reviewers.

纽哈 2023-06-10

It means that the chief editor has invited an editor to handle your article. If they accept, it will be considered as an editor assigned. If they don't intend to take it, the chief editor will have to find another editor, so this situation may continue indefinitely.

为了媳妇要努力 2023-06-09

Can I ask, what is the status of "editor invited"? It has been editor invited for 9 days already.

纽哈 2023-06-09

You need to write down everything he tells you.

Clearlove 2023-06-08

I made a mistake. I submitted it on 5/12, but the status of my paper has changed three times from "reviewer assigned" to "under review".

nengwen 2023-06-08

I have been returned several times, even after making changes, it still doesn't work. I don't know what's wrong.

nengwen 2023-06-08

I have been rejected several times, but it still doesn't work. I don't know what's going on.

nengwen 2023-06-08

I was sent back, and I made changes to the acknowledgements, author contributions, and conflict of interest statement, etc. After submission, it was still sent back. How did you modify it?

为了媳妇要努力 2023-06-04

What does the person upstairs mean? Isn't it still not June 12th yet?
So, may I ask if there is an experience of the editor invited stage?

Clearlove 2023-06-04

6.12 submission has already undergone two changes after being under review.

为了媳妇要努力 2023-06-03

Excuse me, everyone. Does "editor invited" mean that there is no editor?

为了媳妇要努力 2023-06-01

Posted on May 30, 2023, why is it still a new submission now?

折翼天使 2023-05-19

Excuse me,
Did you send the manuscript for external review during these 13 days?
After I completed the major revisions, the second reviewer did not provide any comments, only stating that it can be accepted. The editor asked me to confirm the authorship and other formatting issues. I made the modifications and submitted it on 5/17, according to which it should be labeled as proof/accept. Why did it change back to editor invited, and I also didn't make any changes? I'm a bit confused.

灰色灰 2023-05-08

Why do I have to pay even though I didn't vote for OA?

Find Funding. Review Successful Grants.

Explore over 25,000 new funding opportunities and over 6,000,000 successful grants.

Explore

Add your recorded webinar

Do you already have a recorded webinar? Grow your audience and get more views by easily listing your recording on Peeref.

Upload Now