Xepin 2023-07-20

Submission Timeline:
2023.5.5: Submitted
5.09: Under editor's review
5.28: Under review
6.07: Under review, with changes
6.14: Rejected and resubmit chance (RRC)
6.17: Revised
7.08: Submitted revised manuscript, with editor
7.11: Under review
7.18: Rejected and resubmit chance (RRC)
7.19: Accepted

催化毛小豆 2023-07-19

It has been 19 days and still no news.

邓阿喵 2023-07-17

The text "2023.7.16 Revise" is already in English. It appears to be a date followed by the word "Revise."

夜枫之舞 2023-07-15

May I ask the specific month and date you submitted it?

Justin123 2023-07-14

This is too fast. What's been happening recently? I also got RRC in just 10 days.

邓阿喵 2023-07-13

2023.7.13 required reviews completed

夜枫之舞 2023-07-12

Still, it depends on the quality of the content of the paper and the editor it is submitted to. I submitted two papers myself, one to this hydrogen energy journal in March and another to this journal on May 30th. The one submitted on May 30th was accepted last weekend, but the one submitted in March is still under review until now. I have sent the editor several reminders, but haven't received any response.

芳华待灼 2023-07-11

This journal is so fast!

夜枫之舞 2023-07-10

If it's not Gold OA, then it's the usual kind that is free of charge.

大萌子QAQ 2023-07-10

May I ask if you have chosen gold OA? It feels so fast.

夜枫之舞 2023-07-10

First submission: May 30, 2023
Current Status: Submit to Journal
Current Status: With Editor - June 2, 2023
Current Status: Under Review - June 6, 2023
Current Status: Required Reviews Completed - June 21, 2023
Current Status: Revise - June 26, 2023
Revised submission: With Editor - July 3, 2023
Current Status: With Editor - July 4, 2023
Accept: July 9, 2023
Total time taken: 41 days for acceptance. Wishing the International Hydrogen Journal continued success and striving for inclusion in the Chinese Academy of Sciences Zone 1!

催化毛小豆 2023-07-09

It has been nine days since the required reviews were completed.

lixinying 2023-07-07

I am also waiting for the RRC on June 14th. Until now, there is no news. Previously, I received feedback from two reviewers, one suggesting minor revisions and the other suggesting major revisions. After submitting the revised manuscript, I haven't heard back from the RRC yet.

冒了个泡 2023-07-06

The search time is simply very late, and it was not until the end of April that the search was conducted.

冒了个泡 2023-07-06

Make up for last year's
2022.10.19 submit
2022.11.7 under review
Two reviewers (every two weeks)
2022.12.3 revise
2022.12.18 accept

邓阿喵 2023-07-05

2023.7.05 Required Reviews Completed

邓阿喵 2023-07-02

2023.7.02 under review - This means that something is currently being examined or evaluated on July 2nd, 2023.

邓阿喵 2023-07-02

2023.6.25 Submitted to journal
2023.6.26 With editor
2023.7.01 With editor

Cullinan 2023-06-26

2.23 Submit
3.20 With editor
3.31 Under review
5.3 Minor revision
5.24 Revision submit
6.4 Under review
6.15 Accepted

Translation:
2.23 Submitted
3.20 Being reviewed by the editor
3.31 Currently under review
5.3 Requires minor revision
5.24 Submitted after revision
6.4 Under review
6.15 Accepted

大萌子QAQ 2023-06-21

3.16 with editor
3.23 under review
4.27 returned for revision, two reviewers' comments with 14 points, given 20 days for revisions
5.9 revised
5.26 under review
6.15 accepted
The initial review was quick, but the second review had one reviewer who did not accept the invitation for 20 days. Unable to tolerate it any longer, I directly sent an email asking the editor to resend the invitation. As a result, after 2 days, it was directly accepted. Thanks to the editor!

jz_c 2023-06-14

Hello, do you have any updates now? How long does it take to receive the results after requesting a reviewer completely?

油气终结者 2023-06-10

May 27th: Revised draft returned
May 31st: External review
June 8th: Feedback returned
June 9th: Accept
It took exactly two months from submission to acceptance, and the process was still very fast!

Yaoguojia 2023-06-09

Literal meaning, make changes and replies to these points one by one, add them to the cover letter. If the editor feels that the requirements of the journal have been met, it will be sent for review.

追风er 2023-06-05

Excuse me, everyone, is there a high possibility that the journal will reconsider after making the requested changes? Because the reasons stated by the journal seem very vague, could it be just a polite excuse?

追风er 2023-06-05

2023.05.23 submitted
2023.05.28 with editor
2023.06.05 reject
Not sent for review, rejected directly. I would like to ask everyone if there is still hope for me if I make the changes according to the requirements?
The reason for rejection is as follows: Your manuscript needs improvement. Although readers may be interested in this paper, the manuscript does not meet the quality standards for publication. Please follow the author's guidelines and provide more quantitative results in the abstract, highlights, and conclusion.
Additionally, if you resubmit, please include a more in-depth scientific discussion.

童越浪 2023-06-02

The total time spent on submitting, modifying, and receiving is 39 days.

菜直 2023-06-02

"Required Reviews Complete" has been going on for a week and there hasn't been any change in status. Could it be that it's not going well?"

菜直 2023-06-02

What would be the situation if my Required Reviews Complete has been going on for a week?

追风er 2023-05-31

May I ask why "with editor" takes so long and the time keeps updating several times?

追风er 2023-05-31

May I ask why it takes so long with the editor, and the time has been updated several times? Thank you.