shanmama 2023-08-02

Received email on 7.29: Now that all the checks of your files have been completed, we are pleased to inform you that your manuscript is moving into production to ready it for publication online.

Currently, the system shows "published," but the payment has not been notified yet.

陈颖频 2023-06-28

This publication is very professional, and the review comments are pertinent.

shanmama 2023-05-30

Record the schedule of submission and provide reference for other classmates and teachers:
4.30: Submitted
5.8: All issues resolved
5.11: Deputy editor assigned
Continuously looking for academic editors AE invited and submitted, bouncing back and forth twice
5.29: Found one
5.30: Under review
6.6: Update: Entered pending approval on 6.5
6.18: Major revision
6.28: Submitted after revision, randomly entered under review
7.11: Pending approval
7.26: Accepted for publication

The recent trend of H Publishing: The time spent in the editorial department is long, but the speed of entering external review is accelerated. This paper is no exception. It took a month to enter external review. The total time for two rounds of review does not exceed 20 days, and with my revision time, the entire review process for this paper does not exceed 30 days, leaving several dozen days waiting for news from the editorial department.

Cecilia05 2023-05-11

May I ask what statuses are available? Mine has always been "submitted" and it does not show "under review."

The_Bluebird 2022-11-25

The editor is very responsible, and the four reviewers are also very professional. Experts' opinions on the research content are very pertinent and hit the key points of the paper, which is very helpful for improving the quality of the paper. The editor also provided the opportunity for major revisions. After revising based on the expert's opinions, it was accepted. The journal requires British English and has high language requirements. It is best to proofread it.

zzz12345 2022-03-31

The journal is quite fast after being open source:
1-21 Submission
2-12 Major revision
3-23 Minor revision
3-30 Acceptance
The research topic is quite niche, with only two reviewers. Due to the lack of previous comparisons, the reviewers were not satisfied with the comparison section. After making the modifications, the reviewers still had some suggestions, but the editor decided to accept the paper, which made me very happy. The journal requires British English and prefers proofreading.

thetitleis 2021-08-11

A very professional journal, although it has a low impact factor, it is classified as a third quartile in the JCR. The editor is very responsible, extremely rigorous, and efficient.
Speed: There were two major revisions and two minor revisions. The first external review took 2 and a half months, but subsequent external reviews did not exceed one month.
Review: There are a total of 5 reviewers, among which two are reliable, providing professional and relevant comments. The other three are not very reliable, as their comments only suggest adding references.
Recommendation: It is recommended to have a native speaker proofread the English before submitting the manuscript.

ikon 2021-03-11

2020.10.28 Submission
2020.12.3 Received notice of major revision
2020.12.26 Submitted revised manuscript
2021.2.19 Received acceptance notice