wsakobe 2023-08-04

So you should be getting the result soon, but mine seems to be distant and far from being achieved.

ZKL123 2023-08-04

Did the summer vacation reviewers all take a break? It's only a few days away from your submission date, but it has been three weeks since mine with the associate editor.

wsakobe 2023-07-24

2023.4.12 Under review until now, may I ask how long is the general duration for the first review? Should I remind the AE?

ZKL123 2023-05-25

"Excuse me, is there any result yet? What does the journal status mean?"

XiaoMieMie 2023-03-21

Directly submitted journal
06-July-2022 submitted
17-Oct-2022 major revision
20-Dec-2022 R1 submitted
14-Mar-2023 minor revision
15-Mar-2023 R2 submitted
17-Mar-2023 accepted

会飛的苍狼 2023-02-10

Similar to the process on the 14th floor. After the major revision of the conference, it is recommended for the second review in this journal. After submission, it is "Under review". Three months later, it is "with editor", and the results are available in two weeks. After minor revisions are made and returned, it goes directly to the editor on the next day. The results will be available in two and a half months. The content is fine, but the language needs to be improved. After another month of minor revisions, the results will be available.

pts 2022-12-31

SUBMITTED DECISIONED
1. 30-Jun-2021 14-Feb-2022
2. 13-Apr-2022 15-Sep-2022
3. 21-Sep-2022 05-Oct-2022
4. 13-Oct-2022 29-Dec-2022

The first submission was made to a conference, with four reviewers including one associate editor. Three reviewers gave positive evaluations, while one was stricter. Fortunately, the associate editor thought it was acceptable and suggested submitting it directly to TVCG (Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics). After submitting to TVCG, three new reviewers were assigned. Two gave positive evaluations, but one was exceptionally strict, resulting in a major revision being requested. After making the revisions, minor changes were requested in the feedback. Once those were made, it was stated that it was nearly ready for acceptance, but English writing needed further improvement. After revising the writing, there was a two-month wait before finally receiving acceptance. The conclusion is that the reviewers' comments were strict and the process was somewhat slow.

PengZhang23 2022-11-22

Hello, have you received the initial review results for your paper? Mine has been under review for two and a half months.

AplusX 2022-09-08

Top computer graphics journal, the review process was exceptionally fast this time.
Two months later, major revisions were requested.
After the revisions were made, a week was given for minor revisions.
After the revisions were made, I was asked to polish the English and another round of minor revisions was given.
After the revisions were made, the paper was accepted on the same day.
Surprisingly fast, in the past, the initial review took five months.

LLLLLQismeee 2022-08-12

Hello, may I ask if the status "Under review" for this journal means it has been sent for external review? It has been in this status since I submitted it, almost two months ago. Or does it mean that "Under Review" in capital letters indicates external review?

Charlie Yang 2022-05-24

Here's an update. The paper was ultimately rejected. There were two reviewers in total. One gave a major revision and had a high evaluation of the work in the paper. The other gave a rejection, completely misunderstanding the direction of the paper and criticizing the work based on some well-known researchers, stating that although their work was of high level and relatively new, it was far worse than the one published by XXX 10 years ago (suspected to be the reviewer, as this person's work was mentioned multiple times in the comments). Finally, the Associate Editor (AE) gave a rejection. Currently, the paper has been revised and we plan to resubmit it to TVCG, hoping for better luck and not encountering such an odd reviewer this time.

liucs 2022-01-15

After being entrusted for nearly a year, it was rejected without any feedback from AE. The main comments from two reviewers were that certain articles were not cited and there was no innovation. Recently, in several published articles, we found methods very similar to ours, which were submitted at least three to four months after ours. We seriously doubt the academic ethics of TVCG and will no longer submit our work to this journal in the future.

shawnsong 2022-01-12

Hello, TVCG is under submission. After four months of undergoing major revisions and being under review, it has now moved to the stage of "with associate editor". However, it has been over five weeks with the associate editor and no decision has been made yet. I wonder if I should send an email to the Associate Editor to inquire about the status? How long has your "with associate editor" status lasted?

shawnsong 2022-01-12

Hello, TVCG is under submission. After four months of undergoing major revisions, it has transitioned from "under review" to "with associate editor." However, it has been over five weeks since then, and no decision has been given yet. I'm wondering if I should send an email to the associate editor to inquire about the status?

liucs 2021-12-17

I have also published some articles on various transactions. TVCG is the most delayed in the review process (there were two occasions where it took 7-10 months just for the first round), and every time I emailed to inquire, it took at least half a month to receive a reply, or sometimes no response at all. For more important work, it is better to submit to TIP, TOG, and various conferences that are more reliable.

Charlie Yang 2021-11-24

02-Sep-2021 submit - After submission, it has been under review.
24-Nov-2021 With Associate Editor - It is estimated that the review process is complete, and the Associate Editor is making a decision.

vitoria 2021-08-16

Are the three months you mentioned until the job offer? Or is it the time it takes for each review? How long does it take for you to review it for the first time?

vitoria 2021-08-16

Do you have any results now? I have been waiting for almost two months, and there is still no outcome from the first review.

AplusX 2021-03-19

The speed of review is randomly chosen. I submitted it in January 2021, and there is still no news. How long is everyone's review cycle?