一只小木虫虫虫虫 2023-08-09

2023.06.26 manuscript submitted
2023.07.08 with editor
2023.07.19 under review
2023.07.26 under review

Translated:
2023.06.26 manuscript submitted
2023.07.08 with editor
2023.07.19 under review
2023.07.26 under review

drtfvjbniujnucrttfyguhjkzxcvbn 2023-08-08

Under review has undergone multiple changes, including the addition of new reviewers. Does anyone know about this? The editor invited reviewers, but they either declined or the invitation time expired, so new reviewers were invited. It is not likely that a specific reviewer has completed and submitted their review comments, nor is it the case that reviewers or editors have logged in to check the status of the manuscript.

drtfvjbniujnucrttfyguhjkzxcvbn 2023-08-08

Under review has undergone multiple changes, indicating the addition of new reviewers. The editor invites reviewers, but if they decline or the invitation time expires, new reviewers are invited. It is unlikely that a specific reviewer has completed and submitted their review, nor is it the case that reviewers or editors have logged in to view the status of the manuscript.

Guerrouj 2023-08-08

2023.8.02 manuscript submitted
2023.8.07 sent back to author & submitted
Waiting for further updates

名字_科研新手 2023-08-08

3.4K+ and still no results.

CocoSEU 2023-08-07

Today, the UR has changed again. Maybe they really did add more reviewers, but it's really strange that they are still looking for additional reviewers for the second review.

drtfvjbniujnucrttfyguhjkzxcvbn 2023-08-07

Under Review has undergone multiple changes, is there a new reviewer joining? The editor invites reviewers, but if the reviewers do not respond or exceed the invitation time, then new reviewers are invited. It is unlikely that a specific reviewer has completed and submitted review comments, nor is it the reviewer or editor logging in to check the status of the manuscript.

到二仙桥 2023-08-06

I also received such a response, but after considering the opinions, it requires two minor repairs and one major repair.

ghbj 2023-08-06

What is the situation with the first instance of 5 URs? Still no RRC until now.

CocoSEU 2023-08-06

So, your first review for minor repairs is pretty much stable, huh? I have 3 major repairs in my first review, and 4 in the second review. I have no idea what went wrong, and it's making me anxious.

到二仙桥 2023-08-06

May I ask, how long did it take for you to resubmit after being rejected? Did you receive multiple review comments after rejection? The email states that I cannot resubmit within three weeks. However, I feel that all three review comments can be easily addressed.

absolutian 2023-08-05

In the first review, there were only two reviewers for my paper. One reviewer had no issues, while the other raised good questions which were easily addressed. The editor provided minor revisions. In the second review, on August 1st, it showed "decision in process," but on August 5th, it changed to "under review."

CocoSEU 2023-08-05

2023.4.18 10:10am manuscript submitted
2023.5.5 5:00am with editor
2023.5.10 8:36am under review
2023.5.18 4:16am under review
2023.5.23 2:08am under review
2023.7.13 4:52am decision in process
2023.7.13 12:04pm major revision
2023.7.21 9:07am revised manuscript submitted
2023.7.26 9:08pm with editor
2023.7.27 5:44am under review
2023.7.30 4:48am under review
2023.8.2 3:45am under review
2023.8.4 1:28am under review

I would like to ask the experts, why is there frequent change in the status (ur) during the second review, even though there were three changes during the first review and two reviewers provided comments, which were not very critical?

ghbj 2023-08-05

Has the original poster not come up with a result yet?

liuweibboy 2023-08-04

Unbelievably slow, it's been 2 months and still with editor.

liuweibboy 2023-08-04

I won a paper before, which was submitted at the beginning of last semester, but it was only completed near the end of this semester. Recently, I submitted another paper, but it has been with the editor for 2 months. It makes me want to withdraw it. This journal is really slow. Students and teachers who want to quickly produce results should be mentally prepared!

玫瑰花的葬礼咦 2023-08-02

Date (2023) Status
May 01 Manuscript submitted
May 20 Sent back (check page numbering)
May 20 Re-submit
May 21 With editor
May 22 Under Review
May 23 Under Review
May 28 Under Review
May 29 Under Review
Jun 08 Under Review
Jun 24 Required Reviews Completed
Jun 27 Required Reviews Completed
Jul 05 Decision in Process
Jul 08 Major revision
Jul 28 Revised Manuscript Submitted

ghbj 2023-08-01

How is it now?

ghbj 2023-08-01

Until today, there have been 5 different time points under review.

风之小翼 2023-08-01

According to experience, either it remains unchanged, or it changes 5-6 times before yielding results.

ghbj 2023-07-31

My under review period has changed 3 times in one month.

ghbj 2023-07-31

What does the change in different "under review" times mean? Does it mean that the reviewer has submitted their review comments?

脱发小卫星 2023-07-31

2023.05.24 manuscript submitted
2023.06.10 with editor
2023.06.27 under review
2023.07.31 under review

This journal is so slow. I feel like it's been four months already and I haven't heard anything. Does anyone know why it takes so long for "under review" to change? Did the first reviewer not review it?

ghbj 2023-07-31

What is your manuscript number? Isn't the normal peer review process for Tim three weeks?

ghbj 2023-07-30

Hasn't the result come out yet?

名字_科研新手 2023-07-30

2023.6.19 manuscript submitted
2023.7.1 send back to author & submitted
2023.7.1 with editor
2023.7.3 under review
2023.7.11 under review
2023.7.15 under review
2023.7.23 under review

Translated to English:

2023.6.19 Manuscript submitted
2023.7.1 Sent back to the author & submitted
2023.7.1 With editor
2023.7.3 Under review
2023.7.11 Under review
2023.7.15 Under review
2023.7.23 Under review

pourchopin 2023-07-29

under review, the date remains unchanged; two reviewers.

ghbj 2023-07-29

Does "under review" have a time change?

科研舔狗 2023-07-29

Congratulations. How come your second review is so fast? How many reviewers are there?

pourchopin 2023-07-29

2023.04.18 - Manuscript Submitted
2023.05.04 - Sent back to author & Submitted
2023.05.04 - With Editor
2023.05.08 - With Editor
2023.05.26 - Under Review
2023.06.19 - Required Reviews Completed
2023.06.21 - Decision in Process
2023.06.22 - Major Revision
2023.07.11 - Revised Manuscript Submitted
2023.07.14 - With Editor
2023.07.24 - Under Review
2023.07.27 - Required Reviews Completed
2023.07.27 - Decision in Process
2023.07.28 - Decision in Process
2023.07.28 - Accept