ssgrl 2023-07-18

Indeed, investing in TBME now is too much of a loss, it's better to directly invest in TMI and MIA. This is already the fourth time investing in TBME, and it's becoming increasingly unfriendly.

Gau 2023-07-14

EIC: xxx
ADM: Admin, TBME Under review

Translation: EIC stands for "Editor-in-Chief" and ADM stands for "Admin." The message states that the TBME (possibly a journal or publication) is currently under review.

忍者饿了 2023-07-13

Like me, recently most of the TBME submissions shared on Letpub have been rejected. The threshold is still very high, it's too difficult.

ssgrl 2023-07-13

I recently submitted another paper, which took three months to be reviewed by two reviewers. One gave a positive review while the other gave a negative one, resulting in a tragic outcome. I feel like the reviewers didn't fully understand the significance of the task, and my own writing wasn't great either. Oh well, I guess this job is going to be a failure for me...

fantasydyz 2023-07-13

18 days later, it was rejected by EIC (ADM not assigned).
Rejection message:
TBME receives a large number of papers on various areas in biomedical engineering; as a result, the threshold for acceptance is high and we have to prescreen all submissions to determine if it's fitting for TBME. The associate editor handling the review suggests submitting it to a more specialized journal.

PHDing 2023-07-12

Looking forward to your subsequent updates.

PHDing 2023-07-11

My experience is...

fantasydyz 2023-07-10

The meaning is that the editor intends to reject it directly...

PHDing 2023-07-10

The name of the editor is not available, the situation is not very good.

fantasydyz 2023-07-10

It has been 16 days.....administrator is still ADM: Admin, TBME.

fantasydyz 2023-07-03

Based on my understanding, the search for a reviewer is ongoing, and there will be no changes until the review comments are received.

May8535 2023-07-03

Posted on 2023-06-19, added Associate Editor as ADM on 2023-07-03. The submission status has been "Under review" all along. I would like to know the current status: Has it returned from external review? Has it been sent for external review? Or is it still being decided whether to send it for external review?

May8535 2023-07-03

The submission status has been "Under review" all along. I want to know what stage it is now: has it come back from external review? Has it been sent for external review? Or is it still in the stage of deciding whether to send it for external review?

May8535 2023-07-03

Posted on June 19, 2023, and assigned the deputy editor as ADM on July 2, 2023.

fantasydyz 2023-06-27

I feel like the EIC review is completed and handed over to the AE.

fantasydyz 2023-06-27

Excuse me, how many days does it take for UR to change from EIC to AE (name appears)?

fantasydyz 2023-06-25

2023/06/24 Submission, Under Review: EIC

PHDing 2023-06-05

Posted for 18 days, haven't updated the ADM name, feeling cold.

beluckyqiuqiu 2023-06-05

Is this journal very difficult to get published in now? I feel like all the feedback I've seen is rejection. Worrying (ㄒoㄒ)/~~

忍者饿了 2023-06-02

I updated the adm name 9 days after submitting it.

PHDing 2023-05-30

It has been almost two weeks since the submission, and there is still no specific ADM assigned. Previously, a few days after the submission, the third line would display the ADM's name. I'm getting anxious.

忍者饿了 2023-05-29

5.29, updated two months after submission:
It has been rejected. The opinions of the two reviewers were not bad, but the editor still chose to reject it. TBME maintains an acceptance rate of 20%, and the following is a part of the rejection letter:
So while the reviewers' comments to the authors may sometimes read as addressable, we can only accept a small portion of submissions we receive and must reject some papers ranked lower by reviewers (FYI, the current acceptance rate of TBME is about 20%).

PHDing 2023-05-17

Before making a decision, there is no change in the status. If the status changes, it means that a "decision made" email has already been sent to your mailbox.

PHDing 2023-05-17

There is no change in status before making a decision. If there is a change in status, it means that a "decision made" email has already been sent to your mailbox.

忍者饿了 2023-05-16

No change, still big U small R.

灌水小达人 2023-05-14

What is the current status now? Already invested and same as you now.

忍者饿了 2023-04-24

Posted on 3.29

忍者饿了 2023-04-24

The status of 4.24 has not changed yet, and it is still unknown whether it will be submitted for review or not. It is still Ur (capital U, small r).

xuliri 2023-04-07

The IEEE submission status change information is relatively minimal compared to some journals from Elsevier, which are more detailed. The status can change from submission to receiving revisions or being rejected. On March 29th, the submission status was "Under review," with ADM (Admin) and TBME. On April 7th, the status remained "Under review," but the ADM changed to a specific person (Editor's name). It is unclear what it means for the ADM to change from Admin to a specific person, and the current status is unknown. I hope experienced individuals can share their insights.

PHDing 2023-03-29

You have only been invested for a few days, and it has been under review before making a decision.