派大星同学 2023-08-09

May I ask if any classmates know when we will receive the galley proof notification after the IEEE TAES journal accepts our paper? The teacher doesn't check the email often, and I'm worried about missing the galley proof deadline.

天纸 2023-08-08

Submission Record
● First Review
● 2023.02.06
● Submitted
● 2023.05.12
● Major Revision
● Second Review
● 2023.05.25
● A revision has been submitted
● 2023.06.17
● Minor Revision
● Third Review
● 2023.06.23
● A revision has been submitted
● 2023.06.26
● Awaiting Reviewer Assignment
● 2023.06.28
● Awaiting Reviewer Scores
● 2023.08.06
● Accept
● Follow-up Actions
● 2023.08.08
● Generate DOI
● Submit Copyright Agreement

djx666 2023-08-03

May I ask about the subsequent results? My process is exactly the same as yours!

初九 2023-07-18

2023-03-10 submitted (First submission)
2023-05-24 submitted (Major revision submission)
2023-07-16 Accepted

初九 2023-07-18

2023-04-10 Awaiting Reviewer Scores
2023-05-10 Major Revision
2023-05-24 Submitted
2023-07-15 Awaiting AE Recommendation
2023-07-16 Accepted

Translated:

2023-04-10 Awaiting Reviewer Scores
2023-05-10 Major Revision
2023-05-24 Submitted
2023-07-15 Awaiting AE Recommendation
2023-07-16 Accepted

小能手2154 2023-07-18

Hello, may I ask how it turned out in the end? What happened?

小能手2154 2023-07-18

Hello, may I ask how things turned out in the end?

cl_898 2023-07-12

Direction for navigation, there are two reviewers, the first review takes 3 months, and the review result requires major revisions. Only one and a half months are given for the modifications, and after the modifications are submitted, another one and a half months are allowed for feedback acceptance.
Submission on January 9, 2023.
First review with major revisions on April 17, 2023.
Modification submission on May 28, 2023.
Acceptance on July 11, 2023.

带刀中卫 2023-06-26

2022 10.16 Submit - Submitted on October 16, 2022
2022 10.17 Under Reviewer Assignment - Undergoing reviewer assignment on October 17, 2022
2022 10 27 Under Reviewer Scores - Undergoing reviewer scores on October 27, 2022
2023 01 06 Major Revision - Major revision required on January 6, 2023
2023 02 14 Revision Submitted - Revised version submitted on February 14, 2023
2023 04 02 Major Revision - Major revision required on April 2, 2023
2023 05 07 Revision Submitted - Revised version submitted on May 7, 2023
2023 06 26 Accept - Accepted on June 26, 2023

upupupup 2023-06-24

Yes, I have paid both of them.

DA1018 2023-06-21

Hello, may I ask if you submit both double-column and single-column when submitting your contribution?

DA1018 2023-06-21

Hello, may I ask if you submit both double-column and single-column when submitting a manuscript?

DA1018 2023-06-21

Hello, may I ask if you submitted both double-column and single-column when you submitted your contribution?

upupupup 2023-06-05

The thesis has been in the awaiting AE recommendation stage for over three weeks. Should I remind them?

beehater 2023-06-04

Excuse me, is it normal for "Awaiting EIC Decision" to take more than a week?

Hi空白 2023-05-22

In general, it is better to reply with an attachment. Respond to each reviewer's comments sentence by sentence, including the Associate Editor (AE), to make it formal and maintain a neat format.

Hi空白 2023-05-22

awaiting reviewer scores means waiting for reviewer ratings; the next steps are waiting for all reviewers to rate--> AE rating--> CIE rating--> response. Reviewers usually take 1.5-2 months; AE typically takes one month; the following steps are faster, and the overall time for the review process is usually 3-5 months. Good luck!

LK 2023-05-14

After the first round of modifications and submission, a period of time passed and it changed from "Awaiting Reviewer Scores" to "Awaiting AE Recommendation". However, after a few days, it changed back to "Awaiting Reviewer Scores" again. Does it mean that the result was not good and they had to find other reviewers?

拉普拉斯啦 2023-05-09

Hello, may I ask if in the first step of submitting a major revision, the "response" means briefly describing the modifications made (and later uploading a file as a response)? Or does it refer to providing detailed answers to each reviewer's comments, as mentioned in the attachment "response to reviewers"?

拉普拉斯啦 2023-05-09

Hello, OP. May I ask about the first step of submitting a major revision? Is the "response" simply a brief summary of the modifications made (with the uploaded file requiring an additional response), or is it a detailed answer to each reviewer's comments, as mentioned in the attachment "response to reviewers"?

拉普拉斯啦 2023-05-09

Hello, original poster. May I ask if the "response" mentioned in the first step of the major revision reply refers to simply writing a brief description of the modifications made (and later uploading a file as a response), or is it required to provide detailed responses to each reviewer's comments, as specified in the attachment "response to reviewers"?

ozoz 2023-05-04

This is related to the chief editor of this publication, with a time limit sometimes.

冲冲冲丶 2023-05-03

Hello, may I ask how to solve the problem that modifying the single column in the latex template does not work? Is it a problem with the IEEEtaes.cls file?

dushanhe 2023-05-03

Hello, the field I have invested in is the guidance control system field in TAES. I have been looking for AE for a month, and it is incredibly slow. I see that you are very fast, may I ask which field you have invested in?

dushanhe 2023-05-03

Hello, I also applied for TAES. The field I applied for is guidance control system. I've been looking for AE for a month now, and it's incredibly slow. I see that you're very fast. What field did you apply for?

ozoz 2023-05-02

4.25 submission,
4.26 reply with added single-column format
4.28 add single column
4.30 assigned senior editor
5.1 arrange associate editor, status: Awaiting Reviewer Selection
5.23 status: Awaiting Reviewer Invitation
6.3 status: Awaiting Reviewer Scores

落絮 2023-04-12

I have been in this state since I submitted it on January 31st.

Hi空白 2023-03-29

Submission to first review notice results took: 3 months
Notice of major revision - Major revision took: 1 and a half months (self-delayed)
Submission of major revision - Acceptance notice: around 2 months
Submission to acceptance took: around 7 months
High industry recognition, top journal, 3 reviewers in total, reviewers are professional and meticulous!

upupupup 2023-03-27

Is it normal to still be awaiting reviewer assignment since March 1st?

港岛哥哥 2023-03-22

It is really a bit too slow, with no news at all.