Mr.ZHU 2023-08-08

8.2 返稿 translates to "8.2 Return manuscript."
8.7 accept translates to "8.7 accept."

Mr.ZHU 2023-07-30

Micro motor field
Submission on 7.13
Minor revisions completed in 7 days on 7.28
The speed is really fast. The results are also very good, with almost no negative feedback.
I believe that I did a good job on this work. Unfortunately, I didn't have much luck and didn't win the TIE submission.
However, being quickly recognized by EDL is also quite good.

龙里 2023-07-20

It's really important to be lucky when submitting to this journal. Encountering a suitable editor is your first step to success, followed by finding suitable reviewers, and also depends on whether you have influential authors. I submitted a work that I believed to be world-leading, but it was rejected during the second round of review. The first round had two reviewers, while the second round had five! Among the five reviewers, four said they were very interested in the article but suggested adding some content, and one accepted it directly. Five of them! Just one sentence from each reviewer made the editor think that the article would require major revisions, which goes against the spirit of the journal and the second round of review does not allow major revisions. I give up, really. I accepted the rejection of my article, but I'm afraid that my work will be copied by the reviewers.

资深柚子 2023-06-30

Generally, if an article has not been rejected for a week, it is already sent for review, and the editors will only see the status "UNDER REVIEW" during the processing.

zlq1990 2023-06-11

Top journal in the field of electronic devices, with high requirements for innovation and authoritative in the research field.

噜噜噜1 2023-06-04

Does anyone know if the uppercase "Under Review" means it's under review? It has been in this status for a month...

咸鱼fly 2023-04-26

What is the positioning of EDL, why is it in the second district and not top?

rourou554 2022-12-16

The text "2022-12-15 Reject" is already in English.

rourou554 2022-12-14

2022-12-2 Under Review
2022-12-13 Awaiting Decision Approval

rourou554 2022-12-05

Submitted, waiting for the results.

luner 2022-08-24

Xiao Xiu has accepted.

luner 2022-05-26

The review comments took 21 days to return. The major revisions have been resubmitted and we are waiting for the results.

xwei 2022-03-11

11-Mar-2022 Accept As Is

Translation: Accept as it is on March 11, 2022.

xwei 2022-02-19

10-Jan-2022 Awaiting ED preliminary decision
20-Jan-2022 Sent a Reminder letter to ADM
20-Jan-2022 Awaiting Decision Approval
22-Jan-2022 Major Revisions/Reject and Resubmit (22-Jan-2022)
30-Jan-2022 Under review
7-Feb-2022 Awaiting ED Preliminary Decision
16-Feb-2022 Awaiting Decision Approval
17-Feb-2022 Minor Revision
18-Feb-2022 Awaiting ED Preliminary Decision

LhAFb 2022-02-15

IEEE EDL in the past two years, those who understand know that they must submit something that is either the first or the most in order to have a chance of being repaired/accepted. The review process is very professional and fast, so it's worth trying if you have good work.
2021.11.24 Re-submitted; 2021.12.06 Accept.

luner 2022-01-13

Is the submitted manuscript adjusted to the template format of this journal? Do I need to do the typesetting myself?

xwei 2022-01-10

10-Jan-2022 (Mon) Awaiting ED Preliminary Decision
Christmas seems to be slower.

匿名吧狗狗 2021-12-22

The quality of this journal paper is uneven. The chances of acceptance in this journal rely heavily on luck and the connection with the editors. Some reviewers in certain research areas are also not professional. When you only have simulated data, they reject the paper claiming lack of experimental evidence. When you have experimental data, they reject the paper directly stating insufficient innovation and data. The rejection letter initially suggests submitting to another journal and the reviewer's comments are not professional.

早日毕业 2021-12-21

I also don't know if it's important or not, but I have submitted a cover letter.

xwei 2021-12-17

03-Dec-2021(Fri) 投稿 Awaiting Admin Processing
Translation: 03-Dec-2021(Fri) Submission Awaiting Admin Processing

06-Dec-2021(Mon) under review
Translation: 06-Dec-2021(Mon) under review

yutian0228 2021-12-13

Is this journal cover letter important?

早日毕业 2021-11-25

2021.07.26 Submission
2021.09.04 Major revision
2021.09.14 Resubmission
2021.10.06 Acceptance
2021.11.25 Published
During my master's studies, this is my first paper. The journal has very strict formatting requirements, and it was returned to me two or three times due to format issues.
There were two reviewers, one approved the work, while the other mentioned a lack of innovation. The editor ultimately requested a major revision, which was submitted again after ten days of modifications, and it was accepted.
I have fulfilled the graduation requirements, and I am happy.
I hope the journal continues to improve.

dsz 2021-03-24

2021.1.25 Submission
2021.2.26 Rejected and Resubmitted
2021.3.12 Resubmitted
2021.3.22 Accepted
Last year, I failed the EDL challenge around this time. This year, I challenged it again and succeeded. I often come here to read comments, and today I am checking in myself.
I suggest prioritizing breakthrough and innovative achievements. I wish every diligent researcher good results.