论文接收啦 2023-07-16

My submission was marked as "Under Review" in uppercase on the second day. Does this mean it has already been sent for external review???

论文接收啦 2023-07-16

Submitted on July 13, 2023, and displayed as "Under Review" on July 14. May I ask when the review results are usually expected?

论文接收啦 2023-07-15

I have read what everyone said, and it seems very slow. I am a bit hesitant about whether this journal will be slow or not.

论文接收啦 2023-07-15

Does this cycle have to be this long?

论文接收啦 2023-07-15

Is it true? Is "Under Review" in capital letters already under review?

论文接收啦 2023-07-15

Is this journal really that slow?

dadada 2023-06-30

May I ask if your status "Under Review" should be capitalized or not?

小博努力变强 2023-06-28

I submitted my paper in late April, and it has been under review for over two months. Is this journal known for being slow in the review process? Does the journal not set any deadlines for reviewers? I need help!

Anne3316 2023-06-06

Ah? This journal is so slow?

ASDFASDFSADF 2023-06-06

Submitted On 1 March 2023 by
2023.6.6 Still under review, no updates yet.

Anne3316 2023-06-06

Really? Is "under review" in lowercase letters the same as editorial review?

郑氏集团老总 2023-04-04

Submitted in mid-August 2022, accepted in early April 2023. I would like to express my gratitude to the two reviewers for their valuable comments, which have improved the quality of the paper. I would also like to thank Chief Editor Hong, as well as the editorial department. I hope and look forward to FFEMS achieving Q1 in Zone 1.

ASDFASDFSADF 2023-03-05

Submission Experience:
投稿经验 (Chinese)
Submission Status: Under Review
看到这个是大写的 Under Review，不知道是不是送审了，有的说小写的 under review 是编辑审，大写的是送审了？

Translation:
Submission Experience:
Submission Status: Under Review
Seeing that it is capitalized as "Under Review," I am not sure if it has been sent for review. Some say that when it is written in lowercase as "under review," it refers to editorial review, while when it is written in uppercase, it indicates that it has been sent for review.

成长的小树 2022-12-24

Hello, I have also encountered a similar problem. I cannot upload with the new system, and it always shows "something went wrong". Have you ever experienced this?

成长的小树 2022-12-24

Hello, I would like to inquire whether you are uploading revised drafts on the new platform or the old platform in FFEMS. It is required to upload on the new platform, but every time I encounter a "something went wrong" error. Have you experienced this issue before?

郑氏集团老总 2022-12-11

How many reviewers are there generally?

Superman 2022-11-17

May I ask, is the "under review" of this journal an internal review or an external review?

哎呀喂 2022-09-22

Hello! I returned the revised manuscript through the new system at https://wiley.atyponrex.com/ and received a successful submission message. However, the editor cannot see the manuscript. I have communicated with the editor several times, but they still cannot see the manuscript and don't know why. I would like to ask if you returned the revised manuscript through https://wiley.atyponrex.com/ or submitted it through the old system at https://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/ffems for revision?

li1111 2022-07-28

The text has been revised three times, and one of the experts was very serious and responsible. The article has improved significantly.
In the first round of review, there were three reviewers. One suggested minor revisions, one suggested major revisions, and one rejected the manuscript. The editor provided the necessary modifications.
In the second round, one reviewer accepted the revised manuscript, one suggested minor revisions, and one rejected it.
In the third round, the reviewer raised another question regarding the modifications made and suggested minor revisions. After the revisions, the manuscript was accepted.
The manuscript was submitted on March 28, 2022.
The first revision was done on May 26, 2022.
The second revision was done on June 23, 2022.
The third revision was done on July 18, 2022.
The manuscript was accepted on July 22, 2022.

li1111 2022-07-22

Three reviewers agreed to accept it, and the editor gave minor revisions. The overall process was very fast. The journal is getting better and better.

2021-11-28: Submission
2021-12-29: Minor amendments
2022-01-17: A revision has been submitted
2022-01-27: Accepted

Geotechnics5454 2022-06-30

Hello, boss! May I ask if all authors need to receive an email and confirm for this FFEMS submission?

BiberPeng 2022-05-16

Hello, may I ask how long it takes for the review process after submission? After I submitted, it has been in the "Submitted" status and I haven't received a manuscript number either.

血色残阳 2022-04-16

The final acceptance after two major revisions... It was tough for two rounds, a response of 10,000 words, but it was worth it.
2021-11-19: submit
2022-01-09: major revision
2022-01-28: submit
2022-03-26: major revision
2022-03-29: submit
2022-04-14: accept

金达UP主 2022-04-02

It has already been submitted for review.

血色残阳 2022-03-29

Second revision, just two issues, wish myself good luck.

湘亚 2022-03-22

The review speed is fast, especially after revision, results can be obtained in about a week. Looking forward to FFEMS becoming Q1 soon.

frgjfrghfsgh 2022-03-14

I would like to ask, my status is "under review" in capital letters, but the "review assigned" section has been showing for two weeks in the pre-publication area. Does this mean it has been sent for review?

金达UP主 2021-07-21

The second submission of FFEMS was on May 20th, and the feedback was received on June 21st, suggesting major revisions. The revised version was resubmitted on July 12th and accepted on July 20th. There were a total of four experts who reviewed my manuscript and provided numerous suggestions. After making the necessary modifications, the quality of the article significantly improved. I am especially grateful for the diligent efforts of the editor and the reviewing experts and hope that the journal will continue to improve.

岩土小勺 2021-04-19

Excuse me, sir, is there any requirement for the formatting of the paper when submitting it?

岩土小勺 2021-04-19

May I ask if there are any requirements for typesetting the manuscript if I submit it?