yo你一生一世 2023-08-08

How about yours? My second review has been 4 months now, and there is still one reviewer who hasn't replied with their comments.

Lee 2023-07-22

Posted on March 16th, it has been over four months now. A total of 21 reviewers have been invited, and the manuscript has been reminded twice. Only received a template reply once. I am a third-year graduate student, and I'm graduating next year. I'm so anxious. The teacher suggested that I withdraw the submission and submit it again. It showed that the external review process ended this morning, but only one reviewer has completed it. I don't know if there is a problem.

yo你一生一世 2023-07-17

I have not urged yet. The first trial was quite fast, but I don't know why the second trial is so slow. The main reason is that the second reviewer has not responded.

F-GG 2023-07-17

Have you ever reminded them to submit the manuscript in the middle? The review process has been in a dip state since then, and it has been going on for a month and a half.

yo你一生一世 2023-07-16

Both reviewers have requested major revisions. After the first round of revisions on April 20th, it was under review on May 4th. On May 11th, one reviewer provided feedback, and it is still under review awaiting feedback from the second reviewer.

dragonlord 2023-07-13

How long does it usually take from "with editor" to "under review"?

F-GG 2023-07-09

I haven't received any news about my trial, it has been over a month.

爱种水稻的小林 2023-07-09

Mine is also like this. The external review took only one month. I sent it to 2+ reviewers, and then received comments from both reviewers. After that, it was rejected. It has been two weeks now, and I haven't received any information. If it was bad news, they could have made a decision directly. I guess they are waiting for the third opinion. If they are waiting for the third reviewer's opinion, why did it change from RRC to DIP? Maybe they feel it is too quick and want to extend the review period.

F-GG 2023-06-21

The external audit has ended, CCR took one or two days, and now it has been a month since "Decision in Process", but still no news.

F-GG 2023-06-12

Yes, it feels like it. After submitting, it has been over 20 days and still no news.

远山.ZZZ 2023-06-12

Is the direct DIP with the editor broken?

峰-107 2023-05-25

How long?

yo你一生一世 2023-05-14

After major revisions (by two reviewers), it was resubmitted. The review process started on April 20th, with two reviewers (uncertain if they are the original reviewers). On May 3rd, one reviewer completed the evaluation, while the other has not provided their feedback yet. On May 9th, a new manuscript was submitted, and on May 11th, the new manuscript is under review.

汝 2023-03-14

After I made minor revisions in the first review, I received it and have been working with the editor continuously after uploading the revised draft. I'm afraid that the editor will submit it for review again.

麻城阿宝 2023-03-13

Will they find new reviewers for the second review?

Gene+Model+Wheat 2023-03-13

My second review can be delayed for 7 months because we have not been able to find a reviewer.

springbo 2023-03-09

Hey, it's been three months since it was reviewed. I won't be in a hurry anymore when I see that you have been reviewing for four months!!

springbo 2023-03-09

Super slow!!! It has been three months since the submission, and it is still under external review.

汝 2023-03-06

2022.12.19 Submitted to journal
2023.1.7 Under review
2023.3.3 Acceptable after minor revision
2023.3.6 Revised status immediately changed to With Editor
2023.3.9-3.27 No updates on the status with the editor
2023.3.28 Under review
2023.4.6 Peer review comments received
2023.4.24 Accepted

yo你一生一世 2023-03-01

It has been reviewed for 4 months, and it feels like it will never end.

wudixiaofu 2023-02-10

Accepted on August 18th, published online on August 23rd, took about 5 months in total, quite fast.

2020加油 2022-11-06

August 27th submission
No news yet

Gene+Model+Wheat 2022-10-27

During the second review, more reviewers will be added, so we can only wait patiently. The postdoctoral fellow who has not yet published has been working hard to accumulate achievements, which is not easy.

寒天晨晨 2022-10-25

Dude, you have achieved quite a bit. This journal is said to be quite slow. It usually takes around 8-9 months for publication.

Gene+Model+Wheat 2022-10-14

I can't believe it, I want to withdraw the manuscript. The key is that there is another one under review, and I don't know when it will be reviewed.

爱种水稻的小林 2022-10-14

Yes, I was the first round with two reviewers, the second round also had two reviewers, and the third round had one reviewer who accepted it, and then another reviewer was sought for arbitration. In the last round, it was only accepted after being sent to the reviewers. The review process of this journal is currently very slow, so be cautious about submitting. The main issue is that they keep adding reviewers in the subsequent rounds, which is quite intense.

Gene+Model+Wheat 2022-10-14

Why is this journal so slow now? The first review required major revisions and there was only one reviewer who provided over a hundred comments. It was finally completed after much difficulty. The second review has been under review for almost three months now. We have urged the reviewer, who said that one reviewer has not agreed to review yet. I don't understand this situation.

爱种水稻的小林 2022-10-10

Tonight, we received it and went through three major repairs. Finally, we succeeded as planned, taking a total of 8 months.

爱种水稻的小林 2022-10-10

After the third major revision on October 10th, it turned into a decision, praying for minor revisions or accepting it directly. It's so torturous, so slow, so difficult to submit. This journal...

Gene+Model+Wheat 2022-07-27

Hello, is it "with editor-under review-require reviews completed" after the major revision is returned? Approximately how long does it take from "with editor" to "completed"?