YuP.John.B 2023-08-09

It has been almost a week since receiving the proof.

billmr 2023-08-08

May I ask how long it took between being accepted and receiving the proof?

billmr 2023-08-08

May I ask how long is the gap between "accepted" and "proof"?

YuP.John.B 2023-08-07

3.14 Successful appeal, editor asks for resubmission
4.10 Resubmit it
5.2 Major revisions have returned (editor asks for revisions to be done by 5.31, busy graduation season + preparation of materials again, requested extension until 6.30)
6.29 Revised
7.4 Minor revisions have returned
7.8 Revised
7.14 Accepted

billmr 2023-08-06

2023.6.20.2 submitted
2023.6.25 under review
2023.7.12 major revision, 3 reviewers, minor revisions 5%, major revisions 15%, rejected. Thank you to the editor for their support!
2023.7.25 revisions requested
2023.8.2 accepted
Thank you to Dr. Brenton Hammer for editing, the processing speed was incredibly fast :), and also thank you to the reviewers for recognizing our work!

smy11 2023-08-06

Yes, it's still the same situation. It's too slow to seek.

CCW123 2023-08-06

No news, still in submitted status. Has it been two weeks and still in submit status on your end?

smy11 2023-08-05

I have also been 14 days, and I haven't reached the editor yet. Have you received any news about yours?

CCW123 2023-08-04

Recently, I feel that time is passing by so slowly. Does anyone know if it's normal for a submission to still be in the "submitted" status after a week? Does it mean that the editor hasn't processed it yet?

Jumpdowner 2023-08-04

May I ask how the submission status is for these experts? Why is the AM so slow?

123lululu 2023-08-03

8.1 Under Review Continue to wait

Jumpdowner 2023-08-01

Haha, if there is any progress later, I will update it again.

ylqueen123 2023-08-01

Can the original poster update the submission date, the date of editing, and the date of review?

Jumpdowner 2023-08-01

Why is AM so slow now? It has been 11 days since submission and it is still marked as "submitted".

拔了萝卜 2023-07-28

If there is no update from the editor for about a week, it means that it has been sent for review. Sometimes, even if it has been sent for review, the status may not change.

123lululu 2023-07-28

Submission experience:
6.30 Manuscript submitted
7.11 With editor
I submitted a review article, and it is still with the editor. Does it mean it hasn't been sent for review yet? Could someone from HXD help clarify? ☺

青黛不改 2023-07-27

Excuse me, how many days does it usually take for the editor to know if it will be submitted for review? It has been three days since I submitted it to the editor.

拔了萝卜 2023-07-27

2023.07.27 accepted translates to "2023 July 27th accepted" in English.

一枚大头 2023-07-26

Hello, may I ask if the paper has been accepted? Thank you for your answer.

一枚大头 2023-07-26

Hello, I would like to ask, how many reviewers did you have during the first review? What were their opinions? How long did it take to receive the results of the second review? Thank you for answering.

sanpi 2023-07-26

7.03 提交
7.11 编辑审核中
Is it still with the editor now? Is AM this slow now?

sarazqj 2023-07-26

20230726: The suggestion for the second review was to submit to AS, SMALL. However, it was not agreed upon and instead submitted to another journal, resulting in a waste of two months' time.

Jeni 2023-07-26

5.30 submitted
6.13 under review
6.25 major revision
7.16 revised submitted
7.25 accept

Translation:
5.30 - Submitted
6.13 - Under review
6.25 - Major revision
7.16 - Revised submitted
7.25 - Accepted

123lululu 2023-07-25

Submitted on June 30th, changed to "with editor" on July 11th, it has been two weeks now and it is still "with editor".

dataiyang 2023-07-19

6.4 submitted means "submitted on June 4th".
7.12 major revision means "major revision on July 12th".
Both are at 30%.

sarazqj 2023-07-19

20230512: Manuscript submitted
20230526: Under review
20230620: Major revision
20230708: Revised manuscript submitted

江湖小白 2023-07-18

The editor found several referees for the original poster to arbitrate.

superpig 2023-07-16

Submitted since 7.06, still not approved. Now it feels very slow.

第二性原理@xf 2023-07-13

Excuse me, boss, how long does it usually take to reject a manuscript? It feels like it's taking a long time.

第二性原理@xf 2023-07-12

Too slow, ACS is faster.