认证评论 - Advanced Sustainable Systems
注: 认证评论选取于全球各个学术评论平台和社交媒体。

bzx 2022-02-22

Submission
The first revision took 35 days for the reviewer's comments (modified for 2 weeks).
The second revision took 7 days for the reviewer's comments (modified for 3 days).
After 3-4 days, it was accepted.

大土 2022-02-10

Has your status changed? It has been 25 days for me, and my status is still under consideration.

ss123123 2022-01-12

The editor is very responsible, and the repair is fast, but I don't know why it was classified under materials.

高分子学习研究 2021-11-15

This article has been submitted to many journals. Personally, I believe the article still has some novelty. I submitted it to ACS Energy Letters and it was rejected. I then suggested submitting it to their subsidiary journal, but it was still rejected. Later, I submitted it to Carbon, but it was rejected again. I suggested submitting it to Applied Surface Science, but it was rejected once more. I continued by submitting it to Advanced Science, but it was rejected. I then suggested submitting it to Advanced Sustainable Systems.

After 28 days, the editor requested major revisions, and both reviewers recommended major revisions as well. I was given 20 days to make the revisions.

After 18 days, I uploaded the revised manuscript, and it was accepted 2 days later.

bzx 2021-10-25

Is the status still "under consideration"? Mine has not changed at all.

bzx 2021-09-29

Can you tell me approximately how many days it will take to know if it has been reviewed? What are the specific stages it will go through, and is there a specific timeline?

圣诞树蛋糕 2021-09-20

The text roughly translates to: "The article was submitted for review. The first reviewer suggested minor revisions; the second reviewer was very unprofessional, asking amateurish questions and had a strange and direct rejection attitude; the third reviewer provided professional advice, suggesting major revisions. However, the editor did not give a chance and rejected it directly. This journal is known for its fast pace, but the behavior of this reviewer is quite unpleasant."

高分子学习研究 2021-06-20

1st review in 13 days
Submit after one week
2nd review in 21 days
Accepted 2 days after the 3rd review
Good speed, very fast.

2021-06-13

The journal is not charging fees and is not open-source.

nanatju 2021-05-25

Hello, is this journal fee-based? Can I choose whether it is open-source or not?

2021-04-26

2/9 Submission
2/26 Acceptance
4/19 Online

trash 2021-04-21

The submission was returned with review comments after a month. After multiple revisions based on the review comments, it was finally accepted.

小豆 2021-04-02

Hello, may I ask how long it took for your article to be accepted?

Discover Peeref hubs

Discuss science. Find collaborators. Network.

Join a conversation

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started