Cola-Guan 2023-08-07

August 4th, under review time updated.

灰灰 2023-08-04

Admiration, embrace good luck.

灰灰 2023-08-04

8.2 under changed again.

luoyuxin 2023-08-03

Thank you for informing me. I sent the email on the 1st, and it is now "Under Review" today. I hope everything goes smoothly for both of us. Please, please.

luoyuxin 2023-08-03

Please, please don't reject me. I would be content with a major overhaul.

luoyuxin 2023-08-03

Aug 03, 2023 - Under Review
Finally, the status has been updated. I sent an email on August 1st to inquire, and it has finally been updated. I am so relieved.

Ran极 2023-08-03

Just asked the customer service again. It has now become that there are four reviewers who have agreed to review, and one has given feedback. That means the feedback returned is relatively negative. ??? I'm so unlucky and miserable. Why is it so difficult for my child to publish a paper? ???

CPFEM 2023-08-03

My 14th article with the editor has not been reviewed yet.

CPFEM 2023-08-03

My 14th with editor is still in this state. Previously, I also resubmitted the information on the 13th. I am a bit anxious.

Yin. 2023-08-03

Explanation: The editor is biased towards you, but the opinions of the two reviewers are different. I thought about finding another person to take a look and give you another chance.

The speed is great. At that time, I couldn't find anyone, so there was only one reviewer who gave me feedback after the revision. The chief editor saw that the time was almost up and only one reviewer had given me feedback.

霍大大 2023-08-03

Furthermore, if there are two reviewers with different opinions, it may be necessary to involve another reviewer to seek their opinion.

Ran极 2023-08-02

1 reviewer ?? So, what is the situation when there were 2 reviewers previously reviewing and haven't finished, but after a month, another reviewer was added? Did the editor invite many reviewers and this reviewer agreed later?

霍大大 2023-08-02

I am a reviewer, and several reviewers can be assigned to review a journal article. Usually, there are 2-3 reviewers, but in case of disputes, an additional reviewer may be added.

Ran极 2023-08-02

Does anyone know how many reviewers this journal usually invites? By 7.4, there were already two reviewers who agreed to review, but the under review period changed on 8.1. I asked the customer service, and they said currently there are three reviewers who agreed to review, and none of them have returned their review comments. I am very worried if the editor wants to reject it, so they added another reviewer to see the opinions of other reviewers.

Cola-Guan 2023-08-01

There is a "send email" option in Action Links. After clicking on it, choose "Ad hoc from Author" and then edit your content. I don't know who the editor is, and there is no specific editor assigned.

Ran极 2023-08-01

Aug 01, 2023 under review, the time has been updated again. Please be kind, dear reviewer ????

luoyuxin 2023-08-01

Who did you send the reminder email to? Please let me know, thank you thank you. Did you send it to the editor? I didn't find the editor's email.

can 2023-08-01

The speed of this journal is relatively slow, but the probability of accuracy is relatively high.

知丑 2023-07-30

6.6 submitted to journal
6.8 Send Back to Author: Request to Edit Submission - Remember to provide complete information of the Reviewer when submitting, otherwise it will be returned for completion and resubmission.
6.10 with editor
6.15 under review with 2 reviewers
7.4 revision
7.10 revision submitted to journal
7.11 under review
7.24 accepted
Thank you to Janelle P Wharry for editing, and best wishes for MTC's continued success!

xiaozi 2023-07-29

This journal is extremely slow, and the reviewers are very procrastinating. I do not recommend submitting articles to it.

霍大大 2023-07-28

6.15 Submitted to Journal
6.20 with editor
6.21 under review
7.10 minor revision
7.21 Revision Submitted to Journal
7.22 with editor & under review
7.24 minor revision
7.26 Revision Submitted to Journal
7.28 Accepted

Translation:
6.15 - Submitted to Journal
6.20 - Under review by editor
6.21 - Under review
7.10 - Requires minor revision
7.21 - Revised version submitted to Journal
7.22 - Under review by editor and under review
7.24 - Requires minor revision
7.26 - Revised version submitted to Journal
7.28 - Accepted

Cola-Guan 2023-07-26

7.26, under review.

初雪 2023-07-26

Is there any progress on the paper? My deadline with the editor was on July 13th, and it still hasn't been sent for review... Has everything been slow in the past couple of months? Or is it just in certain cases?

Cola-Guan 2023-07-25

7.24, time updated, the status is still with editor.

Cola-Guan 2023-07-25

July 24, status update, still with Editor, but the time has changed.

XUXU 2023-07-21

Jul 17, 2023 submitted to journal
Jul 18, 2023 with editor
Jul 20, 2023 with editor
Jul 21, 2023 under review

Translated:
Jul 17, 2023 submitted to journal
Jul 18, 2023 with editor
Jul 20, 2023 with editor
Jul 21, 2023 under review

Ran极 2023-07-21

Help, this is too fast ? send it back for repair ????

霍大大 2023-07-21

6.15 Submitted to Journal
6.20 with editor
6.21 under review
7.10 minor revision
7.21 Revision Submitted to Journal

Translation:

6.15 - Submitted to the Journal
6.20 - With editor
6.21 - Under review
7.10 - Minor revision
7.21 - Revision submitted to the Journal

Cola-Guan 2023-07-21

You are so fast, I envy you.

Cola-Guan 2023-07-21

Sent a reminder for the manuscript, and received a reply stating that it is currently undergoing initial processing by the editor, which is equivalent to no response. As of now, it is still "with editor."