太阳hld8124 2023-07-14

13 July 2023 Accepted After 8 months of waiting, I finally received it.

太阳hld8124 2023-07-13

The genome is inherently time-sensitive. Let me criticize this journal a bit. It has been 8 months since I submitted my manuscript and it still hasn't been accepted.

1. After 20 days of submission, they sent it for external review, but surprisingly, they only modified the formatting and asked me to make the necessary changes accordingly.

2. It took a whole year for them to send it back for revisions. On February 16th, it finally went through external review by two experts. The feedback was okay, and I made changes to the content as suggested.

3. On March 19th, I sent it back for revisions, but it stayed with the editor for over a month, almost two months. It was not moving forward during this time.

4. Another 20 days for external review, with two reviewers. I received their feedback on June 9th and made the necessary revisions.

5. After sending it back for revisions, one reviewer had no major concerns. The assistant editor asked for minor changes in the figures and formatting. I don't understand why they didn't ask for these changes earlier.

6. On June 29th, the assistant editor requested additional changes in the figure captions, a very minor issue. Instead of addressing it all at once, they sent it back for revisions within a day.

7. Finally, on June 28th, it was returned to me. It has been 14 days since the last round of revisions, and I have no idea what the current status is. The outcome is still unknown.

太阳hld8124 2023-07-13

09/6/2023 With Journal Administrator
12/6/2023 With Editor
13/6/2023 Decision Pending
16/6/2023 Revision Required
16/6/2023 Revision Incomplete
16/6/2023 Revised Manuscript Submitted
16/6/2023 With Journal Administrator
23/6/2023 With Editor
27/6/2023 Decision Pending
27/6/2023 Revision Required
28/6/2023 Revised Manuscript Submitted
28/6/2023 With Journal Administrator
30/6/2023 With Editor
12/7/2023 Decision Pending

Translated:
09/6/2023 With Journal Administrator
12/6/2023 With Editor
13/6/2023 Decision Pending
16/6/2023 Revision Required
16/6/2023 Revision Incomplete
16/6/2023 Revised Manuscript Submitted
16/6/2023 With Journal Administrator
23/6/2023 With Editor
27/6/2023 Decision Pending
27/6/2023 Revision Required
28/6/2023 Revised Manuscript Submitted
28/6/2023 With Journal Administrator
30/6/2023 With Editor
12/7/2023 Decision Pending

太阳hld8124 2023-07-13

02/12/2022 With Editor
26/12/2022 Out for Review
08/01/2023 Decision Pending
08/01/2023 Revision Required
16/01/2023 With Journal Administrator
14/02/2023 With Editor
16/02/2023 Out for Review
23/02/2023 Decision Pending
23/02/2023 Revision Required
19/03/2023 Revised Manuscript Submitted
20/03/2023 With Journal Administrator
26/04/2023 With Editor
07/05/2023 Out for Review
25/05/2023 Decision Pending
25/05/2023 Revision Required

云浮 2022-11-25

The original data of genome sequencing needs to be submitted to a public database, such as SRA.
How can I do this? Thank you for your guidance.

sch125 2022-10-28

Seriously slow, there has been no change in the state for a month.

Aneira 2022-07-26

This journal used to be very fast, it would finish reviewing within two weeks. Why is the review process so slow this year?

xdsfefcrcda 2022-06-06

It's really outrageous. It has been dragging on since last year, with multiple revisions requested. I made all the modifications as required, but it took 7 months in the end only to be rejected. Moreover, all the modifications were made according to the requirements. Often, there would be no news for three months after waiting. I suggest not to invest.

zhang128 2022-04-20

This journal is incredibly slow in reviewing manuscripts. The editors always claim that the manuscript is under review, but they keep wanting to tease the authors and make them anxious. They make it impossible for you to withdraw your submission, but in the end, they reject it by saying that it lacks innovation. This journal is simply unbelievable.

monkey 2021-10-27

Is not finding a reviewer also a reason for rejection???

sch125 2021-10-20

Now it's really slow. Three months. Tell me that you couldn't find a reviewer to reject it. Hahaha.

海影 2021-09-22

I am too, "under review" changes to "submitted."

海影 2021-09-22

The reviewing speed is much slower than before. I don't know if it's due to the impact of the epidemic. It has been over a month since the revision, but the editor has not provided any comments on the revised version. Moreover, after 10 days of being under review, it suddenly changed to "submitted", and I didn't understand why.

monkey 2021-08-29

Why is the review process so slow now? It feels like it has become stricter compared to a year ago.

Aneira 2021-08-27

Excuse me, have you received any email asking for payment for the layout fee? I submitted an article but they did not ask me to pay the layout fee. The article is already available on their official website, but they haven't asked me to pay the fee. So I have been worried because I submitted to this journal last year and had to pay a layout fee of $600. They usually send an email with a link to make the payment. I don't know why they haven't sent me the email to pay the layout fee this time.

宁 2021-08-17

4.9投 - Submitted on April 9th
4.22回复 - Reply on April 22nd: Raw sequencing data and GenBank accession not publicly available
6.30完成数据上传通过审核 - Data upload completed and approved on June 30th
7.5重新提交 - Resubmitted on July 5th
8.3发回审稿意见，较详细 - Detailed review comments sent back on August 3rd
8.10接收 - Accepted on August 10th
8月13日开始proof - Proofreading started on August 13th

sch125 2021-07-25

2021-7-6 submission
Then under review
2021-7-25
Returned to Submitted
Not sure what the situation is

全世界那么大3 2021-05-06

Do you need a layout fee?

姜钰 2021-03-11

The journal has now slowed down and there has been no news for nearly two months since submission.

Aneira 2021-02-09

How long does it take to receive the proof after submission?