涂涂 2023-08-08

translate the following text into English: revise and resubmit, After resubmission, will the reviewer be reassigned or remain the same?

是小王同学呀 2023-08-08

6.5 submit 大u大r - 6.5 submit 大u大r
7.5 大u小r - 7.5 大u小r
7.9 大u大r - 7.9 大u大r
7.21 大u小r - 7.21 大u小r
8.4 大u大r - 8.4 大u大r

Dear experts, am I making progress? Lately, I have been feeling a bit restless.

sssswwwww 2023-08-07

1. August 7, 2023 submission → Under Review

迷之书童 2023-08-05

Submitted on 30th April 2023, received revise and resubmit on 4th August. Three reviewers and the Associate Editor provided extensive comments. The email suggests that a new round of peer review is required. I want to consult knowledgeable friends whether new reviewers should be sought. How likely is it to be accepted?

U.N.Owen 2023-08-01

2022.8.9: Submit
2023.2.9: Major Revision
2023.3.24: Submit revision
2023.4.28: Minor Revision
2023.5.16: Submit revision
2023.6.12: Minor Revision
2023.6.18: Submit revision
2023.7.14: Accept

The submission process took nearly a year, with the first review taking six months and subsequent revisions taking around one month each. Finally, the requirements for graduation have been met.

dunk 2023-07-29

Didn't go out, just reminded them to submit the manuscript, and the small "r" became a capital "R". It has been like this for two weeks now and hasn't changed.

冒个泡泡 2023-07-29

After checking everyone's comments, UR (大U大R is in the hands of the editor), Ur (大U小r is in the hands of the reviewer), once again UR indicates that the reviewer has finished reviewing and the editor needs to make a decision and provide feedback.
I submitted on July 4th, and on the same day it became Under Review (大U大R).
Then on July 25th, it changed to Under review (大U小r).

mrturnsole 2023-07-29

Dude, did you get any results yet? It has been almost a month and a half since I submitted my second review, and it is still under review... I feel like the process has become so slow. My senior sister got her results in just one month before.

WYFDK 2023-07-28

After my major renovation, I received the outcome exactly one week later. Yours should be accepted, let's see if there will be any results today. Good luck.

WYFDK 2023-07-28

The editing suggestions for my resubmission are not like this. The editor provided their own modifications.

T.SEM 2023-07-27

Hello, a few days after you submitted your major revisions, did you receive any acceptance messages? My paper was also rejected and resubmitted for major revisions. I sent it out again on July 20th, and it has been a week now with no news. In the second round of major revisions, one expert accepted it and another expert provided three comments. I wonder how the final result will be. Do you think the chances are slightly higher?

Joie 2023-07-27

May I ask if the editing suggestion for resubmission is as follows: "The paper is in scope for the Journal but it needs to be carefully revised to be accepted"?

Joie 2023-07-27

Is this the feedback given: The paper is in scope for the Journal but it needs to be carefully revised to be accepted.

WYFDK 2023-07-27

There were no additional reviewers, it has been the same two from the beginning to the end. Good luck!

小夏_0321 2023-07-27

Congratulations, sticking with happiness.
I submitted my application in April and went through the process of Under review--Under Review -Under review-UnderReview, and it has just recently changed to Under Review. I hope for a good outcome. Did you add reviewers midway through the process?

海岸线 2023-07-25

June 27, 2023: Submitted, under review (UR).
July 5, 2023: Changed to under review (Ur).
July 25, 2023: Changed back to under review (UR). Not sure why it suddenly became UR again, what is the situation?

WYFDK 2023-07-25

2023.07.25, accepted.
Two reviewers.
2023.04: Reject (revise and resubmit)
2023.06: Resubmitted
2023.06: Major
2023.07: Resubmitted
2023.07: Accepted
It took nine months, and the reviewers' comments were very constructive. Approximately 40 pages of responses were provided over two rounds of reviews.
Also, I wish everyone good outcomes.

WYFDK 2023-07-25

It took nine months, finally received.

dmax 2023-07-25

Hello everyone, may I ask about my application that was submitted in April? It has been over three months now, and the status has consistently been "small r" (changed to "big r" once the next day and then back to "small r" afterwards). What does this mean? It's really slow and frustrating.

Zzzzippo 2023-07-20

This is the second article I submitted.

myz_tj 2023-07-18

Dude, are you a judge?

Tabe 2023-07-18

7/18 Major revision - This means that a significant revision or update is being made on the 18th day of the month.

Tabe 2023-07-17

7/17 awaiting decision.

Zzzzippo 2023-07-15

Hmm, does that mean the editor still needs to find reviewers?

Tabe 2023-07-15

Difference of opinion. I have previously reminded you to submit this. I still need another round of opinions.

Zzzzippo 2023-07-15

After one month of submission, there was a change in the middle to small 'r', but it has now been consistently large 'R' up until now. In response to the reminder, the meaning is unclear.

Thanks for your inquiry on the manuscript submitted for review. It is currently under review. You will be informed via email as soon as the review process completes.

Kindly note, for IoT Journal the manuscript status remains 'Under Review' from 'Editor-in-Chief Assign Topical Editor' to 'Awaiting Associate Editor Recommendation'.

Thank you for your understanding and continued patience.

myz_tj 2023-07-14

Did you change to be an AD, and now you have changed to be a big R again?

Zzzzippo 2023-07-14

The text translates to: "For the IoT journal, the manuscript status remains 'under review' from 'editor-in-chief assign topical editor' to 'awaiting associate editor recommendation'. What does this mean? Currently, my status is still 'under review'."

Tabe 2023-07-13

This BYD journal review process is really slow.

myz_tj 2023-07-11

Is there a result now? Has it changed to AD?