奈氏图ORZ 2023-07-04

No restrictions, it's possible.

GXUmin 2023-07-01

I want to ask, how many pages are allowed for the initial draft?

GXUmin 2023-07-01

How many pages is the first draft limited to?

GXUmin 2023-07-01

I want to ask, is there a page requirement for the first draft? Is 10 pages acceptable?

莫总08 2023-06-24

What happened in the end?

莫总08 2023-06-23

What happened in the end?

C_A 2023-06-15

Esperando la decisión de ED. (Spanish)
En attente de la décision de ED. (French)
In attesa della decisione di ED. (Italian)
Aguardando a decisão do ED. (Portuguese)
Ожидание решения ED. (Russian)
等待ED的决定。 (Chinese)
EDの決定を待っています。 (Japanese)
ED 결정을 기다리는 중입니다. (Korean)
EDの決定を待っています。 (Japanese)

C_A 2023-05-16

Esperando asignación de revisor.

C_A 2023-05-11

Esperando la selección del revisor.

C_A 2023-05-10

Already voted, hoping for good luck.

rose journey 2023-05-05

It has been a month in AE's hands, am I going to be rejected?

韭菜 2023-04-24

The review and AE processing speed is very fast. Three reviewers provided more than 30 comments, and a detailed response to the comments is required.
02-Jan-2023 - Submitted
02-Feb-2023 - Feedback received (major revision)
27-Feb-2023 - Resubmitted
14-Mar-2023 - Accepted

MahoneSSS 2023-04-20

Generally, within two weeks, the AE efficiency of PELS is not as good as TIE.

rose journey 2023-04-12

2023/04/01 awaiting AE recommendation

Until now, it has been 10 days and there is still no progress. How long has everyone been waiting for the AE's decision?

叶叶的小雨 2023-04-06

Can I just answer the questions from the reviewer in the response letter? Do I need to address the comments from the associate editor?

rose journey 2023-03-18

2023/02/17 submit
2023/02/17-2023/02/21 Awaiting administrator processing
2023/02/22 Awaiting ED Assignment,Awaiting AE Assignment
2023/02/25 Awaiting Reviewer Selection
2023/02/27 Awaiting Reviewer Assignment
2023/03/5 Awaiting Reviewer Scores

Translated:

2023/02/17 submit
2023/02/17-2023/02/21 Awaiting administrator processing
2023/02/22 Awaiting ED Assignment, Awaiting AE Assignment
2023/02/25 Awaiting Reviewer Selection
2023/02/27 Awaiting Reviewer Assignment
2023/03/5 Awaiting Reviewer Scores

笑拥而过 2023-03-17

No urging for manuscripts, let it be natural, more casual.

sadasda 2023-03-16

Hello, I see that your review time is quite long. Can you please remind me about my manuscript? It has been a while, and the status hasn't changed.

笑拥而过 2023-03-14

The text is already in English. It states the dates when the manuscript was received and underwent revisions, and when it was finally accepted.

期刊中中中 2023-03-09

2023.02.03 submit, special issue paper
2023.02.10 awaiting reviewer assignment
2023.03.08 awaiting reviewer scores
2023.03.21 Awaiting AE Recommendation
2023.03.27 Awaiting ED Decision
2023.03.30 Reject

Translated:

2023.02.03: Submitted special issue paper
2023.02.10: Waiting for reviewer assignment
2023.03.08: Waiting for reviewer scores
2023.03.21: Awaiting Associate Editor's recommendation
2023.03.27: Awaiting Editor-in-Chief's decision
2023.03.30: Rejected

juciwdjared 2023-03-02

This has been a bit long, you can contact ADM to inquire. This journal has recently become slow. I have been waiting for one month for reviewer assignment...

sadasda 2023-03-01

2022.10.16 First submission
2022.11.23 Major revisions (three reviewers, one of whom should reject, with the comment "has no value")
2022.12.20 Revised submission
It's already March 1st, 2023, and it's still Awaiting Reviewer Scores. Why is it so slow? Sob sob sob...
Isn't this journal supposed to be fast? Brothers, what do you think about this? Please, I'm begging you.

奈氏图ORZ 2023-02-24

It has been over three weeks without any movement since February 1st until now, maybe it is just slow now.

juciwdjared 2023-02-24

Brother, how long have you been in the "awaiting reviewer assignment" status? I've been in this state for two weeks. It feels like the reviewer hasn't been confirmed yet.

奈氏图ORZ 2023-01-20

2023.1.19 Submitted
2023.1.20 Awaiting AE Assignment
2023.1.24 Awaiting Reviewer Selection
2023.2.1 Awaiting Reviewer Assignment
2023.2.24 Awaiting Reviewer Scores
2023.3.11 Awaiting AE Recommendation
2023.3.14 Awaiting ED Decision
2023.3.30 Reject

Translated into English:

2023.1.19 Submitted
2023.1.20 Awaiting AE Assignment
2023.1.24 Awaiting Reviewer Selection
2023.2.1 Awaiting Reviewer Assignment
2023.2.24 Awaiting Reviewer Scores
2023.3.11 Awaiting AE Recommendation
2023.3.14 Awaiting ED Decision
2023.3.30 Reject

在读博士，求PE 2022-12-23

After reviewing a JESTPE paper, there is no option to reject and resubmit in the review interface. There are only four options: reject, accept with mandatory revisions, accept with minor revisions, and accept.

accept 2022-12-15

2022.4.28 Submission
2022.6.1 Awaiting reviewer scores
2022.7.28 AE recommendation
2022.7.28 Awaiting editor's decision
2022.7.28 Major revision (2 points of innovation explanation, 4 points of explanation, 6 supplementary experiments)
2022.8.27 Sent back for revisions
2022.8.27 Awaiting reviewer selection (Seems like another reviewer was invited)
2022.9.6 Awaiting reviewer scores
2022.9.27 AE recommendation
2022.9.28 Awaiting editor's decision
2022.9.28 Major revision (3 points of explanation, 2 supplementary experiments)
2022.11.08 Sent back for revisions
2022.11.14 Awaiting reviewer scores
2022.11.29 Awaiting AE recommendation
2022.12.08 Awaiting editor's decision
2022.12.15 Accept

花儿对我笑 2022-12-07

Is it true that JESTPE journal does not have the option of resubmission after rejection?

在读博士，求PE 2022-12-07

I asked around, it seems like everyone in Europe where AE is located is on vacation or too busy to deal with it.

花儿对我笑 2022-10-26

Why does "awaiting reviewer selection" take so long?