gao0911 2023-05-04

My 8th issue has not been retrieved yet. I saw the 7th issue on WOS today.

RH2022 2023-05-02

The processing speed is very fast, and the reviewers are also very responsible. Two rounds of major revisions raised soul-searching questions and provided many useful suggestions. I am very lucky.

clby 2023-05-02

4.12 was submitted for review, but it has been 20 days today and there have been no other developments.

shenshen123 2023-04-29

May I ask the original poster, what is the progress of the manuscript now? How long has your pending review lasted?

bao 2023-04-29

How long does it take for WOS to retrieve?

bao 2023-04-29

Can the wos be retrieved?

wenhuan 2023-04-24

It seems that the processing of submissions in April is quite slow. The pending review time for many submissions made in April is becoming longer. Personally, I suspect that after MDPI's public relations, they have started to strictly control the reviewing process. I am planning to email the assistant editor this week to inquire about the progress and will continue to provide updates.

SayHello 2023-04-24

Experience of submission:

3.12 - Submitted and pending review on the same day.
3.13 - Assigned to Associate Editor (AE) and under review on the same day.
3.23 - Major revisions (Three reviewers provided feedback, one positive, one negative, and one neutral. The first reviewer suggested 4 required revisions and 2 optional revisions. The second reviewer suggested 3 required revisions and 2 optional revisions. The third reviewer suggested 4 optional revisions and 2 required revisions.)
4.1 - Revised and resubmitted.
4.6 - Major revisions (For some reason, only feedback from one reviewer was received, suggesting five revisions, of which one is required and five are optional.)
4.11 - Revised and resubmitted.
4.13 - Pending editor decision.
4.20 - Accepted.
4.20 - Pending English editing.
4.21 - Proofread (Proofreading returned).
4.23 - Paper online (After payment).
5.24 - Indexed in Web of Science (End of this thread).
The indexing process only took one month after online publication. I must say, the publishing experience with MDPI is truly exceptional. They get things done efficiently when you pay.

Mr. Black0220 2023-04-23

How is the situation now? Is it still under review? Why is it taking so long to be under review?

wenhuan 2023-04-22

2023/4/5 submit
2023/4/6 under review
2023/4/22 under review

zyyendeavor 2023-04-21

4.20 accept

lucky_ 2023-04-17

Does it take 9 more days for it to change from pending review to under review? It has been 5 days and it is still pending review.

gao0911 2023-04-17

2.28 Submission
3.7 Change institution email address
3.22 Major overhaul
3.30 Submission
4.4 Pending editing decision (payment made on the same day, status changes to "Under English editing")
4.6 Author proofreading
4.7 Website online

lucky_ 2023-04-17

4.17 is still pending review. I wanted to ask how long this status has been lasting. I'm feeling anxious...

lucky_ 2023-04-17

May I ask what is the result behind? How many days will it be under review?

只想顺利毕业 2023-04-16

The same department sent this one for repair after only 25 days, while the other one took two weeks to be repaired. Mine hasn't even been repaired yet. I suspect that this journal might also be under review and will be kicked out of SCI.

奕成 2023-04-16

Wait patiently for about a month and a half.

lucky_ 2023-04-14

How are you now?

zyyendeavor 2023-04-13

2023.4.13 Pending editor decision translates to English as: "Pending editor decision on April 13th, 2023."

zyyendeavor 2023-04-13

2023.3.17 under review translates to "March 17, 2023 under review" in English.

zyyendeavor 2023-04-13

2023.3.16 submit - Submitted on March 16, 2023
3.28 major revise - Major revisions required on March 28, 2023
4.11 resubmit - Resubmit on April 11, 2023
4.13 minor revise - Minor revisions required on April 13, 2023
4.13 resubmit - Resubmit on April 13, 2023

只想顺利毕业 2023-04-13

2023.3.19 submit - Pending review on the same day.
2023.3.20 - Assigned to AE, under review on the same day.
2023.3.21 - Discovered errors, contacted the editor to update the paper.
2023.4.23 - It has been 25 days, and I still haven't received any review comments.
This journal is not as fast as everyone says it is. Where is the promised "graduation miracle journal"...

lucky_ 2023-04-13

4.12 Submission

顺利毕业球球了 2023-04-12

Rejected again, template rejection, and returned back to Electronics.

TUO_TUO 2023-04-11

Submission Received 09 March 2023

The major revision was given around the 25th, approximately two weeks later. The reviewer's comments were received within 10 days.

Submission Revision Date 02 April 2023

After waiting for the editor's decision for 2-3 days, it was directly accepted.

Accepted 10 April 2023

The paper was submitted in the field of acoustic signal processing, with two reviewers, one of whom was more specialized. It was relatively easy to submit and was chosen because of the urgency to produce results.

bao 2023-04-11

投了applied sciences,3.17投稿，当天分配AE；3.18号补充内容发给编辑；3.22号under review；4.6号pending major revisions。大修中……现在是审稿人要求润色，请问一下是先润色还是先修改？

Applied Sciences was submitted on 3.17 and assigned to an associate editor on the same day. Additional content was sent to the editor on 3.18. On 3.22, it entered the "under review" stage. On 4.6, it was marked as "pending major revisions". Currently in the process of major revisions... Now, the reviewer has requested proofreading. Could you please clarify if proofreading should be done before or after making the revisions?

奕成 2023-04-09

No influence on submission, I transferred from sensors.

顺利毕业球球了 2023-04-08

I would like to ask everyone if getting rejected by MDPI's Electronics within three days will affect my future submissions?

nlpyes 2023-04-07

3.10-submit: Pending review on the same day
3.14-分配AE: Under review on the same day
3.20-charge confirm: Confirmation of charges
3.29-major revisions: All three reviewers provided positive feedback. The first reviewer had 3 "yes" and 2 "can" opinions, the second reviewer had 5 "yes" opinions, and the third reviewer had 1 "yes," 3 "can," and 1 "must" opinions.
4.3晚改回: Late revision
4.4-received: Received
4.5-审稿人意见全部回来全部yes: All reviewer comments have returned with all "yes" opinions
4.5-pending editor decision: Pending editor's decision
4.7-paper accept: Paper accepted

junyi 2023-04-06

Five reviewers were assigned for the first round of review, and the results were generally good. However, after waiting for two months with no updates, and with the status remaining as "pending editor decision," I couldn't understand the situation. Therefore, I have decided to withdraw the submission and submit it elsewhere.