武庆昌 2022-05-03

With a suggestion for a major renovation.

James23nb 2022-05-01

What is the status of "pending editor decision"? I have been stuck in this status for a long time.

武庆昌 2022-04-29

I submitted it a month ago and it is still under review.

frank16 2022-04-28

It has been 50 days since submission, and it is still under review. I have sent an email to the editor but have not received a response. Have you ever encountered this situation?

lei, 2022-04-26

Review for 1 month
3 reviewers
Minor revisions, return in 2 days
Accepted on the same day

jakcic 2022-04-25

4.24 pending review - This means that a certain action or task is awaiting assessment or evaluation.
4.25 under review - This indicates that a particular action or task is currently being examined or considered for evaluation.

1111 2022-04-21

How long does it usually take?

YAN XI 2022-04-20

Hello, may I ask how long does it take for your pending review?

蝎子莱莱11 2022-04-20

Yes, the layout fee is around 15,000 Chinese yuan.

认真的xx 2022-04-20

Hello, may I ask if this journal is an open access journal or a subscription-based journal?

认真的xx 2022-04-20

Hello, may I ask if this journal is an open-access journal or a paid journal?

KK HA 2022-04-15

Mainly depends on the editor, sometimes there is a large amount of articles, so please be patient and wait. It is not uncommon for pending to take two weeks.

Carrrrrly 2022-04-11

3/5 Submission
3/25 First round of comments (minor revisions)
3/28 Resubmission
4/4 Acceptance
Before final publication, it seems that the journal helped with some grammar corrections.
Contacting the assistant editor directly via email for many issues was very convenient, and small errors were promptly addressed.
The efficiency was extremely high.

蝎子莱莱11 2022-04-10

Why is it taking so long for it to be pending? I heard that it's very dangerous if it exceeds two days.

KK HA 2022-04-09

2.23 pending review - Waiting for review on 2nd February
3.7 under review - Currently being reviewed on 7th March
3.21小修，当天提交，第二天accept - Minor edits on 21st March, submitted on the same day, accepted on the next day

qaidamensis 2022-04-08

Submission: 16 March 2022, Major revision: 23 March 2022, Minor revision: 31 March 2022, Acceptance: 4 April 2022, Publication: 8 April 2022

守护SEVEN 2022-04-01

3.1投 - 3.1投 translates to "3.1 Investment" in English.
3.22小修 - 3.22小修 translates to "3.22 Minor Repair" in English.
3.23接收 - 3.23接收 translates to "3.23 Receiving" in English.

呜呜呜拉 2022-03-31

Hello, do you require the submission of programs and datasets during the reviewing process?

拉卡 2022-03-31

As long as the quality of the article is acceptable, the review and acceptance process will be quick.
3.20 submission
3.22 editor assignment
3.28 minor revisions feedback received
3.30 minor revisions submitted, accepted on the same day

wxwx111 2022-03-15

2.18 Submission
2.21 Assign assistant editor and submit for review
3.7 Minor revisions
3.10 Submit revised draft and receive it two hours later
3.15 Online publication

It's really fast, a blessing for graduates.

鱼丸粗面 2022-03-11

Recently, it's been too slow, I'm eager to graduate.

鱼丸粗面 2022-03-10

How long has it been submitted for review?

鱼丸粗面 2022-03-09

When did you vote?

Riddick James 2022-03-09

Does "Under review" mean it is being sent for external review? How long does it usually take to receive any updates? xdm

AngelaChenyu 2022-03-07

It is like this, I forgot to upload because I clicked too fast, and instead of uploading, I directly clicked on submit. It is not a system issue, but rather I personally contacted the assistant editor.

王宣王宣 2022-03-03

Hello, you are progressing very slowly, and I am also in a hurry to graduate. I'm getting anxious.

C& AGW 2022-03-03

Recently, the processing has been particularly slow. Please submit with caution.

狗屎 2022-03-01

When I replied to the major revisions, I also missed attaching one reviewer's comments. Then the editor contacted me to send it to him again. But I clearly remembered that I had uploaded all the comments from everyone. In this case, I suspect that there is a bug in the submission system, which missed one review comment.

踽踽独行 2022-03-01

No mistake, it's just absurd, and yet surprising.

AngelaChenyu 2022-02-28

Here is the process of submission:

2022/1/30: Submitted;
2022/2/3: Assigned assistant editor and entered peer review (later found out that even though I submitted to my own Special Issue, because the paper is related to him, my academic editor is someone he doesn't know, which is considered fair?)
2022/2/11: Major revision, given 10 days, the reviewer is a fellow expert, able to understand the paper but not in great detail, requested addition of method comparison and language modification;
2022/2/18: Submitted major revision, entered second round of review on the same day;
2022/2/21: Minor revision, given 5 days, mostly okay, reviewer requested careful checking of grammar and spelling errors;
2022/2/24: Minor revision returned, accepted on the same day, probably not sent for external review;
2022/2/25: Received payment notice, made payment;
2022/2/26: Received proof in the early morning, requested completion within 24 hours, I returned the same day, and it was published on the same day, very fast.

Overall, the paid service was attentive, the assistant editor was diligent in communication. When I replied to the major revision, I forgot to upload one reviewer's comments and directly contacted the assistant editor to help me upload it. This journal has a good JCR ranking, but its reputation in China is not that great. It is suitable for those who are in a hurry for papers and recognized by their schools.