DUODUO-12 2023-05-18

Biology, it is very difficult to submit and the review process is also very slow.

Adv mater 2023-05-13

Actually, it's just about raising money. It's hard to say in the field of biology, but there's no need to invest in the field of chemistry, materials, and energy. There are too many alternative journals in the same category. Why spend money on AS? The money spent could be used to publish another article. It's not like AM or top journals like Angew, it's just an ordinary first-tier journal. If it's AM, it would be worth investing money because it is recognized for tenure evaluation and job searching. For example, even though Small NC has a bad reputation, it is still acceptable for job searching and tenure evaluation if money is spent on publishing in it.

缺舟一帆渡 2023-05-11

It has been three weeks, when will you be back?

e100wt 2023-05-05

My situation is the same. AM didn't give any reason for rejection, directly asked if I want to switch to AS. It feels like my head is buzzing. Can't they at least give a reason?

blisswaiter 2023-05-03

January 9th - Submitted
February 7th - Same day with editor + under review (The editor is really efficient)
February 20th - Review comments came back, one reviewer rejected the paper, the other two reviewers requested major revisions. The editor rejected the paper.
February 23rd - Argued against the comments of the first reviewer and wrote a corresponding appeal letter.
February 25th - Editor accepted the appeal, made major revisions, and started to supplement experiments.
March 24th - Delayed for revisions.
April 18th - Minor revisions (The same reviewer still rejected the paper, the other two reviewers recommended acceptance, and an additional reviewer suggested a minor modification before acceptance).
April 19th - Made overnight changes and submitted minor revisions.
April 21st - Editor provided minor revisions, suggesting moving a part of the supplementary material to the main text.
April 22nd - Made overnight changes and submitted minor revisions.
April 24th - Editor returned with another round of minor revisions, requesting final language polishing.
April 30th - Submitted minor revisions.
May 2nd - Waited for the editor after the May Day holiday and finally received the acceptance email after 9 pm. It was really not easy.

sunsky633 2023-05-02

I suggest not investing anymore. I submitted on March 17th and the review process was quite fast. It took 40 days to receive the review comments.

缺舟一帆渡 2023-05-01

Excuse me everyone, approximately how many days will it take to receive feedback after submitting for review? I am in a hurry to graduate.

mimi111 2023-04-22

The reputation is just so-so, it is nothing more than being called a money-making magazine or a magazine with watered-down content. I don't know about fields like biology, but in the field of material chemistry and energy, it is truly unbearable to look at.

科研嘛不寒蝉 2023-04-22

2.9 submission
Sent for review after one week
3.163 reviewers, 2 at 15%, 1 at 30%, editor for major revisions
Revised on 3.27
Accepted on 4.14
The process was fast, and payment has already been made for proofreading.

缺舟一帆渡 2023-04-22

After 22 days with the editor, it was not until 4.21 that it was submitted for review.

AmazJ 2023-04-19

The translation of the text into English is: "The email with the cost of 5720 dollars was sent even though it was still being edited."

FIXIT 2023-04-18

Super slow, mine has been submitted for 20 days and still in the submitted status.

等一个paper 2023-04-17

Do not submit the urgent graduation, this magazine's processing speed for biomedical articles is slower than a snail!

百鸟生万剑 2023-04-17

I posted directly in the system, but after posting, there won't be any changes in the system. I can only wait for the communication mailbox to receive the email.

阿斯顿企鹅 2023-04-16

Ok, thank you. May I ask if you directly send emails within the system or contact the editor-in-chief?

百鸟生万剑 2023-04-16

I appealed directly and only responded to 50% of the reviewers in the appeal letter. I mentioned that I am willing to conduct additional experiments if necessary. Whether it will be successful or not depends on the mood of the editor, so I decided to send the letter and give it a try.

FIXIT 2023-04-16

4.16 has passed and the manuscript has been submitted.

阿斯顿企鹅 2023-04-15

Hello, I am currently facing a situation similar to yours. One paper has been rejected (50%), while two others have received review decisions of 5% and 15% respectively. The rejection decision seems unreasonable, and it feels like the reviewer is intentionally making things difficult. Could you please advise whether I should appeal directly or submit additional experiments before appealing?

sunsky633 2023-04-13

After the "under review" stage, is there a status called "required review completed" when the feedback is returned for review? Or does the feedback come back after the "under review" stage without any status editing?

zhp_miao 2023-04-13

The status has finally been updated. ??

zhp_miao 2023-04-13

4.13 The status has finally changed to "with editor" ???

zhp_miao 2023-04-12

Then I will observe for another week. ???

FIXIT 2023-04-11

I'm in the same state as you. When my senior sister applied, it was also quite fast.

FIXIT 2023-04-11

Still manuscript submitted, making the child anxious.

zhp_miao 2023-04-11

3.28 Submission
3.29 Returned due to incorrect payment option selection
3.30 Resubmission, only tutor received confirmation email
4.11 Status still "manuscript submitted"
Usually, AS's processing speed seems quite fast, but this time, I don't know why an editor hasn't been assigned yet. Have you encountered this situation before? I suspect there may be a problem with my submission ???

zhp_miao 2023-04-11

May I ask if your submission status has been updated? I submitted on 3.28, and it's already 4.11, but it still shows as "submitted." I started to doubt if there was any issue with my submission.

FIXIT 2023-04-07

3.31 submission
4.7 still manuscript submitted
Isn't this journal supposed to be fast? Why hasn't it reached the editor's hands after a week? ? My child is anxious to graduate.

张同学 2023-04-01

Soon, 1.7 submissions, 2.23 accepted.

大哥快跑！ 2023-03-23

Brother, may I ask if only the submission email can see the status?

已注销 2023-03-23

An overview paper was submitted to AEM and got rejected within a week. The editor suggested submitting it to Advanced Science, Small, or Solar RRL.