吃不胖的洋芋蛋 2022-05-18

Did the original poster submit it for review?

Aurum 2022-05-17

Sanjay Mathur is very slow T_T

cs97 2022-05-15

I have a lithium battery, and I also sent it to Sang Woo Kim. I submitted it on the 13th. There are two recommended Korean reviewers, and currently, the decision is in process. Can you tell me approximately how long it will take to get the results?

cs97 2022-05-15

Is it still 5 reviewers or 3 now?

cs97 2022-05-15

May I ask how many reviewers are there now? Is it five or three?

cs97 2022-05-15

I have a lithium-ion battery, and Sang woo kim sent it too. It is the 13th submission and there are two recommended Korean reviewers. Currently, the decision is in process. May I ask how long it will take to get the results?

Alces 2022-05-14

It has been 20 days and I have been invited as an editor, but there is no news at all! I still don't dare to remind them!

aadadsaaa 2022-05-12

The review result was given after 16 days of review. There were five reviewers... Oh my, I thought only Chinese journals had five reviewers haha. This journal also had five reviewers, but fortunately, they all suggested revisions instead of rejecting it.

lynnnnnnn 2022-05-10

After my submission, the editor invited me for 16 days. After sending an email to inquire about the situation, I had a discussion with the editor the next day. Now, it has been another ten days with the editor, and I don't know when the next step will be.

aadadsaaa 2022-05-06

It has been about 16 days since submission, and it is still in the "Required Reviews Completed" status. The status has changed twice, indicating that there have been four reviewers involved. However, the editor has not yet handled it. Does this mean we are still waiting? Is it necessary to have five reviewers?

aadadsaaa 2022-04-26

My process is also the same. I submitted it to Wang Zhonglin on the same day, and then the editor invited process started. It has been three or four days now, but I did receive an email from Liu Jun forwarding the article. However, it still says editor invited. Will it end up the same as the OP, not being reviewed for more than twenty days? If you don't like it, just reject my submission. I'm in a hurry to publish it.

rhylongbai 2022-04-23

2022.4.21 Submit
2022.4.22 Under Review

djf-xjtu 2022-04-19

After my first review, the editor provided conditional acceptance. There are two small issues, but I haven't received any response for half a month after replying. The associate editor is also Sanjay Mathur. Waiting anxiously!!!

SheepSuzzy 2022-03-30

2022.1.29 submitted
20221.31 with editor (Zhonglin Wang)
2022.2.1 with editor (Zhiqun Lin)
2022.2.1 rejected
Even during the Chinese New Year, the efficiency of the journal is still high, and it doesn't waste time. It's worth trying. I will come back next time if there is a suitable opportunity.

Southern penguin 2022-03-29

2022.03.24 submitted
2022.03.27 decision in process
2022.03.29 rejected

li 2022-03-27

Hello, I would like to ask if the deadline for completing the required reviews on the 18th has been changed to a later date. The date for completing the required reviews for my second review has changed four times (with five reviewers for the first review). It has been almost ten days since the last date change, and I still haven't received any updates. The same associate editor.

yuanm 2022-02-18

Hello, may I ask how you are doing? I also got assigned to this editor, hoping for good luck~

柔和的晚风 2022-01-20

Very good journal. Submitted on December 20th, reviewed on December 23rd, received comments on January 4th. Two reviewers, one accepted and one with minor revisions. Revised on January 13th, accepted on January 20th. Wishing the journal continues to improve!

锦鲤越越 2022-01-04

The third SCI article during my doctoral period, and also the second article with an impact factor of 15+. I am very grateful to Associate Editor Hu Chen and the reviewers for their recognition of the work. The journal has a very high efficiency in handling manuscripts.

The specific submission process is as follows:
November 18th: Submission
December 10th: First review results
December 21st: Submission of reviewer comments and revised paper
January 2nd: Paper acceptance
January 4th: Agreement signing
Waiting for official online publication.
I hope Nano Energy journal will continue to prosper. Thank you, Academician Wang Zhonglin!

htao12014 2022-01-04

December 19th received.

直男毛毛 2021-12-10

Three reviewers, from submission to acceptance, took two months, the journal is very efficient. I am very grateful for the comments, corrections, and recognition of the work from Associate Editor Professor Hu Chengu, and the three reviewing teachers. Special thanks to Academician Wang Zhonglin! I wish Nano Energy continued success!

Alex Zhang 2021-12-05

10.12 Submission
10.28 Revision, three reviewers
11.26 Revision requested
12.4 Accepted

XL@CF 2021-12-02

Submitted to receiving comments from reviewers, it lasted for two months. There were two major revisions and one minor revision (with nine questions...), all of which were very professional, especially regarding the mechanism, with each aspect intricately connected. The attention to detail was quite strict, and the days of responding to the comments were quite challenging. Fortunately, it was eventually accepted, and I feel quite lucky. Wishing NE continued success!!!

WLYCG 2021-11-29

Okay, thank you. The editing has taken about 10 days, and it has already been submitted for review.

htao12014 2021-11-27

Second revision. Return on October 24th.
Required Reviews Completed on November 18th. It has been 9 days since then, and the status has not changed. Does anyone know what's going on? The co-editor is Sanjay Mathur.
My first SCI article...

XXXcalv 2021-11-23

The editing is still acceptable, and basically it will progress to the next stage in 1-2 weeks.

Aurum 2021-11-16

Have you submitted your final version for review? I submitted half a month ago and it took me a month to hear back from the editor. It has been almost a month and it is still in the editor's hands for editing.

拾早 2021-11-15

Received at Editorial Office: 21 Sep 2021
Under Review: 21 Sep 2021
Article revised: 10 Nov 2021
Article accepted for publication: 11 Nov 2021

邹yx 2021-10-27

2021/10/26 accept

This phrase is already in English and does not need to be translated.

WLYCG 2021-10-19

Excuse me, everyone, how is the editing efficiency of Sang-woo Kim? How about the submission rate? Thank you!