Charming666 2022-10-17

October 16th - Agreement received. Two reviewers accepted. One reviewer provided some minor comments.
October 17th - Revised.

rhylongbai 2022-10-05

Received reviewers' comments, three reviewers, one received comments, the editor didn't wait, it took too long. The editor provided major revisions, with around a dozen issues including theory and experiments.

Submitted response to the comments on September 30th.

Under review as of October 4th.

Charming666 2022-09-29

Dear classmate Xiao Cao, the editor assigned to me is from Germany. Currently, the comments from the reviewer on September 23rd have been received, but the editor has not made a decision yet. I suggest waiting a bit longer and patiently await the results after submitting. Good luck!

nano 2022-09-22

9.14 submitted
9.15 with editor
9.16 editor invited
9.17 with editor
9.21 under review
Result unknown, wishing for good luck.

小曹同学 2022-09-19

Excuse me, which assistant editor is it? Mine is still with Assistant Editor Liu Jun, it's a bit slow, thank you.

rhylongbai 2022-09-15

After inviting the reviewer again, it took four to five days to complete the review. The current status is "Required Reviews Completed", indicating that it is time for the editor to make a decision. However, it has remained unchanged for two days.

Charming666 2022-09-14

To Xiao Cao,
Returning the review comments on August 21st.
Revised on September 14th.
The current status of the submission is unknown, good luck!

小曹同学 2022-09-13

How are you doing now, thank you.

rhylongbai 2022-09-12

You are so fast, my five-month manuscript review still hasn't received any news.

poke888 2022-09-12

Thank you, Prof. Liming Dai, for your editorial guidance and the reviewers for their valuable feedback, which helped to improve the quality of the article.

rhylongbai 2022-09-09

Chinese editors have a bad attitude. It has been five months and they are again looking for reviewers. They really only focus on Chinese people.

rhylongbai 2022-09-09

It has been almost 5 months. After urging the editor, they said there was only one review comment, and one had not been replied to. So today, we invited a third reviewer again.
This is really unfair to the authors, to have to find another reviewer after five months, wasting several times the amount of time waiting for an uncertain result.
This journal is truly not ordinary; fewer people will fall into this pit in the future.

rhylongbai 2022-09-08

What's the situation with the original poster now? Any updates?

rhylongbai 2022-09-05

It has been nearly 5 months since the manuscript was submitted. We have reminded them several times, but there has been no response at all.

花火 2022-08-25

9 Aug Submission;
10 Aug with editor & under review
24 Aug Required Reviews Completed
I sincerely admire the efficiency of this journal's handling process. Quietly waiting for the results.

rhylongbai 2022-08-24

It has been over four months since the manuscript was reviewed, and still there is no news.

科研打铁佬 2022-08-20

What's the situation, OP? It has been almost four months since mine was submitted for review, and there is still no news!

科研打铁佬 2022-08-20

What's the situation, OP? It has been four months since mine was submitted for review, and there has been no news at all.

rhylongbai 2022-08-10

It has been four months since the manuscript was submitted for review, but there has been no progress or changes. I have urged for the manuscript, but the editor has not responded.

科研打铁佬 2022-08-09

What's the situation now?

Charming666 2022-08-08

August 2nd Submitted
August 3rd With Editor
August 4th Editor Invited
August 7th With Editor
August 8th Under Review
The outcome of the submission is unknown, good luck to everyone.

rhylongbai 2022-07-28

Pray for it, praise good luck! It has been over three months under review,,, hoping for a favorable outcome,,,

rhylongbai 2022-07-25

Sent a reminder letter to the default system, linked to Academician Wang Zhonglin's email, and the system email was returned.

rhylongbai 2022-07-25

It has been over three months since the manuscript was submitted for review. Today, I planned to send a reminder, but I realized that the editor has never sent an email to the correspondent. The only email received was from a system default email address EM@EDITORIALMANAGER.COM, informing about the assigned manuscript number. This is confusing. The email sent by the submission system is from support@elsevier.com. It's a very peculiar journal. The journal's official website also does not provide an editor's email address.

rhylongbai 2022-07-19

Keep it up, we're almost there, hoping for a good outcome.

aikeyanyanyan 2022-07-19

Mine too, it's been almost three months, hoping that good things come to those who wait.

rhylongbai 2022-07-18

I submitted it for review on 4.22 and it is still under review now.

lynnnnnnn 2022-07-17

After three months of submission, it is finally accepted.
4.18 Submit
4.19 Editor invited
4.27 With editor
5.10 Under review
6.06 Required reviews completed
6.14 Minor revise
6.29 Revised submitted
7.04 Required reviews completed
7.16 Accept

rhylongbai 2022-07-16

I don't know the editor, so I can't see anything. I sent an email to the journal on the system, but there was no response... It has been three months...

aikeyanyanyan 2022-07-14

Mine too, what should I do about it? I'm feeling very anxious.