advanced soft materials 2021-08-13

I want to ask everyone, how long does it take to make modifications after receiving JMCA's feedback? In the email, they only mentioned that they would provide regular reminders but did not specify a deadline.

搬个小板凳看奥特曼 2021-07-29

It has been two months in peer review and no news... Has anyone encountered this situation before... Feeling frustrated _(:з」∠)_

乔少明 2021-07-25

Same, submitted on the 15th, and it was with the editor on the same day, and it has remained unchanged until now.

神 2021-07-23

Posted on the evening of July 22, 2021, only one day later, on the evening of the 23rd, it was "with editor". Isn't it usually a long time for the initial assessment? Did they directly send it to the editor because my article was not good enough? The article I submitted is about single-atom catalysts for CO2 reduction. Has anyone else had the same experience of being "with editor" in one day? What was the final result?

DLY 2021-07-22

Share the submission process.
Submitted on 6.24.
Initial assessment on 6.25.
With editor on 7.2.
In peer review on 7.3.
Minor revision on 7.11.
Revision submitted on 7.20.
Accepted on 7.22.
Overall, except for the initial assessment which took the longest, around eight days, this period was the most anxious as I thought it might be rejected. However, it was very fast once it reached the editor, taking less than a month from submission to acceptance. Thumbs up for JMCA!

DLY 2021-07-20

My initial review was quite slow. I submitted it on June 24th, and it reached the editor on July 2nd. It was reviewed on July 3rd, and I received the revision comments on July 11th.

大鱼 2021-07-17

7-12 Submission

Currently, as of 7-17, it is still in the Initial assessment stage.

I see that other colleagues only take 2 to 3 days to be with the editor. Does Initial assessment usually take this long? Could someone familiar with this journal help analyze the situation? Thank you.

大鱼 2021-07-17

Hello, has your submission been delivered to the editor yet? My submission was on the 12th, but it is still in the Initial assessment phase as of the 17th. Does this mean it's going to be rejected? Thank you.

advanced soft materials 2021-07-14

7.13 major revision
The two reviewers were very friendly. Thanks to the German editor Miriam M. Unterlass.

冲鸭！！！ 2021-07-12

2021.07.05 submitted
2021.07.05 initial assessment
2021.07.06 with editor
2021.07.11 The status disappeared in the submission system, even the previous submission records are gone...
What's going on? Has anyone encountered this before?

一壶乌龙茶 2021-07-12

I submitted it on the 7.5th, and it is still in the Initial assessment stage now.

victor_sjtu 2021-07-07

In general, as long as the editing is submitted for review, the review process is quite fast. I also feel anxious during the submission process and basically log into the system every day to check the status, and also come here to see everyone's sharing. I hope my sharing is helpful to everyone.

victor_sjtu 2021-07-07

Thesis (Zinc battery) received, here is an update on the progress: The assigned editor for handling the manuscript is Kang Kisuk from South Korea (the previously selected editor was not sent).
2021-05-11: Submitted
2021-05-12: Initial assessment
2021-05-15: With editor
2021-05-18: In peer review
2020-05-24: With editor (at that time, there was some confusion, later it was understood that it should be the second round of finding reviewers, ultimately there were four reviewers)
2020-05-25: Immediately followed by in peer review
2020-06-01: Reviewer comments received, major revision (comments from three reviewers were received, all reviewers agreed to accept the manuscript after revisions)
2020-06-03: Follow-up decision, another reviewer's comments received (although this reviewer did not agree to accept, it does not affect the previous decision, the editor suggested addressing the concerns of this reviewer as well)
2020-06-25: Revised manuscript submitted (took three weeks to conduct additional experiments, causing some delay)
2020-07-06: Accepted.

cgydsg1991 2021-07-04

Submit on May 4th, review on the 7th, major revision on June 8th, return on June 25th, and accept on the 28th.

yidingzhong 2021-06-25

How is LZ doing? I've been in the hands of the editor for two weeks, and it still hasn't shown any signs of being sent for review. Is it not going well?

yidingzhong 2021-06-25

I submitted it on the 8th, and it reached the editor's hands on the 11th. It's now the 25th and there hasn't been any response. Did the editor forget?

支付宝在逃RMB 2021-06-25

It has been a week, and it is still the initial assessment. Why is it that others are already with the editor in just one or two days? Feeling disheartened.

zhd236 2021-06-25

6.23 submitted
6.25 with editor

Translation: The submission was made on June 23rd. On June 25th, it was received by the editor.

支付宝在逃RMB 2021-06-24

2021.06.18 - Submitted
2021.6.20 - Initial assessment

Jay21 2021-06-17

2021-6-16 révision soumise
2021-6-17 accepté

2021-6-16 revision submitted
2021-6-17 accepted

letpub李 2021-06-15

translate the following text into English:

5.21 major revision
6.12 revision submitted
6.14 accept

科研痴子 2021-06-11

4.25 submit - Submitted on April 25th.
4.29 in peer review - Under peer review on April 29th.
5.18 major revision - Major revision on May 18th.
5.26 revision submitted - Revised version submitted on May 26th.
5.27 in peer review - Under peer review on May 27th.
6.10 accepted - Accepted on June 10th.
Thank you to editor Aphra Murray (very fast speed, the waiting process was agonizing), and wishing JMCA continued success.

advanced soft materials 2021-06-10

5.23 submitted
5.24 initial assessment
5.25 with editor
6.9 in peer review
The review process is really slow.
The fourth JMCA article.
Hope for good luck.

advanced soft materials 2021-06-02

No need, I only used a template for the communication submission, I didn't use any templates for the other articles, it won't affect the review process.

zhd236 2021-05-31

Do I have to use a template for the JMCA manuscript when preparing to submit it?

GikLY20 2021-05-28

How are you doing now, OP? It's been 11 days, and I'm still with the editor.

GikLY20 2021-05-28

2021.5.17:submitted
2021.5.20:initial assessment
2021.5.24:with editor
The current status is still with the editor. Does it mean it has been rejected? (as of now, 2021.5.28)

biosenser 2021-05-26

Download template and paste format
2021.5.20 Submission
5.21
Checking submission and files
Initial assessment

victor_sjtu 2021-05-24

Follow-up updates:
2020-05-18: in peer review
2020-05-24: with editor

Is the review process this fast? It is now back with the editor, and I don't know what the situation is.

advanced soft materials 2021-05-24

1.16 submit
1.17 initial assessment
2.2 with editor
2.9 in peer review
2.28 major revision
3.18 revision submitted
3.18 in peer review
3.26 accepted
Thank you, Indian editor Goutam De!