天空之城1118 2022-06-17

06.01 resubmitted
06.01 revised version review
06.10 pending minor revisions
06.14 resubmitted
06.14 revised version review
06.14 pending editor decision
06.15 pending minor revisions
06.16 resubmitted
06.16 pending minor revisions
06.17 paper accepted

Translation:
06.01 - Resubmitted
06.01 - Revised version review
06.10 - Pending minor revisions
06.14 - Resubmitted
06.14 - Revised version review
06.14 - Pending editor decision
06.15 - Pending minor revisions
06.16 - Resubmitted
06.16 - Pending minor revisions
06.17 - Paper accepted

nundini 2022-06-17

6.10 接受 translates to "acceptance."

小囊国 2022-06-16

How long will you decide to end your editing?

LITUANTUAN 2022-06-15

Don't say that. It is possible that you have done it recently, so it is faster. Mine is extremely slow (crying, crying).

hanlzh 2022-06-15

Submission on Friday evening (5-19). Confirmation of OA fees on 5-23, so it should have been sent for review. However, until now (6-15), it is still under review. It's been almost a month.

Daisybobo 2022-06-13

I am still pending as well.

Edwin666 2022-06-13

May I ask how long did it take for your article to be accepted after pending editor decision?

科研渣渣5555. 2022-06-12

The post was submitted on 2022/06/09 and it hasn't been reviewed yet as of now (2022/06/12). What is the situation?

卡多希 2022-06-12

Translation:

Posted on April 24th, under review on the same day;
Received first review comments on May 18th, major revisions, a total of five reviewers;
Returned revised version on June 1st, during which a request for deadline extension was made;
Accepted on June 8th.

BSY202004055 2022-06-12

The result of external review came back 15 days after submission. There were 4 reviewers in total, 2 gave a "can" and the rest all said "yes". The editor gave minor revisions and returned them within 5 days. On the fifth day, the revisions were completed and sent back, and they were accepted two days later. It's too unbelievable.

小趴菜233 2022-06-09

May I ask for three general comments on the manuscript review? Feedback will be provided once the review is complete. It seems like I haven't received one yet. Where can I check it?

yuan yi 2022-06-09

I have submitted for two weeks, but the result is unknown. I feel anxious. I saw someone saying that the received review comments can be found on the official website. Could you please tell me the specific location?

天空之城1118 2022-06-02

I will also return in 21 days for the first review. If it does not meet the requirements, it will be rejected within one or two days.

卡多希 2022-06-02

My first trial took 21 days, yours is only 15 days, just wait a bit longer. It seems that if the quality is not good, it will be rejected immediately. In your case, the reviewer's feedback should not have come back yet.

卡多希 2022-06-02

I think it's okay. It has only been 15 days. My first trial took 21 days. I submitted it on April 23rd and received the first trial's opinion on May 18th.

呜呜无鱼 2022-06-02

Estamos escribiendo para informarle que no podremos procesar más su envío. Los envíos enviados para revisión por pares se seleccionan en función de la disciplina, novedad y significado general, además de los criterios habituales para su publicación en revistas académicas. Por lo tanto, nuestra decisión no necesariamente refleja la calidad de su trabajo.

RS-Reviewer-#00135 2022-05-31

From the perspective of a reviewer, it has never taken this long. If so, it is very likely that the quality of the article is not satisfactory.

chenyuzeng 2022-05-31

The submission made on May 18, 2022, has not received any updates so far.

nundini 2022-05-29

3.30 提交 - submitted on March 30th
4.1 under review - under review since April 1st
5.1 major revise - major revisions required on May 1st
5.20 resubmit - resubmitted on May 20th
5.25:pending editor decision - pending editor's decision as of May 25th

litongtong0618 2022-05-26

What is the final result?

zqfff 2022-05-25

This is waiting for the academic editor to make a decision. Generally, the results will be out in a few days.

ABC 2022-05-25

Submitted in the afternoon on May 23rd, currently in a pending review status. It has been 48 hours and it has not changed to under review yet. Is it very likely to be rejected?

天空之城1118 2022-05-25

22.05.03 submit - Submitted on May 22, 2003
05.03 pending review - Under review since May 3
05.04 under review - Under review since May 4
05.24 pending decision - Decision pending since May 24
05.24 pending major revisions - Major revisions pending since May 24

好运自然来 2022-05-25

2022.2.17 Submission rejected, format issues, suggested to revise and resubmit.
2022.2.18 Submission rejected, paper quality not up to standard, suggested to revise and resubmit.
2022.4.2 Submission rejected again, paper in English is not understandable, suggested to revise and resubmit.
2022.4.7 Resubmission.
4.12 Received comments from the first reviewer, 5 cans.
5.12 Received comments from the second reviewer, 5 yeses.
2022.5.24 Minor revisions.
2022.5.25 Acceptance.
Overall, there is a need for innovation. Previously submitted to a top journal in the agricultural field, also suggested to revise and resubmit. The editor recognized the paper's innovative aspects, but language barrier has hindered the quality of the paper. It took half a year for other journals, but the review process in this journal was relatively fast, so it is still worth recommending.

年青人 2022-05-24

Hello, I would like to consult with you. I feel that our situations are somewhat similar. Have you received any results yet? After major revisions, I was advised to reapply within a month, but the feedback I received after being rejected was the same as before. The reasons for my rejection were also modified during the revision process, so I don't know what needs to be changed for the resubmission. What should I do in this situation?

LITUANTUAN 2022-05-23

Hello, may I ask if after the first review, you can see the comments of three reviewers on the webpage. However, the editor has not sent an email yet, and it still says "pending decision." What does that mean? It has been five to six days already.

sky1112 2022-05-18

The image I made was also rejected. I noticed that many people have been rejected by editors recently. Is it because there were too many submissions?

peterwang 2022-05-18

2022.5.16 Submission
2022.5.18 Rejected
Without being reviewed, the editor rejected it.

GRL 2022-05-15

RS is indeed very efficient, being able to maintain a high impact factor of 4.8+ and surpassing the index of the second-tier even with such a large volume of publications (5000+). It is truly not easy. It should not be solely due to luck. The whole process, from submission to major revisions to minor revisions to acceptance to online publication, takes only a month or so.

石头 2022-05-14

22.01.31 Submit
02.01 Under review
04.01 Major revision (deadline: 10 days) Three reviewers provided nearly forty comments. It was not possible to complete the revisions within ten days, so a ten-day extension was requested and approved within five days.
04.15 Still not completed, a second extension request was made and rejected. The editor suggested resubmission, but with the same reviewers.
05.03 Submit the revised version
05.12 Accepted
05.13 Pending English
05.13 Proofreading
05.13 Resubmitted

This is my first SCI paper in life. Originally, my advisor intended to accumulate and submit a larger non-OA paper. However, it has been almost a year since graduation, and both paper submission and PhD application have been challenging. Therefore, a portion of the work was submitted to remote sensing. Two of the three experts provided a significant number of comments, and the resulting revised manuscript became clearer. However, it cost 2500 CHF, which is a bit expensive...