天空之城1118 2022-10-06

When "under review" changes to "pending decision," then you will be able to see the comments.

胡diao 2022-10-05

No need to wait for the editor's decision, you can directly see the reviewer's comments.

胡diao 2022-10-05

The whole process was quite fast. I submitted it on 8.26, and it went under review on the same day. Since it may have been in a popular area, they found three reviewers who all gave a "yes." The editor requested minor revisions, which took 10 days to complete. After resubmitting, it was accepted directly.

baal 2022-10-05

Can anyone see the comments as long as someone uploads them, or do they need to be edited and decided upon before they can be seen?

天空之城1118 2022-10-05

I also have no opinion yet.

baal 2022-10-05

No news at all, although I don't know where to find the evaluation results, but it should be nothing. How about you?

天空之城1118 2022-10-05

Do you have any comments or feedback?

zshgostop 2022-10-02

Can schools in China also select foreign districts?

joey16 2022-09-30

9.30 is awaiting the decision of the editor.

dadatong 2022-09-30

Will there be a response within one day after major repairs and returns?

半尧 2022-09-29

Post on August 26, 2022; Deadline for major revisions set for ten days on September 13; Refine and submit revised manuscript on September 26 and 27 (extension requested until the 28th for careful editing); Re-revision, editorial decision, and acceptance of the article on September 28.

冲着SCI来的 2022-09-29

How are you? Has it been reviewed?

冲着SCI来的 2022-09-29

What is the result, has it been under review?

冲着SCI来的 2022-09-29

Yesterday I submitted it, pending review until now, is it still pending or rejected?

天空之城1118 2022-09-28

Yes, it was changed after "under." Mine was under review in less than 4 hours.

菜鸟一只 2022-09-28

Could you please clarify whether the assistant editor notifies you to modify the email address after being "under review," or if they request you to modify the email address before sending it for external review? Also, how long does it usually take for your initial review to be approved? Is it also around two business days?

wanglingli 2022-09-28

Does using 163 mailbox affect submissions?

天空之城1118 2022-09-27

The preliminary review and email are not related. At that time, I had an author's email address which was also from 163. After the preliminary review, the editor asked me to change to a different institutional email or provide an explanation, similar to stating that the previous email has not published any articles.

菜鸟一只 2022-09-27

I want to ask everyone, is it necessary for the email address to be an institutional email? If the suffix is 163, will it be rejected in the initial review? I submitted it on September 25th and it is still pending review. I feel very anxious.

呵呵呵呵呵呵呵 2022-09-27

The paper has been accepted on September 27th.

呵呵呵呵呵呵呵 2022-09-27

9.27 pending editor decision.

000100 2022-09-26

9.26 Pending review
9.26 Under review

baal 2022-09-24

Let's submit together on the same day and wait for the results.

路灯の闪闪 2022-09-21

8.12 Submission
9.16 Acceptance
After being rejected by the Atmospheric Pollution Research journal after a two-month review, I angrily submitted to RS. In less than three weeks, I received a major revision notice. The opinions provided by all three reviewers were very reliable. After making the revisions, it was accepted within a week. The review speed was truly super fast, I love it, I love it! This is amazing! If given the opportunity, I will continue to submit in the future.

木巾 2022-09-21

8.21 Submission
9.21 Accepted

天空之城1118 2022-09-21

2022.9.20 pending review
2022.9.20 under review

nififikan 2022-09-19

2022.9.16 pending review translates to "September 16, 2022, awaiting review."

Jing Liu 2022-09-19

2022.9.5 Pending Review - This means that the item is currently under review and a decision has not been made yet.

20229.7 Rejected by Editor - This indicates that the item was reviewed by an editor and has been rejected.

Ambition™ 2022-09-14

9.13 Accepted for Publication: It took 34 days, and the overall review speed was quite fast. The reviewers' comments were also quite fair and reasonable.

Ambition™ 2022-09-13

8.31: Able to see the opinions of three reviewers, one opinion is more positive, one gave 5 yeses, and there is one with 3 musts and three cans. Waiting for the opinion of the fourth reviewer.
9.2: Pending major revision: The fourth reviewer exceeded the deadline, so there are only three reviewers left, and they recommended major revisions.
9.9: Resubmit
9.10: Pending revision version review
9.13: Pending editor decision: Both reviewers agreed to publish.
Continue waiting...