InSAR_delay 2022-11-21

August 17, 2022: Submission
September 5, 2022: Suggested for revision and resubmission
October 17, 2022: Resubmission
October 29, 2022: Minor revisions
November 3, 2022: Submitted after modifications
November 8, 2022: Published

sooyio 2022-11-21

Has yours been pending for almost 20 days? Is it pending decision or pending editor decision? Mine has been pending for 11 days.

haoran_1227 2022-11-20

It has been 11 days and it is still pending review. The review process is not as fast as I imagined. I looked at my supervisor's reviewing system and there is a huge number of manuscripts, with new additions every day. Now, I am just waiting for rejection. I suggest those who want to submit to RS quickly to be cautious.

ziqi77 2022-11-19

Excuse me, may I ask what is the current result?

WAITING1 2022-11-19

Hello classmate, may I ask if you submitted to the regular issue or the special issue? Is the regular issue of this journal fast in terms of speed?

Zhanchao 2022-11-18

November 16th, submitted/pending review, 4 hours later under review. Hopefully, there will be a good outcome.

Wikiwang 2022-11-16

What about now? How is it going?

haoran_1227 2022-11-14

It's been five days and there hasn't been any news. I read online that if a review is pending for more than two days without being approved, it means rejection. Why haven't they rejected my submission yet?

Giser-SJH 2022-11-09

It is possible that they want to take the route of the general loop.

Hakertop 2022-11-08

May I ask everyone, I submitted on October 12th, it started under review on October 17th, and it is still under review on November 8th. Can I send an email to ask for the specific situation?

dadatong 2022-11-07

Just don't invest yourself, isn't that fine?

Giser-SJH 2022-11-07

I'm just curious why the publication output of this Remote Sensing journal is so high. Aren't they afraid of being warned by the Chinese Academy of Sciences? By the end of the year, the estimated annual submission volume will probably be less than ten thousand...

wangyishen 2022-11-04

Fecha de recepción
26 de agosto de 2022
Fecha de revisión
19 de octubre de 2022
Fecha de aceptación
27 de octubre de 2022
Fecha de publicación
29 de octubre de 2022

广仁 2022-11-04

Increase the speed of proofreading by one day, as I have a higher word count. Make it slightly more than one day, maybe half a day more.

ZFF发发 2022-11-03

Is there any result, brother?

康德 2022-11-03

What does "这个均没有意见是什么意思？是没有第二轮意见上传吗？" mean? Does it mean there is no second round of opinions uploaded?

Coke7777 2022-11-03

2022.11.1 Submission Special Issue,
2022.11.3 Under review
Continue to wait next.

啊啊喝啤酒 2022-11-02

9.26 submit - Submitted on September 26th
9.28 pending - Pending on September 28th
10.15 major revision - Major revision on October 15th
10.25 resubmit - Resubmitted on October 25th
11.1 第二轮审稿人都同意发表 - All reviewers in the second round agree to publish on November 1st
11.1 pending editor decision，焦虑中 - Pending editor decision, feeling anxious on November 1st

测绘学生 2022-11-01

Rejected after 5 months of submission? That's a little upsetting.

Shiryu 2022-10-31

Just got rejected. There were three reviewers for the first round of review. Reviewer 1 and Reviewer 3 gave positive feedback, while Reviewer 2 mentioned that there was insufficient innovation and suggested major revisions. For the second round of review, only Reviewer 1 provided comments, stating that they had no further questions. However, the editor still rejected the submission.

Shiryu 2022-10-31

Just got rejected. There were three reviewers in the first round of review. Reviewer 1 and Reviewer 3 gave positive feedback, while Reviewer 2 mentioned insufficient innovation and requested major revisions. In the second round, only Reviewer 1 provided comments, stating no further concerns. However, the editor still decided to reject the manuscript.

王宝 2022-10-31

Excuse me, may I ask how long it took for your Rapid editing to come back? I also submitted mine a day ago and I'm a little worried.

wysyqmm 2022-10-30

Received: 26 August 2022 / Revised: 19 October 2022 / Accepted: 27 October 2022 / Published: 29 October 2022

Happy

天空之城1118 2022-10-28

Does remote sensing receive a DOI number upon acceptance or upon publication?

lqzzzz 2022-10-27

Received manuscript on June 16, 2022.
Received first review on July 18, 2022.
Initially, two reviewers provided extensive comments.
On July 23, 2022, the number of reviewers increased to three, and the editor sent an email requesting the manuscript to be revised within ten days and to respond to the reviewers' comments.
Since the status of the reviewers can be seen on the MDPI system, I started preparing additional experiments and improving the manuscript as soon as I received the comments from the two reviewers, so there was still enough time.
Reviewer 1 asked me to conduct physical experiments and provided one or two comments, which were relatively easy to address. Currently, MDPI places great emphasis on having physical experiments, so there is a high probability of rejection if the study is purely simulation-based.
Reviewer 2 had a different perspective from mine, and I did not understand why they reviewed my paper. It seemed like they didn't fully comprehend my research and frequently asked me to cite their own papers in their comments. They listed nearly 15 comments, which I addressed one by one and also referenced the literature they mentioned.
Reviewer 3 carefully reviewed the paper and suggested me to add some theoretical aspects in a few sections, modify the abstract, and address language issues. I replied to each comment and made the necessary revisions.
Received minor revisions on July 28, 2022. Reviewer 2 had no further comments, and Reviewer 3 was no longer involved (probably considered the issues as minor and not in need of further review). Reviewer 1 provided additional comments, suggesting to merge some headings and correct spelling errors. I replied to each comment.
Editor reviewed and revised on July 30, 2022.
Accepted on July 31, 2022.

WeimingChen 2022-10-26

投的Special Issue，速度很快，以下是投稿进度：
2022-09-15: 提交，待审核
2022-09-20: 正在审核中
2022-10-17: 待进行小修订
2022-10-21: 重新提交
2022-10-22: 等待编辑决定
2022-10-26: 接受，待英文翻译

imbawin 2022-10-26

7.29 Submission
9.5 Received rejection and resubmission suggestions
9.20 Revised
9.21 Resubmitted for review
9.30 Received major revision suggestions
10.8 Revised
10.10 Reviewer comments returned, no comments, pending editor decision
10.25 Sent reminder email to associate editor, changed academic editor, paper accepted in the evening.

Goeunn 2022-10-24

Globeland30&ASTGTM2 does not have a clear meaning in any language. It appears to be a combination of letters and numbers that do not form any recognizable words or phrases.

yyz+ 2022-10-23

Did you use remote sensing data? If yes, what kind of data did you use?

Goeunn 2022-10-23

I am involved in land cover change information, and I personally believe it is related to remote sensing. Additionally, three other expert reviewers also agree that it is related to remote sensing, otherwise they wouldn't have recommended significant revisions during the first review. However, this is the result after the major revisions.