yellowsmallblue 2021-12-18

2021-12-17 online translates to "December 17, 2021 online" in English.

yellowsmallblue 2021-12-17

2021-11-2 Post
2021-11-18 Major Revision
2021-12-3 Resubmit
2021-12-14 Accepted
2021-12-15 Author proofreading
2021-12-17 Author proofreading resubmit
2021-12-17 Pending conversion

xander-zhan 2021-12-13

2021-11-11 Post,
2021-11-11 under review
2021-12-13 under review

子不问马 2021-12-12

18/11/2021 submit
06/12/2021 minor revision
10/12/2021 resubmit
11/12/2021 accepted

Translation:
18/11/2021 submit
06/12/2021 minor revision
10/12/2021 resubmit
11/12/2021 accepted

小狮子J 2021-12-11

The content submitted matches 99% of the special issue, with fast review and fast publication.

November 14, 2021: Submission.
November 23, 2021: Major revision, but the reviewers didn't suggest many changes. Deadline: 10 days.
December 2, 2021: Major revision returned.
December 3, 2021: Minor revision.
December 5, 2021: Minor revision returned.
December 7, 2021: Acceptance.
December 8, 2021: Confirmation of proofread version.
December 10, 2021, 2 PM: Submission of confirmed proofread version.
December 10, 2021, 11 PM: Online.

It was really fast, and I feel like my slow editing delayed the editors' speed. Throughout the process, there was a contact person who sent reminders and urged me. It's just that I was lazy (crying face).

天柱山学者 2021-12-07

2021.12.6 under review translates to "December 6, 2021 under review" in English.

宝宝很开心 2021-12-05

May I ask if you have any news now?

hello-word 2021-12-04

09/11/2021 submit - Submitted on 09/11/2021
10/11/2021 under review - Under review on 10/11/2021
24/11/2021 major revision - Major revision required on 24/11/2021
26/11/2021 resubmit - Resubmit on 26/11/2021
27/11/2021 minor revision - Minor revision required on 27/11/2021
27/11/2021 resubmit - Resubmit on 27/11/2021
28/11/2021 pending - Currently pending

xander-zhan 2021-12-03

I submitted my manuscript on the same day as you, but I haven't received the review results yet...

HohaiLee 2021-12-03

12.3 is still pending. It doesn't feel good. Praying for blessings.

FangFFF 2021-12-02

Actually, if the manuscript is highly innovative and has sufficient workload, the review process is quite fast. The manuscript I am currently working on is about landscape ecology/biogeography and carbon sequestration. I submitted it to an RCR with an impact factor of 10.2 this summer. Later, I got seriously ill (sigh, doing a PhD is not easy) and it coincided with my imminent graduation. Fortunately, I saw a relevant special issue in RS, so I submitted it there. The first review took 10 days, with three reviewers giving acceptance, minor revision, and neutral feedback, respectively. I received major revisions. After 10 days, I made the revisions and submitted them the next day. The minor revisions were completed in the morning, and the acceptance came in the afternoon. The speed is indeed impressive. But to be honest, I rarely read articles from RS. I mainly read journals in ecology, such as GCB, GEB, EL, JOE, ECOL, and so on. RS has always had a mediocre reputation, but my doctoral career is coming to an end, and I don't have much time left. I just want to quickly showcase my current work. It's better than letting good things rot in my hands. I wish all my colleagues good luck with their submissions and hope to publish more in RSE and TGRS. When I had no other choice but to choose RS, I polished the article well. Being responsible to others and to oneself. After all, an article stays in the database even after a person's death.

11/11/2021: Submitted
11/11/2021: Under review
11/22/2021: Major revision
12/1/2021: Resubmitted
12/2/2021: Minor revision
12/2/2021: Accepted

xander-zhan 2021-12-02

Posted on 2021.11.11, it is still under review and there is no other information.

天柱山学者 2021-12-02

Already submitted, looking forward to a reply.

HohaiLee 2021-12-02

12.2日投搞 translates to "12.2 day submission event." However, "Pending" remains the same in English.

Jack 2021-11-30

Pray before submitting, hoping for mercy from the editor.

树熊 2021-11-26

The original text translates to: "The original poster is really attentive, thank you for sharing!"

弓长广文武 2021-11-26

During my graduate studies, I wrote my first article, officially began experiments and writing in April, and submitted the manuscript at the end of July. I initially submitted it to ISPRS with full confidence, but it was rejected overnight. Fortunately, it took a long time for the rejection, which gave me some relief. Later, I switched to TGRS and submitted the article on August 2, 2021. It was returned on August 31 (the efficiency was impressive, maybe luck ran out, causing the subsequent submission of RS to be slow). There were four reviewers, two of them were positive, one did not express a stance, and the last one said that what I did was not worthwhile (huh? Later, I found out that I encountered a junior peer). The editor suggested submitting to Jstars, but I felt it would be quicker at the time. Unable to handle it anymore and rushing for a prize evaluation, I resubmitted to RS (now I want to slap myself for it). In this way, after going round and round, RS accepted my first article in life, and it was also my first SCI Q2 article (I hope RS won't disappoint in the future, as this submission process made me feel that RS is truly reliable). I hope all of you here have smooth submissions, and I hope my future research path, despite its difficulties, will continue to move forward!!! (I still can't understand why the editor asked me to resubmit and update the ID ··ε=(´ο｀*))) Sigh, feeling emotional.)

弓长广文武 2021-11-26

2021-11-25, author proofreading-resubmitted;
2021-11-26, final check;
2021-11-26, pending conversion;
2021-11-26, conversion skipped;
2021-11-26, website online.

Translation:

2021-11-25, author proofreading-resubmitted;
2021-11-26, final check;
2021-11-26, pending conversion;
2021-11-26, conversion skipped;
2021-11-26, website online.

弓长广文武 2021-11-26

2021-10-29 submitted; [Re-submitted];
Around November 10th, [The system granted me permission and I saw that both reviewers' comments were from October 29th. One had no comments, and the other suggested some minor changes to a table. Still haven't heard from the third reviewer (too scared to ask)];
November 15th, pending minor revisions [The editor asked for some minor changes, specifically to the table, and told me to wait for the third reviewer (delayed my scholarship application o(╥﹏╥)o)];
November 18th [There were very few changes to make, and I finished them, including replying to the comments, in one night. Waited for three to four days and couldn't bear it anymore, so I asked the editor whether to submit or continue waiting. The editor said: Wait!];
November 22nd [The editor reminded me that they received feedback from the third reviewer, note: make the changes quickly, two days' time! (o(╥﹏╥)o) I checked the system. The third reviewer had no comments. Waited in vain.];
November 22nd, resubmitted;
November 23rd, revised version review;
November 23rd, pending editor decision;
November 24th, paper accepted; [Paid the fee, so expensive];
November 24th, pending English.

弓长广文武 2021-11-26

2021-10-29 submitted;
2021-11-10 approximately 【The system granted me permission and I saw that both reviewers' comments were from October 29th. One had no comments, while the other asked me to make a slight change to a table. Still waiting for the third reviewer (I dare not bother them)】;
2021-11-15 pending minor revisions 【The editor requested minor revisions, asking me to make changes to that table and wait for the third reviewer (it delayed my scholarship evaluation o(╥﹏╥)o)】;
2021-11-18 【There were very few modifications, completed in one night, including replying and making revisions. Waited for three to four days and couldn't bear it, so I asked the editor if I should submit or continue waiting. The editor said: Wait!】;
2021-11-22 【The editor reminded me that they received the comments from the third reviewer, note: make the changes quickly, two days' time! (o(╥﹏╥)o) I checked the system. The third reviewer had no comments, waited in vain.】;
2021-11-22 resubmitted;
2021-11-23 revised version review;
2021-11-23 pending editor decision;
2021-11-24 paper accepted; 【Paid the fee, quite expensive】.

弓长广文武 2021-11-26

Extra! Extra! A student named Dog submitted their RS in September but it was not accepted until the end of November, setting a new record for the longest RS submission time!!! Looking back, these three months have been really frustrating.

2021-09-04: Submitted
2021-09-07: Under review
2021-09-18: Reviewer 1 replied, suggesting major revisions
Around 2021-09-20: Reviewer 2 replied, with positive feedback
2021-10-04: Under review (Editor granted me permission to view the comments from the two reviewers, which made me anxious while waiting)
2021-10-07: Pending major revisions (Academic editor gave me a ten-day deadline for revisions, but mentioned that we have to wait for the third reviewer's feedback while revising)
2021-10-14: Pending major revisions (Feedback from the third reviewer arrived, requiring major revisions and requesting a ten-day extension)
2021-10-29: Resubmitted (After revising, the editor asked me to submit it as a new manuscript, but assured me that it's just an ID update process and the reviewers will still review it. The editor will also inform them that it's just an ID update process. But deep down, I feel like it's almost equivalent to rejection and resubmission.)

ChenLY 2021-11-23

2021-10-7, Submission
2021-11-2, Major revision
2021-11-7, Resubmission
2021-11-10, Acceptance

There were four reviewers, who didn't provide many suggestions (1-2 each). Except for the suggestions from the third reviewer, which were reasonable and led to serious revisions, the rest were hastily done.

碧海星空 2021-11-22

"So quickly got hired."

碧海星空 2021-11-22

Is it so unfortunate?

Kelly250230225 2021-11-19

Already hired, looking forward to your follow-up.

黎156 2021-11-19

Looking forward to the follow-up, hoping for a good outcome.

Kelly250230225 2021-11-18

November 17, 2021 - Conversion skipped
November 17, 2021 - Website online
It will be online soon. Although this paper has been through twists and turns, it has also gained a lot. Thanks to everyone who has helped me~

Kelly250230225 2021-11-17

2021年11月12日 Revised version review
2021年11月12日 Pending editor decision
2021年11月15日 Paper accepted
2021年11月15日 Pending English
2021年11月16日 English correction done
2021年11月16日 Author proofreading
2021年11月16日 Author proofreading-resubmitted
2021年11月16日 Pending conversion

Translation:

November 12, 2021 Revised version review
November 12, 2021 Pending editor decision
November 15, 2021 Paper accepted
November 15, 2021 Pending English
November 16, 2021 English correction done
November 16, 2021 Author proofreading
November 16, 2021 Author proofreading-resubmitted
November 16, 2021 Pending conversion

Kelly250230225 2021-11-17

October 11, 2021 - Rejected and resubmitted, under review.
October 22, 2021 - Pending decision.
October 26, 2021 - Pending major revisions, a lot of issues.
November 5, 2021 - Resubmitted, response was 16 pages long.
November 5, 2021 - Received revised version.
November 5, 2021 - Reviewing revised version.
November 5, 2021 - Pending editor decision.
November 8, 2021 - Pending minor revisions.
November 11, 2021 - Resubmitted.

团团91 2021-11-13

Received Date: 29th September 2021
Revised Date: 12th November 2021
Accepted Date: 13th November 2021
Submission to First Decision (Days): 37

Three reviewers provided helpful feedback on the paper, and the quality of the journal is also improving. We hope everyone will have good results as well.