Flying bravely 2022-05-28

The review process is too slow. It took 2 months to find reviewers and another 4 months to receive their comments. There were 3 reviewers who provided a total of 37 comments. In the end, they rejected the paper, stating insufficient innovation and inadequate analysis. I will never submit to this journal again, as it wasted so much time! The journal's requirements are very high, so I don't recommend submitting if you are in a hurry. It's just a waste of time!

Charlir 2022-05-17

Comparatively slow, it takes a week for the submission to be in the status of being assigned to an editor. After sending an inquiry letter, it takes one day to update to the status of editor review. The submission has been half a month already, and we are currently searching for a reviewer.

One_tiger 2022-05-14

Still haven't found a reviewer, this speed is really unbelievable. Regretting submitting to this low impact factor journal.

One_tiger 2022-04-22

The text "Associate Editor Review 19-Apr-2022" is already in English.

xiaofive 2022-04-21

May I ask if there are any results yet? It has been 60 days since I submitted my manuscript and it is still under associate editor review...

wangqizhou 2022-04-20

After two major repairs, I was hired. More than 50 days later, I received a notification for the first rework. After several modifications, it was approximately 50 more days before I was finally hired. Overall, it was relatively satisfactory, with only one reviewer.

Highest 2022-04-19

May I ask if there have been any changes in the status of your current submission?

冲冲冲1231978 2022-04-15

Is it possible to hire directly without going through the review process?

One_tiger 2022-04-15

It has been several days since the submission, and there has been no progress. May I ask if the journal still needs to be sent for external review?
Associate Editor Assigned 12-Apr-2022
Submission Check by Journal Office Completed 12-Apr-2022 1
Submission Check by Journal Office Started 11-Apr-2022
Deputy Editor Assigned 11-Apr-2022
Manuscript Submitted to Journal Office 11-Apr-2022
Preliminary Manuscript Data Submitted 11-Apr-2022

One_tiger 2022-04-11

I have already switched to AIP Adv2 for two days, but I haven't received the official email yet. Why is it so slow?

黎淼 2022-04-09

May I ask how long it took for your article to be edited in the end? It has been ten days since the editing of my article started, and I haven't received any updates. From March 30th to April 9th.

少年郭同学 2022-04-08

Not bad, quite fast, just a bit expensive.

One_tiger 2022-04-04

I submitted to JAP and got rejected. The editor suggested submitting to AIP Advances instead. The AIP editor has been sending emails urging me to submit, but I have been hesitating because the impact factor is a bit low. It seems like your submission was very successful and fast. It looks like there is no need for further review, and the editorial department has directly accepted it, right?

One_tiger 2022-04-04

I submitted to JAP but got rejected. The editor suggested submitting to AIP Advances instead. The AIP editor has been sending continuous emails urging me to submit there, but I have been hesitant because the impact factor is a bit low.

It seems like your submission was very successful and fast. It looks like there's no need for further review, and the editorial department will directly accept it, right?

Sun 2022-04-01

I am too, it has been 80 days since I submitted the manuscript and I am still looking for reviewers.

尹先 2022-03-23

Posted for 80 days and still searching for reviewers.
It's time-sensitive, not recommended to submit, too slow...
Sincerely want to withdraw the submission.

平行宇宙之艾斯达克星球商店 2022-02-21

The POF submission was rejected, with two reviewers providing feedback. One suggested accepting it directly, while the other rejected it after giving three suggestions. The editor suggested submitting it to AIP Advances and it was accepted after minor revisions. The process from revisions to acceptance took a total of 4 days. The editor was very efficient.

尹先 2022-02-21

The speed is too slow, it has been 49 days since submission, and there are still no results. We have been constantly searching for reviewers, but this journal is really lacking in reviewers. Sigh.

探索者666 2022-02-06

Please wait patiently, mine will take about 15 days.

rolly 2022-02-06

May I ask how long it took for the review? My current status is also assigned as an associate editor.

爆炸 2022-02-05

The work efficiency is extremely high. I submitted it on December 1st last year and received the acceptance notice on December 27th. The proof was done at the beginning of January, and it went online around the 20th. Emails were replied to almost the next day without delay.

阿豪要毕业 2022-01-28

Posted on December 14th, there was a 7-day Christmas holiday in between. Feedback for revision was received on January 6th. The revised manuscript was submitted on January 14th and accepted on January 24th. Overall, the process was quite fast.

I would like to inquire about the assigned issue number, which is 2022.2.28. How long will it take for it to be indexed by Web of Science?

成功院校在读 2022-01-17

Send an email to the publishing house to remind them, that's all. It's been two months since my article in September hasn't been indexed. I sent an email to remind them, and two weeks later they replied saying it has been included.

林先 2022-01-10

The submission made on December 27th, what's going on with being assigned as associate editor? This is too slow.

Dynamo Pooh 2022-01-07

My status has always been "associate editor review". I sent an email asking for a reply and was told to wait patiently. It has been over a month since I sent it back for major revisions.

奔跑的second道哥 2022-01-06

How did your article turn out, friend? Mine has also been reviewed back and forth...

hui0212 2022-01-04

The one hired in November is not yet searchable in WOS. I remember that the first article in AIP can be searched after one month. Is the current indexing speed of this journal so slow?

lp珠峡 2021-12-29

The layout fee is $1500. I think the review process is still quite fast, but the comments indicate that the paper quality requirements are still high. Mine was transferred from the second-tier journal, and I have already met the graduation requirements, so I don't have many demands and decided to transfer it here.

尹先 2021-12-25

Hello, I would like to ask about the speed of review, graduation requirements, and whether it is recommended to submit or not.

wuzihuan 2021-12-25

Hello, I would like to ask how much is the page fee for submitting to AIP? I am in a hurry to graduate, so do you recommend submitting or not?