认证评论 - Scientific Reports
注: 认证评论选取于全球各个学术评论平台和社交媒体。

gaoxinan 2023-04-15

The second trial was completed on March 17th and is awaiting editing decisions. Suddenly, it has now changed to "Technical check passed." I don't know if it's a negative outcome.

kksiz 2023-04-13

How long does it usually take to review a manuscript?

夏天夏 2023-04-12

Are you available now?

smile123 2023-04-10

This comment has been deleted.

smile123 2023-04-10

Seeing that last year's paper is not yet included in Web of Science, I don't know if I should pay for it or not. I am worried that there might be issues with the journal.

南北我鲜 2023-04-10

I have not been included either. It was published on December 19th, 2022.

南北我鲜 2023-04-10

I also published it in December last year, but it has not been included in SCI until now.

南北我鲜 2023-04-10

2022.9.15 Submission
2022.11.30 Provide feedback
2022.12.15 Revised manuscript
2022.12.19 Publication

However, as of 2023.4.10, it has not been indexed by SCI!!!
First query on 2023.3.15, not retrieved, checked every day, still not indexed.
Authors from other schools who published during the same period have encountered the same problem.
This indicates that this is not an isolated case.
The cost of 17,000 RMB is not cheap, and if it is not indexed, both the document and the money will be wasted.
Please be cautious when submitting!!!

lyxapple 2023-04-09

Does it only take 5 days from being hired to publication?

lyxapple 2023-04-09

How long does it take from being hired to publishing?

lyxapple 2023-04-09

How long does it take from being hired to publication?

lyxapple 2023-04-09

Already hired, when will it be published?

我爱罗 2023-04-08

I checked the papers from the end of last year and they have not been indexed yet. I don't know if there will be any issues with the journal.

Xiaocainiao 2023-04-05

The article was published in early December last year, but it has not been included in SCI yet. What's the situation? Has there been any issue with this journal?

吴琦不有 2023-03-29

Submitted in May 2022, during the period I sent emails but received no response, thinking it was lost. Suddenly in February 2023, an email was sent to me stating that the review comments were given. On March 1, 2023, I made the necessary revisions and submitted. Accepted on March 24. The process took too long.

Saniye 2023-03-29

The publication's review fee is so high, yet they don't review the manuscripts quickly. It's really frustrating, where does the money go? It's maddening.

Saniye 2023-03-29

I submitted it on December 23rd last year and waited for two months. I followed up in February, and the editor said they were still looking for reviewers and asked me to recommend some. I was speechless because they should have told me earlier. I made the recommendations, and now it has been under review for a month. I don't know what's going on...

EVA@qq 2023-03-28

"2 Reviewer(s) accepted" means that there are already reviewers who have accepted the review.

EVA@qq 2023-03-28

"Showing 2 Reviewer(s) accepted, does it mean that the manuscript has been reviewed by reviewers?"

EVA@qq 2023-03-28

How many reviewers are usually there?

Outman 2023-03-23

Hello, may I ask if your article has been indexed by WOS after it was accepted?

emerge123 2023-03-21

Direction of image processing. It seems that this journal has relatively few relevant editors. I have heard from friends that they have been unable to find reviewers/appropriate editors. In my experience, I have always sent emails to urge them. After all, it is a paid journal, and the editors have been very good in their attitude; there is no phenomenon of rejection due to urging. I submitted the paper at the end of October 22, and during that time, they kept giving me feedback that they couldn't find an appropriate editor. I sent three emails to urge them, and finally, in February 23, an appropriate editor was assigned, and shortly after, reviewers were assigned. After minor revisions, the paper was published in the following month. As for payment, I used a credit card to make the payment through the submission system and did not encounter any domestic collection issues. If there is such a situation, it is best to contact the journal to confirm.

天池守望者 2023-03-19

5 months, always invited as an editor, have applied for withdrawal of the manuscript, but haven't received a response yet. Be cautious about submitting theoretical manuscripts, as there is no one reviewing them.

刘胖胖爱学习 2023-03-17

My payment link is in the system, but it's all in English and I can't understand it.

12345qq 2023-03-16

The matter of receiving payments from Zhongke is true. However, it is advisable to be cautious about remittance. If you have any doubts, it is recommended to verify with the official email of the journal.

河豚26 2023-03-12

How much is the layout fee in US dollars, it's over 19,000.

潇湘夜雨 2023-03-10

Overall, it was fast, in line with the speed of an OA journal. The two reviewers raised professional questions regarding the simulation of geological and construction materials.

22.12.23 Submitted
23.01.08 Approved by the editor, sent to two reviewers for review
23.01.27 First round of revisions
23.02.13 Second round of revisions
23.03.08 Received revision comments
23.03.10 Accepted

豆子打鬼子 2023-03-08

Boss, I would like to consult you about a remittance issue. I am also making a remittance to Beijing Zhongke using a corporate-to-corporate transfer. However, the remittance note is too long to fill in completely. I would like to ask you how you handle this.

EVA@qq 2023-03-07

Really? It was submitted in November 2022? Wow, what is this journal doing?

天池守望者 2023-03-06

I submitted it in November last year, and it is still in "editor invited" status. I feel that this journal does not prefer papers with strong theoretical content, but rather prefers experimental ones. It is difficult to find reviewers for theoretical papers.

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started

Ask a Question. Answer a Question.

Quickly pose questions to the entire community. Debate answers and get clarity on the most important issues facing researchers.

Get Started