徐同学 2022-04-17

Posted on April 17, 2022.

南辞 2022-04-05

2022-4-5 received.

南辞 2022-04-04

2021-7.13: Submission of manuscript
2021-9.8: First major revision (2 reviewers, 15 comments)
2021-9.23: Revised manuscript submission
2022-3.28: Minor revision comments returned (1 issue from the Associate Editor, 2 issues from the reviewers)
2022-4.4: Minor revision submission

hahuhu 2022-03-30

Hello, may I ask if the images and articles need to be submitted separately when submitting to this journal? What field are you working in? Thank you.

jingbao 2022-03-29

Submitted in January, returned with minor revisions in March, and then accepted directly. So fast!!! There were three reviewers, and their opinions were considered professional.

jingbao 2022-03-29

I just accepted it too. It will take 3 months, and once the editing is done, I will get back to you to confirm the layout and whether it is OA.

毛毛虫123 2022-03-27

After acceptance, do we just need to wait for layout and formatting or do we need to upload the manuscript again?

jingbao 2022-03-26

Really? It took so long, and I just got approved.

南辞 2022-03-09

No results yet.

想毕业想要论文 2022-02-22

I have been in this state for a long time too, for over a month already. I want to know whether I should remind or not.

南辞 2022-02-13

2021.7.13 Submission
2021.9.8 Major revision review
2021.9.23 Major revision resubmission
Still awaiting results from the re-review since 2021.9.21, feeling too anxious.

南辞 2022-02-13

Brother, how are you doing? My second trial has been going on for 5 months.

zxk 2022-02-13

Please, hurry up and give me a result.

HeDan0821 2022-02-10

Hello, may I ask how long it takes for this journal to be published (the kind that can be searched) after receiving the manuscript from the school? Thank you!

HeDan0821 2022-02-10

Hello, may I ask how long it takes to be published after receiving and proofreading (the kind that can be searched)?

janeyou 2022-02-06

The first review took 5 months, and after a major revision, it was submitted with serious modifications.
The second review took 2 months, and during the process, one reviewer rejected it, very resolutely.
The result of the third review is unknown.

zxk 2022-02-05

This journal is too scary.

苦修 2022-01-29

After major repairs, minor repairs were conducted and it took a full 10 months to be hired. Minor repairs were given only after 4 months after major repairs.

fatislord 2022-01-21

2021/7/13 Submission
2021/10/15 First review result, four reviewers, 13 provided positive feedback and recognized the research value, but pointed out the lack of innovation and requested the proposal of new methods. Reviewer 4 provided in-depth comments and discussed many technical issues with me. However, Reviewer 2 was extremely critical, providing 21 negative comments, stating that there was a lack of innovation and improvement needed in writing.
2021/12/5 Submitted revised manuscript for first review
2022/1/21 Accepted

As someone from a different field, I am already satisfied to have a paper accepted in a computer graphics CCF Class C journal. It means I have made some progress. It seems that the journal has certain requirements for the professional level in computer graphics. The paper needs to have some theoretical depth and its own methods. The journal may be aiming for a higher impact factor recently, and the future quality requirements for papers may become even higher. I hope the journal continues to improve.

niko_zhang 2021-12-20

2021/5/29 Submission
2021/6/15 Under review
2021/7/28 Received major revision comments
2021/8/27 Submitted major revision
2021/9/29 Received minor revision comments
2021/10/12 Submitted minor revision
2021/11/10 Accepted

南辞 2021-12-12

After submitting the major revision around September 23, it has not yet been returned for reevaluation.

Zhaoqian Jia 2021-12-11

Posted on March 29, 2021, the first review took about two months, and a total of three revisions were made. Accepted on December 10, 2021.

zxk 2021-12-08

Posted on July 23rd,
Still no result from the first review.

zxk 2021-12-08

"Reviewing is as slow as a snail."

janeyou 2021-11-18

It has been over four months since I submitted my manuscript, and there is still no result from the first review. I heard that this journal used to have a decent speed for the review process, so why is it so slow now?

陈景翊 2021-11-10

21 Aug 2021 submitted
08 Oct 2021 accepted
06 Nov 2021 online
Less than two months from submission to publication, accepted without any revisions.

tys 2021-09-27

Brother, we are experiencing something similar.

积极的金金金 2021-09-26

Conference recommended submission rejected in the first review.
07 Aug 2021 Submitted
10 Aug 2021 Requested to supplement Compliance with Ethical Standards
11 Aug 2021 Editor Assignment Pending
13 Aug 2021 Under Review
16 Aug 2021 Still Under Review
17 Sep 2021 Reviews Completed
22 Sep 2021 Reject
Received feedback from reviewers 1, 2, and 4. The first two provided around 5 points of suggested revisions, including higher requirements for innovation and contribution explanations, as well as the use of LaTeX to generate the manuscript and insert vector graphics (although the journal actually requires submission in Word format, as generating PDF images can result in blurriness). The final reviewer was relatively perfunctory and did not provide specific suggestions.

tys 2021-09-23

Posted on September 18, 2021;
Rejected on September 22, 2021, reason: not in line with the main direction of the journal.
The email mentioned that they would recommend suitable journals, with two options: agree to switch submission or refuse to switch submission. I stubbornly chose the latter option.

南辞 2021-09-23

2021-07-12 Submission
2021-07-16 External Review
2021-09-08 Major Revision
2021-09-23 Submission of Major Revision