认证评论 - APPLIED SURFACE SCIENCE
注: 认证评论选取于全球各个学术评论平台和社交媒体。

good1 2021-02-02

May I ask how many reviewers are there for your article?

QJS 2021-02-01

Actually, I don't know either. I am also not the corresponding author.

好运护体 2021-01-31

May I ask if an email will be sent to the corresponding author when the status first shows "under review"? Does the corresponding author need to click on a confirmation? Because my status has been under review for a while, and the corresponding author is a teacher, so I haven't dared to ask the teacher.

好运护体 2021-01-31

I'm not sure about the repetition rate either. I didn't see any relevant explanations.

paper好运护体 2021-01-30

May I ask if this journal has any requirements for the plagiarism rate?

paper好运护体 2021-01-30

May I ask if this journal has any specific requirements for plagiarism rate?

好运护体 2021-01-29

Have you received the email for review? Besides sending it to the corresponding author, do you also send it to other authors?

好运护体 2021-01-29

under review: In the process of being evaluated or considered
期望中: As expected

麦子LYL 2021-01-27

I submitted the manuscript using the corresponding author's email, and the "with editor" status was only sent to the corresponding author.

一头牛 2021-01-26

That is because there is no reviewer's consent to review.

good1 2021-01-26

Your review is so fast. Will the editor only send emails to the corresponding author with the status "with editor"?

麦子LYL 2021-01-26

Submitted on January 15th, received with editor on January 16th. I received an email assigning the manuscript to an editor. However, since the 16th, the system status has remained as "under review" and I have not received any email regarding the review process. Can you please explain this situation?

超人姐姐 2021-01-25

How long did the original poster receive it later? My third review has been more than a month and still no news, I'm anxious...

超人姐姐 2021-01-25

How are you doing now, OP? It has been 8 months since I submitted mine, although there were reviewer comments in between, but once I made the changes, there has been no news, and it is still under review...

爱你521 2021-01-23

I don't know if this journal will give a chance to resubmit after revisions.

Silence~雨 2021-01-22

I also got assigned to this editor. How efficient is this editor in handling the tasks? Are there also emails during the external review? Or are emails only sent after the reviewers agree to review the manuscript?

Silence~雨 2021-01-22

At the same time as the editor, you will receive an email. This journal will send emails to the corresponding author for every status.

Silence~雨 2021-01-21

With the editor, the corresponding author will receive an email stating which editor they have been assigned to.

zhaozhao1 2021-01-20

May I ask how to check which editor my manuscript has been assigned to?

Silence~雨 2021-01-20

The article on characterization of metallic materials has been assigned to Aliaksandr S Bandarenka, who specializes in the field of chemical battery capacitors. I'm not sure how it will turn out or if there will be a chance for it to be reviewed. How fast is this editor in handling the process?

Jinshan 2021-01-20

It has been a month since submission with the editor ?
Why hasn't it been reviewed yet?
Should I send an email to ask the editor?

Strive 2021-01-19

It has been more than ten days for me too with the editor.

Strive 2021-01-19

This journal has become so slow, it's been more than ten days with the editor.

LLayf 2021-01-18

Where in the system is the deadline? I can't seem to find it. Could you please provide a specific description? Thank you.

爱吃香菇的姑奶奶 2021-01-18

The general duration for a major repair is two months, and there is a deadline in the system.

LLayf 2021-01-18

How long will the major renovation take? The email the editor sent me didn't mention the deadline. Now it's already vacation, and I can't conduct any experiments either.

zhaozhao1 2021-01-13

It has been 20 days with the editor, but it hasn't been sent for review yet. I'm asking everyone, how long does it generally take for this journal to be sent for review? I'm in a hurry to graduate.

QJS 2021-01-13

submit 2020/9/7
with editor 2020/9/7
under review 2020/9/16
Required Reviews Completed 2020/10/4
under review 2020/10/6
Required Reviews Completed 2020/10/21 Major
Revision submitted 2020/11/19
with editor 2020/11/19
under review 2020/11/22
Required Reviews Completed 2020/12/8
under review 2020/12/10
Required Reviews Completed 2021/1/4 minor
Revision submitted 2021/1/11
with editor 2020/1/11
accept 2020/1/12

QJS 2021-01-13

submit 2020/5/10
Under review 2020/5/14;2020/6/2;2020/6/17;2020/6/20
Required Reviews Completed 2020/7/7 minor revision
Revision submitted 2020/7/22
with editor 2020/7/22
Under review 2020/7/23
Required Reviews Completed 2020/7/30
Accepted 2020/8/2

Find Funding. Review Successful Grants.

Explore over 25,000 new funding opportunities and over 6,000,000 successful grants.

Explore

Become a Peeref-certified reviewer

The Peeref Institute provides free reviewer training that teaches the core competencies of the academic peer review process.

Get Started