5555555 2021-04-08

Some reviewers refuse to review, so we need to find new ones.

laser2018 2021-04-08

Hello, may I kindly ask what does it mean when the "under review" dates have changed four times? Does it indicate that the manuscript was sent to the reviewers and they have provided feedback? I noticed earlier someone mentioned that they were continuously searching for reviewers. Thank you!

Jinshan 2021-04-07

Jeff Terry, this editor has no taste. It has been several months since submission and there hasn't been any feedback. Moreover, we can't even rush him for the manuscript. I feel like he is particularly slow and his character is questionable.

小海11 2021-04-03

The editor I assigned is ZHIGANG WANG.

1233321 2021-04-03

My submission was quite fast, it was reviewed on the same day. However, it has been two months and there is still no result. The status "under review" has changed several times, and I am feeling anxious.

爪子zzZ 2021-04-03

I am too, it has been almost a week since I submitted it, but it hasn't been reviewed yet T T

小海11 2021-04-02

It has been a week since submission, but it has not been reviewed yet!

Jinshan 2021-03-30

I have been waiting for four months and the manuscript is still under review. Oh my goodness, this journal is so slow and incredibly sluggish.

张叔不凶 2021-03-30

I will send you an email to inform you.

yaoyaoyaoyao 2021-03-24

Do all submissions require G A or only the review?

享受简单 2021-03-19

Now it has clearly dropped to Zone 2.

科学搬运工 2021-03-19

Belonging to Zone One, has always been, right?

maxcsu 2021-03-19

Received at Editorial Office: 25 Nov 2020
Article revised: 11 Feb 2021
Article accepted for publication: 3 Mar 2021

tianhui232 2021-03-17

2021.2.13投: Submitted on February 13, 2021
2021.3.9 required reviewers completed: Reviewers' comments were received on March 9, 2021
3.15号 一个中修 一个拒 编辑给拒: On March 15, one reviewer recommended revisions while another rejected the submission
其实意见都很中肯也不用补实验 拒的也只是说机理分析挖掘不够，但是在现有数据上也能挖掘出来: Actually, the comments were all fair and there was no need for additional experiments. The rejection was mainly due to the insufficient analysis and exploration of the mechanism, which could have still been explored using the existing data.
哎 难过 我的第一篇: Sigh, I'm sad. It's my first article.
多磨难: Many hardships.

一凡 2021-03-12

What is your current status?

超人姐姐 2021-03-12

Less than a month after receiving, online.

超人姐姐 2021-03-12

highlight needed

踏踏实实搞科研 2021-03-09

May I ask which district this journal belongs to? My mentor says it belongs to the first district.

科学搬运工 2021-03-07

Jan 04, 2021: Submitted.
Jan 29, 2021: Major revision, two reviewers, one of them provided more than 20 comments, but it wasn't too troublesome, just need to add some data.
Mar 06, 2021: Revision submitted.
Mar 06, 2021: (4 hours later) With editor.
Mar 07, 2021: Accept.
I feel like this journal has always been quite fast in the review process. I have also submitted manuscripts before, but maybe they weren't in-depth enough to be accepted. This journal has certain requirements for the novelty of the articles, it's not easy to get accepted, and its influence has been increasing in recent years. I wish them continued success.

刁民 2021-03-07

I would like to ask if highlighting is required when submitting here?

颁白 2021-03-04

It's so slow with the editor, it's been half a month already. James E. Whitten's editing efficiency is a bit low.

The little snail 2021-03-02

How long online?

good1 2021-02-20

"Required Reviews Completed" means that the necessary evaluations or assessments have been finished or fulfilled. The phrase "变了两次" in Chinese translates to "changed twice" in English.

超人姐姐 2021-02-13

Looking for a reviewer.

麦子LYL 2021-02-12

What situation does it belong to when the date changes multiple times during the under review period? After receiving the review email, the date changed again.

QJS 2021-02-10

There are 5 reviewers, whereas the previous article had 3 reviewers.

QJS 2021-02-10

There are five reviewers, the previous one had three reviewers.

超人姐姐 2021-02-09

2020.05.29 submission; until today, 2021.02.09, received acceptance email after more than 8 months...
2020.05.29 submitted
2020.05.29 under review, the dates changed many times, finally received an email from two people agreeing to review
2020.08.14 major revision, due to the pandemic, only returned to school in September, the revision was delayed for a month, and then changed for nearly a month
2020.10.08 revision submitted
2020.10.08 under review
2020.11.26 minor revision
2020.12.22 revision submitted
2020.12.23 under review
2021.02.08 accepted

东方月初 2021-02-06

submit 2020/12/02
with editor 2020/12/06; edited by Nini Pryds
under review 2020/12/11
under review 2020/12/29
required reviews completed 2021/01/14
major 2021/01/15 reviewer #1 suggests transfer; reviewer #2 minor revisions; major revisions provided by the editor;
revision submitted 2021/01/21
with editor 2021/01/22
under review 2020/01/24
required reviews completed 2020/02/03
accept 2021/02/05; reviewer #1 suggests transfer in the first review, directly accepting in the second review; reviewer #2 suggests minor revisions in the first review, agrees with reviewer #1 in the second review, suggests transfer; editor agrees to accept.

麦子LYL 2021-02-04

Received the email for review on 1.27, will only send it to the corresponding author.