briangao0315 2022-05-12

The review process was indeed slow, going back and forth for a year, but it was finally accepted.

2021-4-30: Submitted
2021-9-15: First major revision
2021-11-23: Second major revision
2022-1-18: Minor revision for the third time
2022-3-15: Minor revision for the fourth time
2022-5-10: Accepted

There were a total of three reviewers. One reviewer accepted the paper after the first review. The other two repeatedly requested higher resolution images (even though the resolution was already ensured in the first review), and one of them repeatedly requested additional references (however, suggested references in the comments were not allowed, so it was not possible to add the specific references requested by the reviewer).

ns51 2022-05-10

May I ask how you see the process of gathering two reviewers' opinions? I have been under review for three months already, and the date has not changed at all.

对不起，该用户昵称已被注册 2022-05-07

Reply to the questions from the two friends above:
1. We have started the external review process now, but it took more than half a month to find two reviewers who accepted the invitation. It is not considered fast.
2. Regarding the friend's misunderstanding about the simultaneous major revision, that article was actually submitted last year. However, during the "ASCO with editor" stage, it was sent back for major revisions. The timing of this event remains the same.

㐒罩 2022-05-05

October 17, 2021 - Submission
January 31, 2022 - Major revision (3 experts, 1 directly accepted, 2 major revisions)
March 11, 2022 - Revised manuscript returned (1 additional expert)
April 30, 2022 - Accepted
The speed this time was very impressive. Although it took 2 months with the editor for the new submission, the external review time was within 2 months.

zl10248 2022-05-03

4.8投 - 4.8 investment
4.9with editor - 4.9 with editor
一个月没有变 - No change for a month
好慢 - So slow

XuanZoong 2022-04-21

What's the status now, brother?

Skycactus 2022-04-21

How did you end up in District 2?

小王1701 2022-04-19

At the same time, I was given 45 days for major revisions for another journal paper. May I ask which journal it is, as the first review was so prompt?

小王1701 2022-04-19

2021.10 Submission
2022.2 Major revision
2022.4 Acceptance
Shortly after submission, it is under review. Reviewer 1 completes the review quickly, and the editor is reminded in December 2021. Major revision is done in February 2022, and it is returned three weeks later. Finally, it is accepted in April 2022.

zmlg 2022-04-09

The translation of "4-9 with editor" into English is "April 9th with editor."

zmlg 2022-04-08

2022-4-8 submission

Deitch 2022-04-08

The first trial lasted nearly two months, which is considered fast. The second trial took three months. As of April 8th, 2022, it has entered the "Decision in Process" stage. Hopefully, it will be accepted. Haha.

9527_yy 2022-04-06

May I ask, how many months did your first trial last? How many reviewers were there?

Deitch 2022-04-06

I have already submitted the manuscript, but the review process is relatively long. The first review required significant revisions, and it has been over three months since the second review. On April 4th, it was updated to "under reviewer" again, which means there might be feedback. I hope they don't assign additional reviewers. I'm exhausted from making revisions.

对不起，该用户昵称已被注册 2022-04-03

I want to complain about how slow this journal is!!! I submitted my paper in mid-January and received an email on New Year's Eve saying that some formatting needed to be adjusted and they sent it back to me. The next day, I made the necessary changes and resubmitted it.

Starting from February 1st, it has been "with editor" the whole time. Meanwhile, another paper of mine in a different journal was given 45 days for major revisions. When there was less than a week left for the deadline of the other paper, ASOC emailed me saying that the editor was preparing to handle my manuscript...

My major revisions are about to be completed, and they are just starting to process it, which means that no one has been handling it for about 40 days...

Well, at least they have started processing it, so I will wait. But now it's already early April, and it is still "with editor."

It has been two and a half months since the first submission, and the editing process seems to have no end in sight...

If it can enter the external review process next and be accepted, that would be some consolation. But if it takes this long and gets rejected, the time wasted really cannot be compensated for.

老怪兽 2022-03-28

In the case where I have been waiting for three months and have written two letters to the editor...

123 2022-03-28

How long has it been since the initial submission with the editor?

xiaowei123456 2022-03-21

100%回去 translates to "100% go back" in English.

Hong91 2022-03-19

Can you please provide some context or explain the abbreviations "if" and "一区"?

Hong91 2022-03-12

My article, with the editor for five months, took eight months to receive the first review comments.

Hong91 2022-02-22

Ten months, finally got hired!

蛋蛋鸭 2022-02-22

After 4 revisions and 18 months, finally hired.

Hong91 2022-02-15

I am too, after the second review, the decision is still in progress, and a few days later the decision is rescinded. What the heck is going on? It has been exactly ten months from submission to now.

Anticimin 2022-02-08

The submission has been under review for over two months, and the decision process took three days. Suddenly, it was changed to "decision rescinded," which scared me. I hope it won't be rejected.

xiaowei123456 2022-02-08

Will definitely return to District One, where the quality is guaranteed.

㐒罩 2022-02-07

Is there any hope for this journal to return to the first zone of the Chinese Academy of Sciences this year?

吃鸡肉的熊猫 2022-02-04

Record of the submission process:
08 Nov 2021 Initial Date Submitted
31 Jan 2022 Under Review
This is my first time submitting to this journal, and it took three months to find reviewers after the submission... Hopefully, I'll have good luck.

跑哥 2022-02-01

After one and a half years of experience, I finally got hired. There were four reviewers and they had a lot of opinions, which greatly improved the quality of the paper.

handsome520 2022-01-18

It has been over a month since I submitted, and it is still in the hands of the editors. Is anyone in the same situation? Has it not passed the initial review yet?

Dream123456 2021-12-28

It has been almost 2 years for me, with reviewers in between. Now the final reviewer's opinion is here, waiting for the editor's decision. It's taking too long.