风雨潇潇 2023-01-03

It has been two months already. I've sent two reminder letters and even changed the editor, but still unable to enter the "under review" status. I feel like withdrawing the submission and getting angry...

科研小虫子 2022-12-22

My application is not under review, it is directly "Awaiting Decision." I feel like this means it has been rejected, but why haven't you rejected it yet? Why are you dragging it out like this?

gogofly 2022-12-22

Brother, I have been with the editor for two months, and the first review took 8 months.

;ohas1949 2022-12-20

Indeed, ASOC likes to add additional reviewers during the process.

;ohas1949 2022-12-15

In the third round, I encountered the same additional reviewers. I give up. There are three reviewers in each round, and new ones are added when the previous ones have no objections. Now, I have dealt with five reviewers. Speechless.

EleaM Josen Haplacg 2022-12-13

It has been almost one and a half months and it is still "with editor". The editor probably hasn't processed the manuscript yet. Compared to other journals, the editing process for this journal seems slower.

XXXXXXL 2022-12-11

It has been a month and still with the editor ......

风雨潇潇 2022-12-11

Brother, is your paper under review? Mine has also been submitted for a month, still with the editor.

JinNiu666 2022-12-10

What content should be added if the scope is not appropriate? I would like to ask, thank you.

dtxh 2022-12-06

I am the same... Just wanted to ask, how are you doing now, brother?

dtxh 2022-12-06

I am also like this... just want to ask, brother, what happened to you in the end?

dtxh 2022-12-04

I'd like to ask which email address is used for submission reminders?

EleaM Josen Haplacg 2022-12-03

It has been a month since I submitted, but it is still with the editor and there has been no progress. Does XDM know about it? Does XDM take a month for review? Thank you.

fengqh 2022-11-21

Is this journal generally slow this year? I submitted my article in 2021 and it is still under review. It's too slow, isn't it?

gggzh 2022-11-20

Can I choose not to submit the code when I submit it again?

dtxh 2022-11-16

Thank you, I just found out that Elsevier has customer service. I just asked customer service, they said only one person has returned the review comments and I have to find another reviewer.

JeremyLau 2022-11-16

Tracking the review status is done simultaneously with the external review. I only discovered the change to the external review status when I entered the system after receiving the push notification email with the link. If you haven't received the link, you can contact customer service to inquire about the external review status. The chat service is available in both Chinese and English, but recently, there has been difficulty connecting with English-speaking customer service. You can try reaching out to Chinese-speaking customer service instead.

dtxh 2022-11-15

My submission has been Under Review since September 22nd. At that time, I asked the corresponding author if they had received the link, so I wanted to ask how long it took for you to receive it after it was Under Review.

JeremyLau 2022-11-15

After external review, a tracking link will be sent to the communication email. If you haven't received this link, then you can only consult customer service to inquire about the status of the external review.

caizihui 2022-11-15

I also applied in August, but I didn't receive the tracking link. May I ask if your tracking link was sent by the journal or did you ask the editor for it yourself?

JeremyLau 2022-11-14

The external audit tracking link is this year's service in Aisville. You can try asking customer service if the submission system is still under external audit status. It has been a long time already.

handsome520 2022-11-11

Hello! May I ask how to track the status of an article that was not provided with a tracking link by the editor? Or how to inquire about the tracking link? It has been submitted for over 10 months.

handsome520 2022-11-11

The editor did not send an email with a tracking link.

JeremyLau 2022-11-11

Does your reviewer agree to review it? I don't dare to rush the submission either, I can only wait patiently.

小鸣是 2022-11-11

Both of us have the same progress, we're still "Under Review" until now.

JeremyLau 2022-11-11

Translated into English:

Submitted to Journal: Aug 21, 2022
With Editor: Aug 23, 2022
With Editor: Sep 10, 2022
Under Review: Sep 19, 2022
Under Review: Sep 29, 2022
The tracking link shows that no reviewer has agreed to review yet. It's so difficult to wait. The editor hasn't continued to invite reviewers either.

小鸣是 2022-11-10

My review has also been a long time, about 3 months already. It has been under review all this time and I am afraid I will miss the application deadline for the scholarship.

;ohas1949 2022-11-08

The following text translates to English as: "...DIP is the normal process. The deputy editor will provide the opinions to the editor, and the editor will make the final decision."

Xiaohongqi 2022-11-08

I want to know if I'm already doomed because my first-instance decision is in process. I heard that someone in Louisville got their first-instance decision rejected. I'm seeking an expert's criticism on my situation.

glorypan 2022-11-03

I'm almost done too. Can I send an email to remind them?