土壤小菜鸡 2022-02-23

To be honest, the journal Plant Soils itself is only at the level of Zone 2, so the poster is deceiving themselves. Just take a look at the articles published in the past five years and see what level they are at. Many low-quality articles can be published, which can only mean that the editorial board's standards for review are too low. Even a second-year graduate student from our research group submitted an article to Plant Soils for review. It was initially rejected by Catena and the overall environmental review, but strangely it was accepted for review by Plant Soils, which clearly indicates a problem.

oceanography 2022-02-11

I'm just curious, there are indeed many 10-point water journals related to materials, energy, and the like. Since your research direction is environmental ecology and soil science, we can also be considered colleagues. It's not a bad idea to mention the 10-point water journal and let everyone take a look. There is no need to excessively praise or criticize it, so as not to make outsiders laugh.

积极努力-科研顺利 2022-02-10

This is my first submission to the "Plant and Soil" journal. Based on my experience, I would like to express my personal opinions in a one-sided, serious manner. Please note that these are just my own views, and I hope they will not be criticized. My impression of the "Plant and Soil" journal is that it is "professional" and "solid". If you have an article published in this journal, no one will criticize it as being of low quality. Personally, I believe that compared to many other journals that are considered to be of low quality, even rated as "10 out of 10" in terms of being poor, traditional well-established journals, especially in the field of ecology, are more widely recognized by peers, regardless of having a significantly lower impact factor. They leave a good impression and receive positive feedback. I hope that these well-established ecology journals will become stronger and stronger!

Jing Huang 2021-12-15

Overall, it was very fast. After the major overhaul, they were directly hired. The old-established journal is holding on. Hopefully, it can return to the top tier.

刘先生1895 2021-07-28

I submitted it in February 2021, and got the result in just over a month. They requested some modifications. However, I went back relatively late, about a month later, and made some minor edits before being accepted.

椭圆三向箔 2021-04-15

Now Chinese people's manuscripts are flooding. In order to limit the quantity of Chinese manuscripts, they have started to reject or not review them.

博物馆的猫 2021-04-12

I want to know what the situation is when I can't find a reviewer. Can I urge them at this time? It has been two months already. Please let me know.

博物馆的猫 2021-04-12

I want to know what's going on with not being able to find a reviewer. Can we follow up at this point? It has already been two months.