学术狗 2021-03-23

Submitted in mid-October 2020.
Received 20 comments from three reviewers after about a month and a half.
Revised and resubmitted after one month.
Received feedback in February 2021, reviewers were generally satisfied, major revisions were made regarding grammar.
Accepted in mid-March 2021.
Overall, the process took about four months.

taylor1993 2021-03-18

None of the ND submission options recommend a reviewer. Don't mislead others.

tw686 2021-03-12

From the experience of submitting articles, it is still a decent magazine with responsible editors and relatively diligent reviewers. The reason for rejection was that I did not recommend a reviewer, and one of the reviewers had difficulty understanding the mathematical expressions in the article, while the other reviewer's recommended revisions were clearly biased. However, both the editors and reviewers were very polite.

纳维 2021-02-22

In our field of mechanics, we have a good reputation. Nowadays, the peer review process has become very strict, with 3-5 reviewers, and it is difficult to get published if even one disagrees. Sometimes, there is even a second round of review. It is one of the journals highly recognized in the field of nonlinear dynamics.

刘雷 2021-01-31

Now it is relatively difficult compared to before, as one cannot publish with just one rejection from four reviewers in the field of mechanics, which is highly recognized in journals.

kris说你还可以 2021-01-28

The text translates to: "It has been three months since I submitted it in November last year, and there is still no news. You are very quick with reviewing it, huh?"