志强者，事竟成 2022-08-16

The progress of the manuscript review is as follows:
2021/08/03 - Submitted to the journal
2021/08/28 - Under review
2021/11/28 - Required reviews completed
2022/01/11 - Decision in process
2022/01/17 - Revised and reconsidered
2022/02/11 - With editor
2022/03/11 - Under review
2022/04/19 - Required reviews completed
2022/04/19 - Decision in process
2022/05/08 - Accept with minor revision
2022/05/14 - With editor
2022/05/22 - Under review
2022/07/01 - Required reviews completed
2022/07/07 - Decision in process
2022/07/12 - Accepted
2022/07/26 - Online

imsyz 2022-08-14

2021.12.20 - Submitted to journal
2021.12.21 - With editor
2021.12.22 - Editor invited
2022.1.09 - With editor
2022.2.1 - Under review
2022.3.26 - Required Reviews Completed
2022.4.24 - With editor
2022.4.25 - Editor invited
2022.4.25 - With editor
2022.5.23 - Under review
2022.6.09 - Under review
2022.08.02 - Required Reviews Completed
2022.08.13 - Accept

The review process is average, but it was a bit challenging to find reviewers due to the specific topic. Each stage took a considerable amount of time. The suggestions provided by the reviewers were very good, and after the first revision, the paper was accepted directly in the second review.

小蜜蜂2018 2022-08-10

May I ask what is the current status of your second review?

小蜜蜂2018 2022-08-10

The second trial has lasted for a month and a half, and the outcome is unknown.

agrichron 2022-08-09

Equivalent to major repairs, not a complete re-investment.

Skycactus 2022-08-07

It's like this, recently I found that the publishing editor did a rough job in transferring the format after the manuscript was submitted. More attention is needed during proofreading. However, communication with them is relatively smooth, and any problems that arise during the proofreading stage can be resolved directly, so it's still acceptable.

llzhao 2022-08-04

2022/01/19 submit to the journal
2022/04/14 revise and reconsider
2022/05/24 article revised
2022/07/25 decision in process
2022/08/03 accept

The first review took 3 months, and the second review took 2 months, which is slightly slower than the average duration. This is because the system now provides real-time tracking of the manuscript processing progress. It can be seen that the longer time for the first review was mainly due to one invited reviewer who did not agree to review, so the editor had to find a third reviewer. The longer time for the second review was mainly because one reviewer took about 6 weeks to complete the review, while the other reviewer was much more efficient and resolved all issues within three days, agreeing to accept the article directly.

Overall, the review comments were reasonable and professional, not as some places claimed to be of low quality. Finally, I wish myself and everyone else a successful research and acceptance of their papers!

tzwy 2022-08-04

I have fulfilled my vow. After 511 days of reviewing, the first round took one month, the second round took five months, and the third round took ten months, finally it was accepted.
Wishing everyone good luck~

shuyupiaopiao 2022-08-01

It has been one week since my Required Reviews were completed, and I have already been waiting for five months. Should I remind them about my situation?

shuyupiaopiao 2022-08-01

It has been one week since my Required Reviews Completed. Should I remind them about it? It has already been five months since I submitted.

一切顺利啊 2022-07-27

Classmate, can you share the detailed progress, please? Thank you!

小巢 2022-07-27

7/26 online translates to "July 26th online."

lalalzz 2022-07-24

Is there a requirement for the number of pages in the manuscript? I noticed that most of the accepted ones are 12 pages or more, but my initial draft is currently 9 pages. Will this have an impact?

一撇一捺 2022-07-22

DIP is estimated to be unfortunate.

你喜欢吃凤梨吗 2022-07-19

Just invested on July 19, 2022.

llzhao 2022-07-16

The time for submitting the modifications is almost the same, but it has been nearly two months and the second review has not been completed yet... May I ask if the second review has been completed on your end?

llzhao 2022-07-16

Replied to the wrong floor...

llzhao 2022-07-16

The modifications were submitted around the same time, but the second review has not been completed yet. May I ask if the second review has been completed on your end?

等待 2022-07-13

Hey buddy, may I ask on which date specifically did you submit your contribution?

等待 2022-07-13

Hey buddy, may I ask on what date did you submit your contribution?

科研渣渣5555. 2022-07-13

Rejected after applying, leaving with brothers.

小巢 2022-07-13

2021/08/03 Submitted to the journal
2021/08/28 Under Review
2021/11/24 Under Review
2021/11/28 Required Reviews Completed
2022/01/11 Decision in Process
2022/01/17 Revise and Reconsidered
2022/02/11 With Editor
2022/03/11 Under Review
2022/04/19 Required Reviews Completed
2022/04/19 Decision in Process
2022/05/08 Accept with minor revision
2022/05/14 With Editor
2022/05/22 Under Review
2022/07/01 Required Reviews Completed
2022/07/07 Decision in Process
2022/07/12 Accept

Translation:
2021/08/03 Submitted to the journal
2021/08/28 Under Review
2021/11/24 Under Review
2021/11/28 Required Reviews Completed
2022/01/11 Decision in Process
2022/01/17 Revise and Reconsidered
2022/02/11 With Editor
2022/03/11 Under Review
2022/04/19 Required Reviews Completed
2022/04/19 Decision in Process
2022/05/08 Accept with minor revision
2022/05/14 With Editor
2022/05/22 Under Review
2022/07/01 Required Reviews Completed
2022/07/07 Decision in Process
2022/07/12 Accept

小巢 2022-07-13

It took nearly a year, and finally it was accepted on 2022/07/12.

杨小小cb 2022-07-13

In the past 5 months, from submission to acceptance.
2022-02-16 submitted
2022-02-17 with editor
2022-02-19 under review
2022-02-26 under review
2022-03-24 required reviews completed
2022-03-29 revise and reconsider
2022-05-07 submitted revision
2022-05-07 with editor
2022-05-16 under review
2022-05-24 required reviews completed
2022-06-28 decision in process
2022-07-12 accept

kuailexingqiu123 2022-07-12

Second review, Decision in Process, it has been almost 20 days. Has anyone encountered this situation? Can I send an email to follow up?

aada 2022-07-12

Hello, how many days does it take to get the results after transferring?

aada 2022-07-11

Hello, hello. After you transferred, did you receive the transfer to that journal?

nyg 2022-07-05

(这阶段是指论文正处于审稿过程中)

nyg 2022-07-05

Jun 25, with editor
Jun 28, with editor
Not yet under review for second review.

kenramzes 2022-07-03

Jul 01, 2022 With Editor