FPX 2022-10-17

Posted on October 14, 2022
With Editor on October 15, 2022

letpubbird 2022-09-23

I applied in June last year, and now it has been three months since the minor repairs, but there is still no result.

kenramzes 2022-09-23

The submission experience this time was very good. It was submitted at the end of June and accepted in mid-September. I will share the process here and wish everyone a successful acceptance!

Jun 30, 2022 Submitted to journal
Jul 01, 2022 With editor
Jul 06, 2022 With Editor
Jul 10, 2022 Under Review
Jul 14, 2022 Under Review
Jul 26, 2022 Required Reviews Completed
Aug 07, 2022 Decision in Process
Aug 08, 2022 Reconsider and Revise
Aug 20, 2022 With Editor
Aug 24, 2022 Under Review
Sep 12, 2022 Decision in Process
Sep 13, 2022 Decision in Process
Sep 16, 2022 Accept

plz 2022-09-23

Generally, editors ask you to submit whatever they want you to submit. Since I don't have many changes, I directly mark red modifications on the original manuscript. Finally, I submit a version with changes marked and a clean version.

plz 2022-09-23

Submit whatever the editor asks you to submit. I have made only a few changes, so I will directly mark the modifications in red on the original manuscript. Finally, submit a version with changes marked and a clean version.

scikk 2022-09-21

Hello, may I ask what else is needed for the revision besides replying to the review comments, modifying the PDF, providing the source file, and author information? Do you need a revised PDF with a comparison between the old and new versions?

plz 2022-09-16

It is also possible that the reviewer's comments have returned, and it is required that all reviewer's comments have been completed.

plz 2022-09-16

All the dates are mentioned above, oh. The first time with the editor was more than a month later before it went under review.

biAli 2022-09-16

2022/08/30 - Submit to journal
2022/09/03 - With editor
2022/09/16 - Transfer pending

小蜜蜂2018 2022-09-12

May I ask if the time of Status Date has been updated recently, but the Current Status is still under review? I'm wondering what the situation is. It has been two months in the review process. Could it be that the reviewer has been changed again?

biAli 2022-09-12

Classmate, how long did you take for the first time with the editor?

biAli 2022-09-09

Classmate, how long have you been investing?

plz 2022-09-06

One revision, lasting over a year, finally got accepted. Sharing the status:

2021.08.12 submitted to journal
2021.08. with editor
2021.09.12 under review
2021.10.07 editor invited
2021.10.17 under review
2021.11.15 under review
2022.3.24 Required Reviews Completed
2022.4.3 revision

2022.5.13 submitted
2022.5.16 editor invited
2022.5.30 under review
2022.7.20 under review
2022.8.24 Required Reviews Completed
2022.8.29 decision in process
2022.9.4 accept

风之小翼 2022-09-05

The text translates to: "It has been two weeks since submission and it is still in the editor invited phase. The slowness is real."

nyg 2022-09-05

Will this state still be sent for review, or will the editor decide to accept it after minor revisions?

nyg 2022-09-05

Will this state be sent for review again, or will the editor directly accept it after seeing it?

nyg 2022-09-05

Will this status be sent for review or will the editor accept it directly after seeing it?

nyg 2022-09-05

Will this state be sent for review or is it enough for the editor to have a look?

biAli 2022-09-04

2022/08/30 Submit to journal
2022/09/03 With Editor

Translation:
2022/08/30 - Submit to journal
2022/09/03 - With Editor

风痕 2022-09-02

Does it affect if I choose an editor for the returned draft without knowing the editor of the first review?

小蜜蜂2018 2022-09-01

The second review has been under review for over two months with no news yet.

biAli 2022-08-31

Just submitted, the official website says the first review takes about a month... but seeing everyone being so slow, I feel like I've been cheated...

6t 2022-08-31

Two months is too long, wuwuwu.

nyg 2022-08-30

I didn't dare to urge, let's see the situation in the next few days.

6t 2022-08-29

Wow, it's been so long. So, did you remind or urge?

nyg 2022-08-27

Like me, mine has been almost two months. It changed from this to "under review" again, and I'm about to cry.

6t 2022-08-27

It has been more than 20 days since my second review required reviews were completed. Should I remind them?

Hellen 2022-08-25

No need, it's up to you.

风之小翼 2022-08-25

May I ask, after submitting the manuscript, is it necessary for each co-author to confirm the automatically sent email from the system?

6t 2022-08-20

Do I need to remind them that it has been half a month since my second review of required reviews completed?