suerxz 2022-12-06

Record it down. Submit on 12.6.

大脸猫是卷王 2022-12-05

One reviewer said that my SOTA method has insufficient experiments and the method is not novel enough.
Another reviewer asked me to cite his paper.
The comments from the AE are neither strong nor weak. Well, I'll give up and submit elsewhere.

dingyun 2022-12-02

I don't know, I revised it and submitted it to somewhere else.

dingyun 2022-12-02

I don't know, it feels a bit inexplicable.

Jh_SCUT 2022-12-02

I feel like this should be for minor repairs or major repairs, why was it rejected?

yuyuyou 2022-12-01

2022.11.27 submitted to the journal
2022.11.29 with the editor
2022.12.7 rejected

Translated:
2022.11.27 - Submitted to the journal
2022.11.29 - Under review with the editor
2022.12.7 - Rejected

JN6666666666666 2022-11-30

May I ask which month did you submit the contribution?

JN6666666666666 2022-11-30

May I ask which month did you submit your contribution?

Mrs.lemon 2022-11-29

Blocked. First submission, one reminder for review, email informed that one reviewer did not submit comments. Within two days, it was rejected. The first reviewer was responsible and provided great help in revising the manuscript. The second reviewer, who delayed and provided comments at the end, probably received a reminder from the editor before giving some perfunctory comments. Every comment was perfunctory and lacked specificity, just for the sake of rejection. Then the editor's rejection reason was roughly: we have many manuscripts and don't need yours.

I was not satisfied because the comments from the first reviewer were not difficult to address, not a major issue. The second reviewer was unprofessional and perfunctory. So, I made the revisions and replied, resubmitted, but it was rejected again within two days. The reason for rejection was that the editor believed there were no major changes. Haha, there weren't many areas that needed modification in the suggestions provided, and I answered and made revisions to each comment seriously, including the perfunctory reviewer's comments. Maybe they just have a lot of manuscripts and don't need mine. Both the reviewers and the editor are disappointing. I don't believe the editor couldn't see through the whole process of the second reviewer's empty words and perfunctory attitude.

dingyun 2022-11-28

The submission time and the results are unexpectedly similar, but I am confused by the reviewers' comments. One reviewer only asked me to add references, while another directly stated that the work can be published without any major changes. The last reviewer provided numerous suggestions, and as a result, the work was rejected. Now I am considering whether to revise the manuscript and resubmit it.

dingyun 2022-11-28

The submission was rejected, but the reviewers' comments have left me confused. One reviewer only asked me to add references, while another directly stated that the work can be published without any major changes. The last reviewer provided many suggestions, but in the end, the submission was rejected. Is it still necessary to submit it again?

海洋 2022-11-23

May I ask you a question? I have submitted my manuscript, but another teacher is the corresponding author. I have submitted it to him for review, but neither the corresponding author nor any of the authors have received a confirmation email. Is this how the journal operates? Will they not send a confirmation email or is there a delay? Thank you~~

JN6666666666666 2022-11-23

Hello, can you please always work with the editor and not submit it for external review?

知则 2022-11-23

In October, I submitted it, but did not choose OA. In November, it was rejected, but no reason was given. It was not even reviewed at all.

Jh_SCUT 2022-11-22

neurocomputing? It is not open source.

ZXXXX0305 2022-11-22

Is this journal open source?

Jh_SCUT 2022-11-17

2022.8.19 submitted
2022.8.23 with editor
2022.9.4 editor invited
2022.9.8 under review
2022.10.3 required reviews completed
2022.10.20 under review
2022.10.28 required reviews completed
2022.11.16 transfer pending

During the review process, there were two instances of "required reviews completed." I'm not sure why. On November 16th, the editor sent an email informing me of rejection, but then the editorial department sent another email asking me to submit to another journal. After agreeing, the system status changed to "Submission Transferred" instead of "reject." This was my first submission to this journal, so I'm not sure why. Lastly, I would like to ask everyone if, in this situation, I can still submit to Neurocomputing after revising the article based on the reviewers' feedback, or if being rejected means I cannot submit to this journal again?

MM_gdbt 2022-11-16

The initial trial results of the July case, which was submitted at the beginning of July, were indeed a bit slow. It took nearly three months until the end of September.

6t 2022-11-14

I only had one month for the first trial. I submitted it in May.

风之小翼 2022-11-12

I submitted in August, and the first review is not yet completed. Is there anyone who also submitted during the same period and can share their progress?

sadasfasd 2022-11-07

5000 plus, I feel that there are very few people who have voted.

JN6666666666666 2022-11-03

Excuse me, is there a large amount of submissions now? May I ask approximately how many submission numbers there are?

等待 2022-11-03

2022.6.13 Submitted
2022.6.15 With Editor
2022.6.22 Editor Invited
2022.6.24 With Editor
2022.6.28 Under Review
2022.7.16 Required Reviews Completed
2022.7.22 Required Reviews Completed
2022.7.26 Decision in Process
2022.7.29 Revise and Reconsider
2022.8.15 With Editor (Resubmission)
2022.8.19 With Editor
2022.8.31 Under Review
2022.10.11 Required Reviews Completed
2022.10.14 Required Reviews Completed
2022.10.20 Decision in Process
2022.11.1 Decision in Process
2022.11.3 Accept

等待 2022-10-30

with editor represents that the associate editor has not been assigned yet, please wait patiently.

等待 2022-10-30

May I ask what is the current status? My "decision in process" status has been going on for a full 10 days.

等待 2022-10-30

May I ask what the current status is? My second review "decision in process" has been in this state for a full 10 days.

yhao98 2022-10-26

Just submitted, not sure when there will be a result.

大璐璐 2022-10-26

Hello, OP. Where can I see the real-time tracking of the manuscript processing progress? Is it in the system's status or is there something else? Because I feel like you know it in detail, but I have only received a "with editor" status for a long time after submitting. Thank you for your response.

FPX 2022-10-25

Rejected, from submission to rejection took half a month. It is advised to submit elsewhere.

FPX 2022-10-20

Status on the 20th is still with editor.